3 ms·
This is easily one of the best explanations of AI and explorations of its implications that I've read. Probably because I largely agree with the author, but hav
by danso 9y ago
This is easily one of the best explanations of AI and explorations of its implications that I've read. Probably because I largely agree with the author, but have never been able to express such assertions so clearly:
> These are rarely new problems; rather, the formal process of explaining our desires to a computer — the ultimate case of someone with no cultural context or ability to infer what we don’t say — forces us to be explicit in ways we generally aren’t used to.
It was also interesting to read his inside account about Google Photos's "Gorilla Incident". I had always assumed it was due to training on limited data but that just didn't make sense as Google would not have been lacking for data in 2015.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThe article is good, I agree. The line you quoted is not specific to AI/ML, it's the fundamental rule of programming (and why I absolutely love it as a tool for understanding) - the machine is the ultimate bullshit antagonist. You can't handwave away your lack of understanding of a problem, like you can do with people. And the process of trying to code a problem (e.g. for a simulation) forces you to learn just about everything you don't yet comprehend about it.
- danso 9y ago> The line you quoted is not specific to AI/ML, it's the fundamental rule of programming Very good point. Though the OP's observation comes with additional poignancy/force in the context of artificial intelligence. A lot of people are fine with the idea of machines being told explicitly what to when it comes to doing "mechanical" things. I would guess most of these laypeople do not realize that the same sausage-making process is involved when it comes to having machines do human-like things.
- natestemen 9y ago> You can't handwave away your lack of understanding of a problem well we do use packages written by others all the time which we don't necessarily need to have a complete understanding of.