6 ms·
Going to a well known third party is a guarantee that my payment data isn't sitting in a poorly secured vendor database. That's more important to me than a seam
by kevin_thibedeau 9y ago
Going to a well known third party is a guarantee that my payment data isn't sitting in a poorly secured vendor database. That's more important to me than a seamless transaction. PayPal is most useful when you don't fully trust the site you are buying from to have their shit together.
- nicoburns 9y agoEbay presumably doesn't have this problem though... they are large enough to be trusted on their own...
- xab9 9y agoIt just takes one malicious ad on the payment page... and the tempation to shove ads into the face of every customer and his dog is big. Think about java updates and a certain antivirus product as a great example of insane greed :)
- DrScump 9y agoeBay itself had a major password hack in 2014.
- donatj 9y agoThis. Entirely. I used to work for a small ecommerce webdev shop. I’ve worked on sooo many shitty insecure shopping carts over the years I simply know not to trust basically any small website asking for my card. Completely unencrypted, storing CVVs, sending CC details as GET parameters, I’ve seen it all. It’s painfully common! If a company is not a huge name, and is handling your credit card info themselves, they are mishandling your credit card information in one way or another. I guarantee it. Having been through PCI compliance, it’s no joke. It’s really not worth doing yourself in my strong opinion.
- marcell 9y ago> If a company is not a huge name Not to be snarky, but a huge name is no guarantee of safety. See: Target, Equifax.
- DrScump 9y agoEven eBay itself (PayPal's parent) had a major password hack in 2014.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoHowever, the advantage of PayPal is that I can buy from multiple websites while only needing to trust one entity with my credit card information. If trusting one entity can already be insecure, having to trust dozens of them is nuts.
- bdhess 9y agoParent didn’t say that. You assumed the converse.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y ago> sending CC details as GET parameters facepalm
- dang 9y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- reacharavindh 9y agoThis. I wish there was a fundamentally different way of handling payments. Something like a one time hash you give the vendor that serves like a digital check(cheque). This way, if they lose the hash they lost their money instead of the customer's. Handing a merchant credit card details "feels" like handing them a blank Check and trusting them to not take more than they should because of the risk of them losing the data. Edit: The digital hash should say where money comes from, to who, for what purpose, time, auth code and so on. I live in Denmark, and they have a system of phone banking here called "Mobile Pay" it works kind of like that. Where you transfer money to the merchant public phone number and show them proof of sending.. However it only works for in-person payments where you can swing your phone to show.
- jobigoud 9y agoThere are also banks that provide virtual credit cards that can only be used by one merchant and where you specify the max amount and expiration date.
- reacharavindh 9y agoYeah, but that's like buying a gift card for every merchant. That's a huge inconvenience. I can't buy one for every small website I want to buy stuff from..
- Already__Taken 9y agoIt's 2018 we should be generating these on the fly from my encrypted 2FA phone app instantly.
- diaz 9y agoThis is a reality in many places already. On the internet I never input any real card details, I go to the app, generate a virtual card with X amount available or for one buy only or for a single merchant for Y amount of time and use the generated card details instead.
- tome 9y agoAnd why would that matter to me? I've shopped online at small (and large) vendors for 20 years and I've never experienced fraud. Even if I did, the CC company covers it, don't they?
- rawfan 9y agoBut these problems don't exist if you use a service like Stripe. You never ever store any confidential customer information on your own servers.
- donatj 9y agoStripe was just getting big as I left for a job in edtech so I never had a chance to work with it. Excuse my ignorance but does it require you to send your card info to the vendors server rather than directly to stripe? If that’s the case you are still wide open to basically every form of bad handling. Just because a vendor doesn’t NEED to store your CC doesn’t mean they’re not out of sheer ignorance or incompetence.
- dodgrile 9y agoNope, it's designed so that the card details never touch the vendors server. They don't see it to be able to store it.
- fludlight 9y agoYou and I and the rest of the HN crowd are concerned about this problem, but the rest of the world doesn't even know that it exists. I wonder what real world bounce rates look like for PayPal vs InsecureCart.
- rawfan 9y agoThat's not how Stipe and similar services work. They exist to prevent your scenario. They actually work very similar to Paypal except that you don't have to be redirected to the Paypal site to enter your credentials. Instead you get a small "secured by Stripe" widget that takes the credentials (directly to Stripes PCI compliant servers so that yours don't have to be). As a reply you'll get some kind of token that you can use to actually charge the credit card (or SEPA, or whatever else). It's a secure way of handling payment without the "we're now redirecting you to some payment site" which BY THE WAY Paypal themselves offer in the form of their Braintree payment services.
- krutzger 9y agoI see a possible problem with that statement: starting from a poorly secured sellers site, users can't really be sure if he ends up on the real PayPal page anyway.