4 ms·
Whoah, TIL that > EFF researchers discovered this leak of personal health data from healthcare.gov to DoubleClick It blows my mind that a site such as healthc
by Tepix 9y ago
Whoah, TIL that
> EFF researchers discovered this leak of personal health data from healthcare.gov to DoubleClick
It blows my mind that a site such as healthcare.gov would include 3rd party trackers. You guys in the US really don't care about privacy at all.
- azernik 9y agoThey were specifically using a monitoring tool (Floodlight, for tracking conversions) that happens to be provided by an ad company. To my view, it's more of a security issue than a privacy issue, as DoubleClick was prohibited by TOS from using the data for advertising.
- paulie_a 9y agoIn this era, if it comes from an ad company it almost certainly is a privacy issue and should generally be considered a security problem
- rrcaptain 9y agoThis is largely the part of independent contractors and subcontractors. Contracts go to the companies good at winning contracts, not necessarily the best company to do the job. The contractor takes an obscene profit for providing no value and then subcontracts the project to various subcontractors who may or may not employ actually qualified and skilled engineers. The government employees managing the contract typically do not have the expertise to evaluate the project or write proper specs. The HealthCare.gov contract was a mess of incompatible buzzwords. The engineers have no vested interest in the project as they're only there to complete that contract and they're so many levels removed from the government agency that no one actually knows who they are so it won't reflect poorly on them when everything comes out poorly. Because their career doesn't really depend on the success of the project, as the government gets blamed for contractor failures while contractors get the credit for success, they don't really need to do more than meet the specs. A better way to do this would be to expand the number of engineers within the government through groups like 18F and USDS, and give preference to them over private industry. Private contractors rarely work, but even when they do it's only when you have expenses that the government doesn't need (such as contracting a machine shop or car manufacturer to build something with their preexisting infrastructure). In software though, your only expenses are really your engineers and the cloud (as no one needs to run their own data center). The only thing subcontractors can do that the government can't is pay their employees more than the GS scale. However because the contract is supposed to be cheaper than the government just hiring employees themselves (as industry has "profit motive") they're going to have to cheap out elsewhere, either by hiring fewer developers or neglecting parts of the development. All of this is solvable by Congress, simply boost pay flexibility, but there's no political motive to fix it as all of the contractors are political donors. As a result, government software sucks.
- masklinn 9y ago> This is largely the part of independent contractors and subcontractors. Contracts go to the companies good at winning contracts, not necessarily the best company to do the job. The contractor takes an obscene profit for providing no value and then subcontracts the project to various subcontractors who may or may not employ actually qualified and skilled engineers. Frankly, I don't think that's really the case / honest here. There's been a movement to create "readable URLs" over the last few years, how many people considered that this could leak information through referers? I really can't say I remember seeing any discussion of that issue.
- vidarh 9y agoClearly not enough people considered that it'd leak information, but awareness of it was sufficient that most mail providers and large portals had redirect servers to "clean" URLs of meaningful referrers from their pages already by 2000 or before. So I agree it's probably an issue that people still don't understand this, but it's not a new issue, and there's really no excuse for not knowing this.
- belorn 9y ago> (as no one needs to run their own data center). That can be extraordinarily expensive once it leaks out that classified government data is in the hand of uncertified third-party cloud in some other nation, and you have to rush and pay twice or three times more in order for the contract to be changed and now have local certified supplier. This is what happened here in Sweden in equivalent departments for the DMV, which later implicated a further 40 different government department which used the same practice. When the cost go up by 200%-300%, suddenly the idea of running your own data center sounds much cheaper. It ended up being the highest single cost the departments had, excluding salaries and rent. you can get quite a nice data center for those billions. https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Transport_Agency%27s_law-breaking_of_security_for_computer_system https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Transport_Agency%2...
- rrcaptain 9y ago