4 ms·
More evidence of rent declines in Portland
- coolspot 9y agoI think controversy is not that building more has no effect on rent prices - of course more supply drives prices down. It is more about whether we want to live in over-populated ant-farms or want to pay premium for less dense living.
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> to pay premium for less dense living What is stopping you from doing that in any one of: Hillsboro, Beaverton, Tigard, Lake Oswego, Vancouver, ...
- ggg9990 9y agoI mean, if someone already owns a home in Portland, and can use their vote to maintain the kind of lifestyle they want, why wouldn’t they? Altruism towards a potential future resident? Unlikely.
- koverstreet 9y agoIf everyone acts that way that'll be a good way to end up like California.
- ggg9990 9y agoNo, because without Prop 13 a retired teacher isn’t going to want her house to be worth $5 million if she plans on continuing to live there.
- koverstreet 9y agoThat mindset was what led to prop 13. When did altruism become such a dirty word? When did selfish, short term thinking become such the norm? That isn't the kind of thinking that built the stuff we take for granted.
- electricslpnsld 9y agoAnd where are contemporary teachers supposed to live? The San Francisco school district is building what amount to dorms for teachers because the housing market is so distorted.
- carlivar 9y agoWhat American cities are your ant farms? New York? This seems like hyperbole to me. I think there is a happy medium between anti build NIMBYs of, say, San Francisco, and a so-called ant farm.
- jjaredsimpson 9y agoI don't think people are choosing to pay a premium in favor of lower density. Incumbent land holders using local zoning laws to prevent density to maintain their wealth. Also using the phrase overpopulated ant farms isn't useful or accurate.
- orangecat 9y agoIncumbent land holders using local zoning laws to prevent density to maintain their wealth. And they have an alliance of convenience with "anti-gentrification" activists who reject basic economics. Hopefully results like this will make some of them reconsider.
- com2kid 9y ago> It is more about whether we want to live in over-populated ant-farms or want to pay premium for less dense living. You are forgetting all the people, such as myself, who are willing to pay a premium for more dense living. I love being able to walk everywhere.
- usrusr 9y agoDensity does not necessarily bring walkability. You can see aging "highrise suburbs" all over Europe, a well-intended experiment to make living close to nature accessible to the masses. They rarely have more than a badly serviced bus stop in walkable distance. This is what many people think of when they hear density.
- Tehdasi 9y ago> I think controversy is not that building more has no effect on rent prices - of course more supply drives prices down. After reading many internet conversations on property, the idea that supply drives down prices in property is far from an accepted viewpoint.
- jmknoll 9y ago"Over-populated ant farms" is a pretty strong phrase, and is usually more the result of bad policy than density in and of itself. San Francisco has about 6000 people/square km, and feels crowded. Paris has about 20,000 people/square km, and to me feels less crowded. In Paris, they've taken the general development policy of building everything up to 6-8 stories, with commercial on the ground floor and residential above. Strikes me as a good way to pack in a lot of people without things feeling too crowded.
- SwellJoe 9y agoThe US is, by and large, absolutely insane in how it plans cities. "Mixed use" is a total novelty in most cities...only now being considered for a small percentage of development. Most cities still have city plans and zoning that enforce huge suburban neighborhoods with no commercial development within them. It leads to disastrously bad neighborhoods with disastrously bad traffic going into and out of the places where people are doing things like have jobs or shop. Even hip/progressive cities are this way. It's really a big deal when a development happens that steps out of it, and people in surrounding housing usually raise holy hell to keep it from happening. Americans are mostly goddamned idiots who hate nice things, is what I'm trying to say. (And, have the nerve to complain about traffic in the same breath as demanding nothing other than single-family homes be allowed within miles of their single-family home.)
- s2g 9y ago> Americans are mostly goddamned idiots who hate nice things > their single-family home maybe they just like single family homes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- EtDybNuvCu 9y agoPortland is terrible. The homelessness is depressingly tangible, the streets are either full of crap or protestors, everybody is too white, and the weather is unpleasantly unremarkable. I used to work for a big multinational with a Portland office and a Seattle office; the Seattle office is far nicer.
