3 ms·
On one, this is honorable and impressive. On the other, why hoard so much? Could he have been at least slightly more generous all along? Wouldn't that, done ea
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
On one, this is honorable and impressive.
On the other, why hoard so much? Could he have been at least slightly more generous all along? Wouldn't that, done earlier, create a positive sooner? A positive that could have been compiling social compound interest (if you will)?
I under the rules of the game (i.e., capitalism). That doesn't mean you have to buy all in to those rules. There are (personal) alternatives.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoIf IKEA can generate a higher return on capital than generally available, it could make more sense to accumulate and compound the money for as long as possible so he can donate a bigger amount later. Hard to quantitatively compare to the utility of early philanthropy.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoCapital? Maybe. Provided IKEA doesn't go tits up. What I'm suggesting is a form of portfolio diversity. And who's to say that if you invest in NPO X today that the "ROI" won't be significant5 or 10 years from now. Why not try to put a value on lives saved, impacted, etc.? So yeah. Use Capital as your only measuring stick and you're correct. But the real truth is, there's more to life than Capital. But of course the capitalist doesn't want you to know this. Note: I'm not suggesting better (or worse), just different. There are alternative measurements.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoI agree that there's much more to life than capital/money. What I'm saying is its very very hard to put a value on life saved/changed and compare that to money. Is donating $1M to an NPO distributing malaria vaccines today better or worse than donating $2M worth of malaria vaccines in 2 years? Who knows? How would you even begin to compare those 2 scenarios? You'd have to translate the subjective costs of being sick, costs of a life, all the uncertainties around effectiveness of the vaccine, uncertainties around how well the NPO uses its capital etc. into a dollar value to compare.. there is no right answer there, its just too uncertain. So if he did a similar calculation and decided more money later is better for the world than less money now, well I can't fault him because that calculation is infinitely complex. Seems like you are saying donating say 1% every year is better than donating 0 and then 100% at the end, but it is very hard to tell.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI don't want this to sound snark / too direct but... Bill Gates must have some sort of formula. My sense is also, some of that formula is what he can contribute. You can't do much contributing when you're dead :) Nothing of value is easy. And big progress / big change takes (big) time. The longer you wait the more difficult it is to move the needle. My question is kinda like an A/B test. That is, instead of waiting til the race was over, what would the impact had been had some of this started 20 years ago?
- ChrisLomont 9y ago>why hoard so much? Nothing was hoarded. IKEA is a private company, and the founder likely held a lot of that ownership. He didn't simply grab people's cash and hide it in a box. To turn that ownership value into cash so he would not "hoard so much" would be to turn ownership (and hence direction) of IKEA over to others. To sell ownership would mean others would turn cash into ownership, so there's really no net gain/loss in terms of "hoarding," only a change in assets. He decided to keep IKEA independent. His value represents the value IKEA provides to others and is not taking away from society.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoBy defintion, more than you need is hoarding. He could have distributed (read: invested via donations and grants) more sooner. Why wait til death? Unless, there's some personal "quirk" (e.g., hoarding) prevented him from doing so? As they say, ya can't take it with you. Why not go with your bag lighter? Why not go you're leaving with seeds planted and growing? Why risk some unforseen legal snafu? Etc.
- ChrisLomont 9y ago>He could have distributed (read: invested via donations and grants) more sooner. The only way he could have done that is to sell the company, and using your definition, as soon as the company was worth more than he needed personally, he would have to sell it to not be a hoarder. I'm pretty sure in that case the company would never have grown to what it is, as there's ample studies showing that founders, who know a business, provide more growth than letting outsiders run a company, when averaged across all companies. I'd suspect this is the case for this person also. So your plan would have resulted in less total worth provided to humanity. And, as I pointed out above, the only way to realize that value is to sell ownership - so now you've removed some cash from someone else to get ownership, given that cash to this owner, for a net zero change in cash available for society, with a likely less value add over time. This is why these ideas do not work economically. Warren Buffet is a good example of this - he was far better at allocating capital than most (perhaps anyone), and when he dies the world will see that worth transferred to charity. Had he constantly handed it over earlier to less efficient capital allocators, there would have been less growth, since others are likely far less capable than he was/is, and there would be less total for the planet.