6 ms·
What use is this data? How does knowing the drivers o2 saturation after a crash change any procedure? It isn't as if they are ever going to leave him in a wre
by sandworm101 9y ago
What use is this data? How does knowing the drivers o2 saturation after a crash change any procedure? It isn't as if they are ever going to leave him in a wreck for a second longer than needed. He is comming out asap and his 02 measured immediately no matter. Will they pull a driver from a race should his o2 appear to drop? I doubt it.
- JshWright 9y agoKnowing the patient is critically injured would likely increase the acceptable level of risk to the rescue personnel responsible for the extrication. It might also change how the incident is handled on track. Generally F1 prioritizes keeping the race going (deploying a safety car only if absolutely necessary). Knowing a driver is critically injured would likely trigger a "red flag" stop to the race, allowing rescue personnel unrestricted access to the track.
- sandworm101 9y agoReally? They are going to move slower on a trapped driver because his o2 sensor says he is still breathing? No. They are going to move at 100% towards any and every trapped driver. And once out of the car his gloves will be stripped and a standard sensor applied, one that can be read directly.
- JshWright 9y agoF1 cars are dangerous things. F1 tracks even moreso (when the race it still taking place). They are going to move very slowly and deliberately, checking and double checking all the safety features of the car. They are going to be very careful moving the driver, to avoid potentially exacerbating an injury. If, on the other hand, they know the driver is dead in a couple minutes without intervention, some of those steps are going to get skipped (that's what I meant by the "acceptable level of risk" changing). For what it's worth, I'm a firefighter/paramedic, and have cut many people out of (ordinary) cars over the past decade or so.
- vvillena 9y agoNo, that's not how they work. Emergency personnel can get the driver out extremely quickly if need be, but if there's no immediate risk they will work slowly to avoid further injury.
- alistairSH 9y agoThey are going to move at 100% towards any and every trapped driver. Nope. Not true. Track personnel are trained to be cautious. They shouldn't be on a live track unless absolutely necessary. Anything that increases their ability to discern "absolutely necessary" from "not necessary" is a good thing. [Former amateur race car driver]
- blauditore 9y ago> It isn't as if they are ever going to leave him in a wreck for a second longer than needed. Actually, the goal is generally not to pull a driver out of a wreck as fast as possible. For example, if the driver has some broken bones (especially spinal ones), rescuers might want to act carefully to avoid any further damage if the circumstances allow that. But if the wreck is catching fire or the driver is in danger of suffocating (as potentially detectable with those gloves), they'll have to act faster and "trade" potential additional injury for saving the driver's life.
- sandworm101 9y agoAnd they need/will trust the gloves to tell them if the wreck is or isnt on fire? Fire and/or danger of suffocation happens long before anything these gloves could detect. I know that this data is medically interesting but cannot see how it could impact actual procedure trackside. Someone will be at the scene asap regardless of data. They will check for fire and breathing issues. If either driver isnt talking or car on fire, driver is comming out now. After out, or sometimes before, gloves are off and other sensors applied. Decisions such as the use of a spinal turn on danger, not medical data: always a spinal unless car about to explode. I dont see the case for this data as it only means something long after more apparant dangers have already dictated decisions. (In my work i regularly draft ERPs for aviation crashes, a similar senario. I just last month completed a hypoxia course in a hypobaric chamber where o2 sat was a very big deal)
- avdmerwe 9y agoThis will indeed not slow down anyone's initial response, but it will hopefully give us an insight into what happened before anyone gets there, or while the rescue evolves. We would have really liked to know what happened while we were underway to the scene in this scenario: https://youtu.be/QOM5SzxEFGU?t=1m50s https://youtu.be/QOM5SzxEFGU?t=1m50s And a driver under a few 100kg of Tecpro barriers takes a while to get to: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJN-b-ovkQQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJN-b-ovkQQ
- 9y ago
- avdmerwe 9y agoThis is meant to serve as an extra data point during the decision-making process when we first get to a driver, especially when we don't have immediate access to them. As other posters have pointed out, we try to minimise additional risk to the driver and rescue workers as much as possible. Pulling a car out of the barriers quickly could potentially injure a driver that was perfectly fine. The data will also be useful in post-analysis, as much of the time it can take up to 2 minutes for us to reach a driver at some circuits. If we can see that a driver wasn't moving and had low blood sats, that could be useful info when deciding on further treatment/imaging/etc. I drive the F1 Medical Car, and came up with this system together with my colleague Dr. Ian Roberts, and have spent the past 2 years developing it. Any questions, ask!
- TallGuyShort 9y agoI never seem to be able to think of intelligent questions when I suddenly have a rare opportunity to ask someone cool - so may I just say it's really awesome to see you commenting about this on HN?
- avdmerwe 9y agoPersonally, I think it's really cool that anyone would post this on HN or even have questions about it!
- sandworm101 9y agoThen your guys must be operating in a much lower energy environment than mine. In an aviation crash my driver (air crew) will be inside a mess of aluminum, high voltage wires, fuel and burning carbon fiber. Extraction is the first priority. Unless the pilot is talking and can give a great reason to stay, he is comming out. It isnt so much for his safety but for the five or more rescuers who dont want to be caught in the inevitable fireball. Our SAR guys are backing away from even checking vitals in situ, let alone o2 sat. In the extreme, ejection seat aircraft often have instructions for activating the canopy/seat on the ground, if necessary to "extract" a pilot. A twice-broken back is better than burned to death.