- electricslpnsld 9y agoPortland is amazing. The food is great, the beer is world-class (and all sorts of weird little breweries can be found everywhere), the coffee is top notch and the selection of coffee shops is amazing, Oregonians are among the nicest people I've encountered in the United States, awesome Springs and Summers, lots of amazing nature nearby, no sales taxes, lots of art, lots of music, lots of cool weird music venues, people are incredibly environmentally conscious. All in all a great little city in my estimation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gt_ 9y agoIt would do them some good to be be more homeless epidemic conscious. Any political gesture Portland could collectively be proud of is undermined by it’s failure to show concern for the members of it’s own society.
- telchar 9y agoSomething that would be worth considering in homelessness discussion re: Portland, SF, etc is how many of these people are city dwellers that became homeless versus already-homeless people who gravitated toward (or were shipped to) the city? The former is a reflection on the city, but in my opinion the latter is less a reflection on the city than it is of the nation. If I become homeless and move out to Portland, is that an indictment of Portland? Is it more their responsibility to house me than say, Pittsburg, who may have sent the people there on a bus? I don't know the stats mentioned above but it seems like the places that have huge homeless problems are mostly those with nice mild weather and tolerant residents. While I lean left and support affordable housing and the welfare state, it seems a little unfair to saddle those places particularly with housing a homeless population that they didn't cause to be homeless.
- deephoney 9y agoThis is exactly what you would expect to see in a city where demand is largely driven by people living and working in the area, but in some large international cities (Vancouver, London I'm looking at you!) Speculation/Investment from non-residents makes up a such a significant part of demand and the highest margin part of that demand, that there is a risk of new builds becoming "empty nest eggs". [1] http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/vancouver-non-residents-statistics-canada-figures-1.4456657 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/vancouver-non...
- newbear 9y agoJust spent a month looking for a studio or one bedroom below $1200. Plenty of ok options and a couple better than ok. All apartments came with the threat of a scary property management company. Finally we found an artsy owner with an attic and After waiting two weeks for our background check to pass for a studio we were approved but had already signed a lease for he attic. Pretty stressful process. Mostly because the paranoia of dealing with shady property managers. If I was a Stanford MBA I'd start a nation wide property management firm that focus on ethics and does shit right. Housing fellow hard working citezens should be an honor and done with good morals. And to think how much harder it is for somebody just even a little bit worse off than me...
- fapjacks 9y agoProperty management companies in the San Diego area are absolutely shit-awful and I've thought about starting a nation-wide property management company myself. There's just no way I could be any worse than what's out there.
- carlivar 9y agoI wonder what you'd need to charge? Lots of awful property mgmt companies out there because it cuts into property owner's profits to pay more for a better one. If demand is high, what's the motivation for the owner? I suspect they mostly go with the lowest bidder.
- newbear 9y agoIs there away to make owners responsible? In my eyes they should be - they are the 'owners' afterall.
- telchar 9y agoOut of curiosity, what makes you call those property managers scary, vs others you have encountered?
- newbear 9y ago
- gigatexal 9y agoIt’s a shitty time to be a landlord though, one without deep pockets anyway: I just have a home that I bought years ago that when I got married a year later thought I’d supplement my new family’s income with some rent. Nothing major since I have a mortgage and a high interest rate and all that. But it was fine. I treated my tenants well, came rushing in to fix anything, didn’t charge late fees, etc. then the Portland city council run by a woman who has never owned a home passes an ordinance that makes it nigh to impossible to raise rents (caps them at 10%) and even if someone is on a month to month lease they get 90 days notice (totally cool with that) and a stipend to pay for their next place between 1800 and almost 5 grand based on length of stay. (Not cool!).
- stevenwoo 9y agoThis article says if you only rent one home, the new tenant protections don't apply. https://www.portlandmercury.com/news/2018/01/24/19626335/portlands-small-time-landlords-dont-have-to-follow-renter-protections https://www.portlandmercury.com/news/2018/01/24/19626335/por...
- gigatexal 9y agoInteresting. That’s not how I read the law but thanks. I’ll look more into it.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y ago10% annual rent increase is a lot, and is well above inflation for most areas. Is the stipend only required if you kick them out? If that's the case, then it makes sense IMO. Renters are people and need stable housing.
- JBlue42 9y agoRent stabilization is capped at 3%/yr in LA. On /r/LosAngeles, you can read about those without it getting crazy increases like 22%. A 10% max seems reasonable. Given that unless you switch jobs you're unlikely to see any big % increases to your salary, why create instability or price out good tenants.