3 ms·
I'm not sure if I count as a member of the regressive left, but I'll try to give a clear answer anyway: be aware of it. The usual phrase is "check your privileg
by geofft 9y ago
I'm not sure if I count as a member of the regressive left, but I'll try to give a clear answer anyway: be aware of it. The usual phrase is "check your privilege," not "eliminate your privilege" or even "use your privilege". Be aware that there are things that others perceive as hardships that aren't hardships to you, or approaches to life that you can take that others can't take without social (or legal) penalty, or whatever, and show some compassion - certainly do not say "Well, if I could do it, why couldn't you." You are slightly more likely to get the benefit of the doubt from potential employers, or police who find you in a place they don't like, or conservative religious-political leaders suggesting policies, or whatever, than you would if you weren't a cis white man. You also don't have the life experience of not being a cis white men, which certainly doesn't mean that you can't understand other people, it just means you can't extrapolate your own experiences and reconstruct what life is like for them from first principles. That's it.
If you want to give all your money to the poor, great, don't let me stop you. If you want to improve Western civilization and make life better for the poor (and the rich too, perhaps), also great, don't let me stop you either. If you want to improve Western civilization for people who look like you but not for others, well, at least stop for a second and realize that's what you're doing before you do it. (And if you continue nonetheless, there's probably room for criticism, but that criticism is not fundamentally about how you merely have privilege.)
- virmundi 9y agoI'm replying to you since you have the longest reply (and it's thought out too). The regressive left is the SJW that tells the Norwegians they can't use their own letters because Nazi decided to co-op their culture back in the day [1]. You have individuals like Gazi [2] running around saying that white people need to pay reparations even though most white people in the country descend from immigrants that arrived after the civil war therefore they never owned slaves. We've gotten to the point that some on the regressive left don't think that it's even possible for a white man to empathize or even understand the language used to describe their situations. If enough feel like communication has broken down to this level, they have and will call for war. My problem is that people that say, "check your privilege" use it to shut down dialogue. We're getting into identity politics. This never, ever ends well for anyone. I'm all for compassion. I'm not for the hypocrisy of using race and guilt as cudgels against supposed political enemies. I'm not for college campuses insulating themselves with their own group think to the point that it's an arrest-able offense to hand out the Constitution, the very document that defines that we are all equal in the sight of the law, to students on Constitution Day by a student of the college [3]. I absolutely abhor the continued press for ignorance about the very historical facts at hand in which the white man, and only the white man, was to blame or profited from slavery [4]. 1 - https://sputniknews.com/europe/201801311061237928-norway-nazi-attacking-viking/ https://sputniknews.com/europe/201801311061237928-norway-naz... 2 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tanz1IxVpVA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tanz1IxVpVA 3 - http://reason.com/blog/2017/01/21/students-arrested-constitutions-michigan http://reason.com/blog/2017/01/21/students-arrested-constitu... 4 - https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/ppzevg/hey-v12n5 https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/ppzevg/hey-v12n5
- geofft 9y ago> The regressive left is the SJW that tells the Norwegians they can't use their own letters because Nazi decided to co-op their culture back in the day [1]. Ehhhh. I'm of Indian descent, and I am perfectly comfortable with the modern inability to use the swastika in international contexts, where you don't have a culture where people expect the pre-Nazi meaning of the swastika. "They banned an up-arrow" just ... doesn't seem like something worth getting upset about? Presumably if the logo accidentally looked like a penis, they'd change that too, but that's hardly a sign of identity politics or anything. > You have individuals like Gazi [2] running around saying that white people need to pay reparations even though most white people in the country descend from immigrants that arrived after the civil war therefore they never owned slaves. I have no idea who this person is, or how genuine they are. Every political viewpoint has extremists and trolls and uninformed folks (I don't know if this person fits in one of these categories, but I certainly don't know that they don't), and many of those people are on YouTube. A much better case for reparations, which includes arguments about why white people who arrived in the US after slavery still benefited unfairly from organized oppression of black people, can be found in, say, Ta-Nehisi Coates' "The Case for Reparations:" https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-cas... > it's an arrest-able offense to hand out the Constitution, the very document that defines that we are all equal in the sight of the law, to students on Constitution Day by a student of the college [3] As far as I can tell from the reporting, these students were protesting a "free speech zone" policy on campus, right? I'm certainly not about to endorse "free speech zones," but it seems pretty clear that the motivation for the arrest was not that they were handing out Constitutions, they simply chose to hand out Constitutions because they knew they'd get favorable news headlines like this. > I absolutely abhor the continued press for ignorance about the very historical facts at hand in which the white man, and only the white man, was to blame or profited from slavery [4]. The fact that your source is from VICE, which is regularly accused (possibly correctly!) of being left-biased, doesn't do much to convince me that these facts are being hidden on the left. Certainly I've never heard anyone on the left make a reasoned argument that only white men were to blame or ever profited from any slavery in history.
- 9y ago
- Red_Tarsius 9y agoPeople are not children who need to be always reminded of their own privilege. We already know it.