8 ms·
Here's what puzzles me. I have looked into Stripe, and just browsed the Adyen webpage. Both of those services seem to require you to maintain your own "active"
by analog31 9y ago
Here's what puzzles me. I have looked into Stripe, and just browsed the Adyen webpage. Both of those services seem to require you to maintain your own "active" server that can run server side code.
PayPal seems to be unique in being able to take payments from a passive web page, because the customer conducts their transaction at PP's website.
This is why I continue to use PP for my tiny little business (without eBay). Even though I consider myself reasonably tech savvy, I don't trust myself to maintain a website that is compatible with everybody's browser, phone, etc., and that guarantees the security of their personal data. Moving to another payment processor requires a quantum leap in technology that I'd rather not keep up with. I'd rather design another gizmo.
From time to time I look around for an alternative to PP, and haven't found one yet. I suspect that many small-time eBay sellers may be in the same boat.
- slobotron 9y agoBest way to integrate with stripe is to use their checkout button to get a token instead of receiving CC info directly. Iirc, still need to use backend code to do the actual charge, but at least you never see any sensitive info.
- cortesoft 9y agoRight, but the poster is saying they don't want to run a server AT ALL.
- arca_vorago 9y agoThen what are they running their website on? This is a perfect example of the infectious nature of the word cloud, people say the word cloud as if there's no server still running it! Oh noes, I have to run php code stripe has done all the work on and provided to me! Scary!
- Fogest 9y agoCouldn't you run a more static based site if you don't have to run some PHP code though?
- arca_vorago 9y agoI was just using php as an example. See stripes documentation for more info: https://stripe.com/docs/stripe-js https://stripe.com/docs/stripe-js https://stripe.com/docs/charges https://stripe.com/docs/charges
- zbentley 9y agoThere's a big difference between running a server that does basically glorified inventory tracking, and running a server that hosts (even just a wrapper around) payment infrastructure. If my inventory service breaks I might have some pissed-off customers or have to re-ship some items, the odds of getting in bigger trouble than that are low. If my payment infrastructure goes down or gets compromised, the odds of lawsuits or federal/financial-org penalties are way higher. So sure, you still probably have to have a "server" somewhere (you could probably make a fully static site for a merchant using third-party payment links, javascript, and mailto links or something--think "email as database"--but I suspect this would be neither featureful, secure, nor reliable), but the difference in what you need to maintain/serve is huge.
- lsaferite 9y agoWorking with Stripe and PayPal are essentially the same if you use best practices. Stripe can do the payment page and redirect if needed and can also capture paying info from a static page that is submitted via JS in the background. In the end you'd get a simple token that's just a reference to the payment details in Stripe (just like PP). If you integrate with the Stripe payment page then they will even remember you across sites (again, just like PP) and you won't have to input payment details.
- clintonb 9y agoIf you use Stripe, you still need a server to make secure API calls to charge the card. The card is not charged until you make an API call with the token.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hkmurakami 9y agoHow's visa checkout? War under the impression that it was a direct PayPal competitor.
- analog31 9y agoI'll take a look. Thanks. If nothing else, offering two payment options would be good for the very small fraction of customers who have had a bad experience with PP for whatever reason.
- TheHegemon 9y agoI can't speak for how it is now. However: the implementation for developers was so bad that they offered my company $200k to integrate it into our site and we STILL lost money on the deal.
- jtc331 9y agoNo, Visa Checkout is a confusingly named product that only serves to send credit card data to a merchant’s servers. The card data isn’t even kept safe by a intermediate token; the merchant has to run a PCI compliant solution. That’s very different from PayPal’s offering.
- draw_down 9y agoWho knows, maybe that will change one day.
- dcosson 9y agoNot sure I follow - you mentioned not handling browser compatibility which implies you're not directly writing the html/css for the site. If you're using shopify or hosted wordpress or something, I would think most of those providers would handle the Stripe integration for you? You also mention a passive web page, if you're talking about a static site (as in a jekyll or hugo site hosted on S3), you may be right. I don't fully understand how that might work since if you're accepting payment for a service, presumably you also need to keep state somewhere to track the delivery of that service to users and such. But if you did want to accept Stripe on a static site, I would think you could use Lambda functions in AWS to handle the callbacks without worrying about the maintenance costs and security risks of running your own linux server.
- koolba 9y agoYou don’t need any of that. For a small shop an email from the payment processor with the customer’s name, address, and order details is all you need. No lambda, backend, or database necessary.
