9 ms·
A Tale of Two Columbia Classes
- tomkat0789 9y agoYeah it's hard to imagine having good natured debates around social justice topics in America these days. I once went to a museum event where the staff dressed like renaissance scientists and humorously debated whether the "celestial spheres" rotate around the earth or the sun. It's hard to imagine a similar event about the more politicized subjects of our time. Perhaps the question is: should we?
- adamnemecek 9y agoDoes this school of thought originate in the US? I realize it’s based on the Frankfurt school but I’m not sure if it was always so militant.
- phyller 9y agoA very close friend of mine recently received a master's degree in Philosophy at Columbia. She definitely did not fit the mold of many students who were there, being a conservative and an active duty pilot in the military who was preparing to teach at an academy. She found many people and professors to be open minded and mostly fair. However she experienced a few professors of the type described here, where the authority of the professor was used in ad hominem attacks on disfavored groups. Voicing any dissent was greeted with scorn and disgust. One of the interesting things, at least about the graduate program, is that you can take many credits as "R credits", meaning you don't get graded. You have to show up and submit research papers, but they don't get graded. The idea, I think, is to focus on the learning and not focus on getting an A. I think this can also give the students the ability to disagree with vindictive professors without getting their academic career derailed. I think this really works to provide more intellectual freedom to students at Columbia, and my friend had a good experience there.
- jseliger 9y agoShe found many people and professors to be open minded and mostly fair. However she experienced a few professors of the type described here, where the authority of the professor was used in ad hominem attacks on disfavored groups. Voicing any dissent was greeted with scorn and disgust. I went to grad school in English at the University of Arizona and my experience was similar. The same is true of students; people regularly ask me about those crazy students on campus, not realizing that the ones who make the news are the exception: https://jakeseliger.com/2017/04/24/ninety-five-percent-of-people-are-fine-but-its-that-last-five-percent/ https://jakeseliger.com/2017/04/24/ninety-five-percent-of-pe... Most profs are open minded and fair, but the ones who are't yield the best, juiciest, and most absurd soundbites.
- wallace_f 9y agoWhere dissent, authority and virtue meet there are difficult dynamics for humans to work with. I had a professor who flirts with antisemetic ideology, and who justifies violence towards western countries. While he is among the most controversial professors in the world and holds ideas that are entirely unacceptable... within the class room, when I protested, no one joined me in dissenting these ideas. I am not trying to portray myself as better than others, but I still cannot believe that fact about people. And that professor was the most vindictive, petty and insulting I had ever interacted with. If those ideas weren't unacceptable outside the classroom, then who would question or criticize him? Anyone? I guess it's always been the case that the Thomas Paines of this world will be dying alone. Dissenting views are still no great virtue in 2018 and can still be met with barbaric behavior just as they were in centuries past. For example, Lil Wayne said he was not a victim of racism and he criticized BLM, and he was shot and then made into a pariah for this. Speaking of classes on specific ideas, should this be one of the great lessons of history people should be learning of? I mean, the inability to question authority is exactly what tyrants like Hitler and Hirohito wanted. It was the most important thing to them. The only German child Nazis went to the trouble of formally executing (Helmuth Hübener) was the one who just wanted people to hear what British radio broadcasters were saying about the war. Yet who at Columbia learns of him? Perhaps the greatest injustices and most embarassing tragedies of men and women in history are made possible when you make dissent impossible.
- aor215 9y agoI also recently received a masters in philosophy from CU and know exactly who you’re talking about! By and large, I agree with her assessment. However, I would add that close-minded professors and students are quite rare - or at least they were when I was in grad school. Among the students, I found everyone to be willing to debate any of these issues, even if passions were strong.
