3 ms·
I wouldn't presume to question Nicholas Kristof's awareness of world and humanitarian affairs, given that his career is so focused on it. And I applaud what I p
by danso 9y ago
I wouldn't presume to question Nicholas Kristof's awareness of world and humanitarian affairs, given that his career is so focused on it. And I applaud what I perceive to be his intent, to remind all the folks (mostly east coast media folks) that there is a world beyond Trump's tweets, and that it is not all crisis.
But I'm unclear how he can say 2017 is the best year in human history. Is it merely an argument of numbers? That since hundreds of thousands more people every day have electricity and water, that the net amount of suffering has surely decreased?
To put it another way, what kind of disaster would have to happen in 2017 for us to say that 2017 was worse than 2016? According to his numbers, nearly 100 million people get access to water and electricity every year (300K per day). If we had got into a nuclear war that wiped out 1M people, could we still see stay that 2017 was, all things considered, a better year?
Last year, the UN said the Yemen/Africa crisis was the worst humanitarian crisis since WW2. That sounds like something that would disqualify 2017 from being considered as "probably the very best year in the long history of humanity." Unless it is the case that we had far fewer wars and crises elsewhere in 2017? Is that the case?
Edit: forgot the link https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/11/world-faces-worst-humanitarian-crisis-since-1945-says-un-official https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/11/world-faces-wo...
- oconnor663 9y ago> Last year, the UN said the Yemen/Africa crisis was the worst humanitarian crisis since WW2. Looking that up real quick, it sounds like it's put 20 million people at risk of starvation, which is very bad. But the Great Leap Forward in China had an actual death toll (not just a risk estimate) that was even larger than that, 1958-62.
- danso 9y agoSure, but the OP isn't saying that 2017 was better than the 1950s, he says he believes it to be "probably the very best year in the long history of humanity". Which means it's better than 2016, 2015, 2012, etc. Is it possible all those other years had similar continent-level crises that make them less bad than 2017? I get that his larger point that Western suffering is a small part of the equation. But it seems to me there was a lot of suffering elsewhere too. Not Holocaust or Spanish Flu levels of suffering, just maybe enough to make it less great of a year than others this decade.