- analog31 9y agoI'm using Google Sites. Previously, I wrote plain HTML, but just the most basic sort, that most browsers will typically format into something readable, even if not beautiful. You're right, I mean a static site -- one that cannot run a server side script. At its most basic level, you can pay me by going to PayPal and telling them to send money to my account. PP takes your credit card info. I get an e-mail, and my PP account shows a log of transactions. Then I click on "create shipping label," and it creates a shipping label (USPS or UPS) to the customer's address. At a slightly higher level, PP will generate a "add to cart" button in the form of HTML that you paste into your web page. But it does the same thing as sending money to my account -- it just looks a bit more professional and maybe less confusing. This is for a gadget, but for enthusiasts in an area where people are not typically tech savvy, and don't feel put off by a site that doesn't look professionally maintained. Edit: I should note that despite seeming sketchy, a lot of trust is built into PP's buyer and seller protection policies. If I try to screw around with you in any way, PayPal will happily reverse the transaction.
- roordan 9y agoI think the idea is that eBay doesn't want to have users sign up with Paypal anymore. Instead only ever interact with eBay, with Adyen just being the pipes for eBay.
- dboreham 9y agoWouldn't small time eBay sellers just use whatever payment processor eBay integrates with? (there's no need for them to host any part of the payment process since the transaction is conducted entirely on eBay). Reasons to not use the default processor would be : transaction cost.
- clintonb 9y agoThe reason for processing on your own server is so you own the entire checkout experience. If you redirect he user to another site for payment, you run the risk of losing track of that user. Also, the third-party’s branding may clash with your own.
- bspn 9y agoIt also puts you squarely in PCI scope which is a massive burden. I believe many of the modern payment processors offer embedded iframe solutions these days where they handle the sensitive bits (card and CVV#) but allow you to style the payment form however you like.
- LesZedCB 9y agoto an extent yes. There is another lever, PA-DSS compliance which is less stringent than full PCI-DSS compliance because you aren't actually storing card data on your servers, they are just passing through, or pages that collect them are being rendered by that server.
- robinwassen 9y agoThe third party branding can also be positive depending on your own brand trust. Made numerous payments to shoddy businesses in SE asia the last month, but since most offer PayPal as payment provider I feel confident entering my CC number.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoGoing to a well known third party is a guarantee that my payment data isn't sitting in a poorly secured vendor database. That's more important to me than a seamless transaction. PayPal is most useful when you don't fully trust the site you are buying from to have their shit together.
- nicoburns 9y agoEbay presumably doesn't have this problem though... they are large enough to be trusted on their own...
- erikpukinskis 9y agoDoes Stripe Checkout not fit the bill? https://stripe.com/checkout https://stripe.com/checkout
- arbuge 9y agoStripe Checkout still requires server side code for the Stripe checkout form to submit to.
- vasusen 9y agoYou might want to take a look at https://www.everbutton.com/ https://www.everbutton.com/. It basically wraps Stripe’s API so you can drop front end JavaScript without any backend code. Much more customizable than PayPal with all of Stripe’s benefits.
- vectorEQ 9y agoi agree it's actually kind of bad that payment providers don't provide this page. todays technology could even render it on the webpage of the customer shop without redirecting fully to another page (scrpt scr=paymentproviderscript.bla? or so?). If people have to maintain and host their own script it makes them horrible prone to attack. In which case i'd rather have a payment provider who needs to secure it than every customer of the payment provider (reduces attack surface). i think paypal does good by providing this passive system and other providers should follow it, and perhaps if it's not to their liking innovate in this line instead of dumping their issues to the customer shop.
- thinkloop 9y ago> scrpt scr=paymentproviderscript.bla? They can't do this because then the untrusted merchant has access to everything again. It needs to be sandboxed in a separate page so that the customer is talking directly with the processor, with SOP, cors, https, and simply not being able to intercept PII and payment information.
- celman 9y agoThis is already possible via iframes, check out braintree payments for example.
- kennydude 9y agoMost third-party payment gateways I've worked with are like this. They usually offer some kind of "pay links" or something similar.
- darthbanane 9y agoAdyen actually provides this too, it's called Hosted Payment Pages (HPP)[1] and it's difficult to find because the documentation structure is abysmal. There's a shared secret you can use to verify the payment when they callback to you after payment, and their HPP is skinnable. [1] https://docs.adyen.com/developers/api-reference/hosted-payment-pages-api https://docs.adyen.com/developers/api-reference/hosted-payme...
- cdancette 9y agoStripe checkout does this