- meri_dian 9y agoI've noticed the author's view is becoming more common, within the past year. It's the inevitable reaction to extremism. I accept the existence of privilege but I believe that militancy about it is counterproductive. Using the state of black people in America as an example, certainly they have higher poverty rates than whites because of slavery and continued discrimination, but there are problems within the black community that must be addressed by the community itself. Broken homes are a huge problem which perpetuate poverty but within the privilege centric framework it's racist to even mention this. Of course slavery is ultimately to blame for all of this, but focusing on it will not undo it.
- virmundi 9y agoI've never seen a clear answer about what a cis white male is supposed to do about their privilege. Should they give all their money to the poor? Should they shoot themselves to remove the blight of the Western World, it's democracy, relative tolerance, and ability to reflect upon itself and improve? Should they just say, "You're right and I'm thankful"? The regressive-left makes no sense in their stance.
- geofft 9y agoI'm not sure if I count as a member of the regressive left, but I'll try to give a clear answer anyway: be aware of it. The usual phrase is "check your privilege," not "eliminate your privilege" or even "use your privilege". Be aware that there are things that others perceive as hardships that aren't hardships to you, or approaches to life that you can take that others can't take without social (or legal) penalty, or whatever, and show some compassion - certainly do not say "Well, if I could do it, why couldn't you." You are slightly more likely to get the benefit of the doubt from potential employers, or police who find you in a place they don't like, or conservative religious-political leaders suggesting policies, or whatever, than you would if you weren't a cis white man. You also don't have the life experience of not being a cis white men, which certainly doesn't mean that you can't understand other people, it just means you can't extrapolate your own experiences and reconstruct what life is like for them from first principles. That's it. If you want to give all your money to the poor, great, don't let me stop you. If you want to improve Western civilization and make life better for the poor (and the rich too, perhaps), also great, don't let me stop you either. If you want to improve Western civilization for people who look like you but not for others, well, at least stop for a second and realize that's what you're doing before you do it. (And if you continue nonetheless, there's probably room for criticism, but that criticism is not fundamentally about how you merely have privilege.)
- indescions_2018 9y agoIsn't it funny to think that by the end of this century. We may make actually progress toward solving the problem. Of what it feels like to be a bat? What is it like to be a bat? By Thomas Nagel https://organizations.utep.edu/portals/1475/nagel_bat.pdf https://organizations.utep.edu/portals/1475/nagel_bat.pdf
- nostromo 9y agohttp://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html > When you find something you can't say, what do you do with it? My advice is, don't say it. Or at least, pick your battles. I've noticed this in the work environment lately. It's palpable. People are afraid of saying the wrong thing. Everyone is basically taking pg's approach, and sitting quietly. It's sad. I don't know what to do about it. But, man, is it a relief when you're getting a beer with a close friend and can explore some good-natured heterodoxy. That sort of interesting conversation is getting rarer and rarer in public. When I was young, it was the political right that would shut down heterodox opinions, like flag burning or atheism or same-sex couples on TV. But strangely enough, I feel more free to talk openly around my political right friends today. It's strange that "liberalism" in America today feels so illiberal.
- sampo 9y agoThen there is that quote from Ben Franklin.
- FluteBook 9y agoFor what it's worth (if it's any solace), you're not alone in noticing this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=evWiz6WRbCA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=evWiz6WRbCA I think part of it is the fear of becoming e.g. Justine Sacco. It's incredibly easy for something you say to be taken out of context and to become the target of the internet hate machine. Nuance, complexity, context - whatever you want to call it, it's hard for people to digest. As a result, "celebrities" become either angels or devils. I don't think this unwillingness to accept complexity is a new facet of society, but it's much easier than ever before to get a mob together for the proverbial witch hunt. As a result, lots of people (and I'm not claiming to be an exception) are either going over the top to proclaim their piousness lest they be declared witches, or slinking along silently hoping that no one would ever want to accuse them in the first place.
