2 ms·
re: your edit; it's not necessarily true that deaths/distance is a better way to assess how terrible humans are at driving. People who are able to drive many mi
by danso 9y ago
re: your edit; it's not necessarily true that deaths/distance is a better way to assess how terrible humans are at driving. People who are able to drive many miles (relative to the average) likely drive regularly on the interstate, which has been designed to make driving as decision-free as possible, even at high speeds.
Maybe the author's fault was to use deaths as a metric when accidents would have been far more telling of how frequently humans commit errors while driving, especially the kind of errors that computers do not make. Namely, computers make far fewer errors the more regular and controlled the operating conditions. Humans, on the other hand, can get into even more accidents the closer they are to their own home.
- mulmen 9y agoBut there needs to be some normalization because machines drive many fewer miles. How do you suggest we normalize the number of fatalities for the sake of comparison?
- danso 9y agoBut the OP doesn't argue that machines currently have a better fatality rate. And so it's seems nonsensical to say that his use of the fatalities/year metric is more "misleading" compared to fatalities/km. The OP used the fatality rate to say that humans were terrible at driving, because so many fatalities occur out of basic, preventable human error, despite all of the money and research and policy invested. And the context of the comment is in pointing out human fraility when it came to consistency at mundane, mechanical tasks. I would agree that the OP's use of fatalities is perhaps sensationalist. His point would have been far more clearer if he talked about all kinds of accidents.