4 ms·
Oh nice, if he thought he could use the money better, then sure, please carry on not paying taxes. Can I do the same? Or is that a privilege reserved for the me
by andrepd 9y ago
Oh nice, if he thought he could use the money better, then sure, please carry on not paying taxes. Can I do the same? Or is that a privilege reserved for the mega-rich?
Or let's call a spade a spade, and let's call tax evasion tax evasion.
- ptaipale 9y agoSure, call tax evasion tax evasion, but AFAIK Kamprad wasn't doing it. Authorities go very hard against tax evasion, the illegal thing. Tax avoidance is by definition things that are legal, not tax evasion.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoIn fact authorities are pretty lenient on tax evasion by the hyper-rich. The number of convictions and jail sentences isn't zero, but given the sums involved it's pitifully low. This is partly a resource problem. If you can pay advisors to create an impenetrable network of shell companies through which money disappears five levels down, you can pay lawyers to defend you if something goes wrong. The authorities are far more likely to go after - and jail - sole traders, smaller SMEs and consultants for five or six figure transgressions than near-billionaires with six, seven, or eight figure creative accounting.
- ptaipale 9y agoIt's not only relevant what the sums involved are. It is very relevant whether laws are broken, and how clear the lawbreaking is. Thus you can have large sums involved, but may find out that law wasn't broken, so there is no conviction. This is as it should be.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI think there are also significant risks involved when facing the hyper-rich. SMEs are a dime a dozen. If some get sacked for skirting or breaking the rules, nobody cares. But if you piss off a large megacorp enough to make it e.g. build its new factory elsewhere, or move its business away entirely, then suddenly your political career is on the line.
- Hello71 9y agoYou're not calling a spade a spade, you're calling a trowel a spade. While they have similar means of operation and mostly similar results, their definitions are commonly understood to be different. Trowels are single handed tools, spades are double handed. Tax avoidance is carried out publicly and legal, if possibly unethical, whereas tax evasion is carried out in secret and is illegal.
- charlesdm 9y agoWant to stop avoidance? Make proper laws. If it's legal (even through lobbying), then it is legal. And frankly I don't see why you shouldn't if you legally can. But to each their own views on this. You know who can stop avoidance? Politicians. They need to take responsibility. Feel free to shame multinationals or HNWIs for not paying taxes, but at the end of the day avoidance is only possible because politicians (or their advisors) make shoddy laws that aren't well thought out. Tax avoidance is essentially nothing more than understanding the law and framework you are operating in well, and finding a way to place income outside of the application of the law. So make better laws -- that's the only thing that can stop (excessive) tax avoidance. As long as politicians and don't put in a significant effort to close loopholes, I don't have any issue with tax avoidance.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoI can't agree with this enough. Expecting profit-motivated companies to voluntarily choose to pay more tax than they have to is fundamentally doomed to failure. One of the powers of the free market is to encourage the elimination of inefficiency and waste—not that it's perfect at that—and we can't expect to both have our cake and eat it, in that sense. I strongly agree that many companies should be contributing more to the state for the services that they use. But the way to do that is though robust and clear taxation frameworks, not some kind of general social pressure to pay an arbitrary, 'acceptable' amount of tax.
- charlesdm 9y agoYes, I agree they're not paying enough, and should be paying more. But that will only happen when laws are changed.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoYou can't have a robust and clear taxation framework in a plutocracy, because government is owned by the rich and run for the benefit of the rich. And they're hardly likely to support legislation that forces them to pay more tax. (Even if some are, there will always be a powerful lobbying effort agains any such move.) The economic and political rhetoric around "freedom", "taxation is bad because government is bad", and so on is a propaganda exercise. It isn't something that appeared spontaneously as a self-evident social truth. The more time I spend finding out about the history of political though in the US, the more I realise that the dominant narrative is the language and thinking of the hyper-rich, generated and maintained entirely for their benefit.
- dx034 9y agoYes you can. Move to a country with low/no income taxes.
- ptaipale 9y agoKamprad didn't really move to avoid income taxes; Sweden has all these decades had a relatively high income taxation, even when Kamprad moved back to Sweden from Switzerland. What he ran away from was wealth taxation that showed intention of becoming confiscatory, meaning his company would be taken from his control by the government.