- danso 9y agoI think Justine Sacco got a raw deal too, but I don't see this as a simple example of society becoming more sensitive. I sympathize with her -- not just because I think you shouldn't ever send death threats to a stranger because of a tweet -- but because I'm sure me and my friends and acquaintances have made that kind of joke too. And the reason why we don't tear each other apart is because we know enough about each other to assume that we are being facetious/ironic/darkly humorous. But Twitter is not a bar, or a group SMS. It is a platform on which you can instantaneously broadcast something to an entire world. The world does not know you, and it's presumptuous to think that hundreds of millions of people should have known who you were. Again, this doesn't justify the hatemob -- I'm just saying that Sacco's situation was less an issue of society becoming too sensitive, and more an issue of tech amplifying our reach far beyond what we comprehend.
- poster123 9y agoFrom the article: "The other course is called Philosophy and Feminism, in which we learn the core principles of intersectional feminism, queer theory, and feminist epistemology." Those aren't real intellectual disciplines, so naturally the professor discourages debate.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y ago> Those aren't real intellectual disciplines, so naturally the professor discourages debate. I think we should distinguish a topic from those paid to teach about it. It seems to me that regardless of how silly we consider a particular set of beliefs to be, we might gain useful knowledge by studying (with intellectual rigour) why people hold those beliefs, how societies react to the ideas, etc. But I'm sure it's equally possible for some areas of study to attract foolish or undisciplined professors, and for that pattern to become self-sustaining.
- Firebrand 9y ago>But I also suspect that many students with little philosophy experience came away with the impression that this class represented what philosophy is, and that’s what disheartens me most. Haven’t we all experienced a professor who was good in their field but couldn’t teach well, or was too much of a hardass? Faculty ratings and ratemyprofessor are there for a reason.
- nlowell 9y agoI don't think this story is about a teacher who isn't good at "just" the fundamental actions of teaching. It sounds like their actual skill and respect for the material is lacking. If your math professor couldn't prove the basic theorems he wanted you to memorize without referring to his authority, that, to me, would be a sign not that he was bad at explaining but that he was fundamentally unskilled in his field.
- rdtsc 9y agoWhat is the point of a philosophy class if you can't debate or argue about ideas being taught. It seems like it would be a great class for discussion. Common, how can you read Foucault and not start a debate wondering what he meant. > She went on to swear at us in this guilt-inducing way a couple more times before the semester’s end. Why is that ever ok? Why is the professor still teaching there? What if they have tenure. What does a professor have to do then to be kicked out. It would seem like swearing at students in class would be a good reason. > As hyperbolic as this might sound, voicing a strong pushback against any idea that the Professor favored was nearly unthinkable. It suddenly dawned on me, as I was typing this, that it's actually a useful class! It does teach a modern approach to discourse. That's exactly what is popular and so it makes sense to teach it that way - shutting off debate and discussion, swearing at people, demoralizing them, making them feel guilty, punishing if they don't appear guilty enough, etc. Looking back, I am sure this student would find this class was more memorable and useful than the other one. They'll forget about Thomas Nagel but never forget how they could not discuss Focault.
- EthanHeilman 9y ago>What is the point of a philosophy class if you can't debate or argue about ideas being taught. It seems like it would be a great class for discussion. Common, how can you read Foucault and not start a debate wondering what he meant. ... and people across the philosophical and political spectrum, especially feminists, have critiques of Foucault. It seems irresponsible and deeply insulting to treat a philosopher as beyond questioning.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thro1237 9y agoI have tried to read Foucault and could barely understand what he was trying to say. May be most students are quiet because they don't know what to refute :-)
- lewis500 9y agoI believe there is self-selection in the professorship as to who teaches what, and this explains this student's experience. Feminism has (relatively) direct political and behavioral consequences, and so the professors who teach it will tend to skew towards people who want those policies and behaviors implemented. By contrast, what is the agenda of someone who teaches Methods and Problems of Philosophical Thought? Probably that field self-selects for people who don't want, or believe they can, change the world too much in any particular way. Rather, if you asked them why they got into the subject, they would probably say it's inherently interesting, or that they like reading and argument, or have some kind of vague idea about changing the world that lacks much salient political or behavioral implication (e.g., "opening people's minds"). Thus, they will encourage debate and want to make sure the students learn all the ideas correctly (the ideas being what they find beautiful) moreso than actually accept the ideas. After all, who cares if one of your philosophy students goes on to law school thinking it's not impossible he's a brain in a vat? It would be interesting if the philosophy professors had to swap out who taught what. But this is unlikely because of the division of labor and time required to teach and do research---each would feel frustrated. In my own field, transportation engineering, many professors often started out like the first type of professor and wound up like the second. They go into the field thinking they're going to help improve transit or get people to stop driving less or design highways better. But after a while they realize the decisions they impact are (i) extremely context-dependent (e.g., bus rapid transit vs light rail), (ii) made by bureaucrats not the public (e.g., diverging diamond interchanges) or (iii) made politically/randomly without any pretense of optimization whatsoever (e.g., Trump's infrastructure plan seems to have been designed partly by an investor, Wilbur Ross, with no prior interest in roads). At that point the professors become more interested than they were in furthering knowledge for its own sake, which is all that's left over to do and is also what will get you tenure. This leads to something of a balancing act when they teach, whereby the professors want to teach the students the big ideas without discouraging their enthusiasm.
- throwcu2018 9y agoThis is an interesting anecdote picking on one professor, but I can say as a current student, Columbia does an outstanding job of admitting students from a diverse background through the School of General Studies. I'm a student here now, and I've made friends with several of the ex-military folks who make up most of the population of the School of General Studies. Just earlier tonight, I was chatting with a 35 year old former marine from Mississippi who just completed his undergrad at Columbia and is running the Columbia Republican Club (CUCR). Columbia has always given them the opportunity to have speakers (Charles Murray, Mike Cernovich, Dinesh D'Souza spoke last year, Scaramucci and Jordan Peterson are on deck this semester). Security is always made available to them, and protestors, while permitted, are not allowed to prevent the guest from speaking (unlike Middlebury or Berkley). The events that I've attended are civil and the audience generally acts according to what you would expect from an academic institution.
- tetrazine 9y agoSeems like this post has been killed, but here's another perspective anyway. I'm a former student at a school functionally identical (and in many, many ways culturally similar) to Columbia. Aside from my professional-focused studies related to topics many HN readers would be familiar with, I'm a serious philosophy student. I've taken classes in both of these academic categories within philosophy that the author seems to be outlining. For what it's worth, I do not fit the political or demographic mold of a person who would stereotypically pursue the "progressive" branches of philosophy being discussed and in many cases criticized here. There are many classes with different teaching styles. Some present material as dogma without affording critique, as in the feminist theory class the author described. This is bad teaching, it is possibly even more common in classes on feminist and similar theory. It's there in other areas of philosophy, including mind-focused and analytic topics, but harder to encounter until you're already deep in academia. I promise that there are Plato scholars who act just as the professor in the article did. There are those here that feel feminist, queer, and race-driven theory is not serious "philosophy" or who will reduce it to cultural marxist or similar terms. This is intellectually dishonest, and probably driven by odious people you've met that espouse beliefs along the lines of Foucault or the Frankfurt School. Yes, Foucault's supporters can be extremely annoying and unreasonable. But there are real insights in many progressive philosophical works, some of them evoking striking and existential moments of reflection, and proposing new ways to live and see the world. I urge readers here to attempt to look past the frustrations they might have with feminists or progressives and try to find something valuable in these works, because it really is there. I.e., when you hear people talk about things like abolishing the police or that all women or people of colour are violently oppressed, try not to react immediately to these phrases and see what is really being said. Philosophy is often about getting to the very root meaning of a term, or making subtle distinctions, or creating technical terms out of everyday language. You may find that the people who have annoyed you have bastardized the philosophers they espouse, or have at least failed to communicate the meat of their work.