5 ms·
A description of -- not a name for -- is corporate control of an open source project. Trying to keep up with Angular or Kubernetes or Go is not a problem at th
by brudgers 9y ago
A description of -- not a name for -- is corporate control of an open source project. Trying to keep up with Angular or Kubernetes or Go is not a problem at the Google from whence they come because the technologies are primarily used by and hence primarily designed for use by teams. Not individual developers.
A team's brain can schedule a time where part of it is training or studying while the rest of it is making progress on the task at hand. A team's brain can resolve ambiguity and complexity more easily because it has multiple human brains and those brains have different strengths and experiences.
A single developer can't duplicate a brain. A small team of developers can't replicate the larger multi-team brain of a Google org-chart. Google org-charts are the context for which its tools are designed. The same is true of other corporate open source technology bundles like React and AWS.
People kick themselves for not grokking technologies like Kuberentes without realizing that it wasn't really designed for their use case, isn't documented to be easy to pick up, and isn't managed with the cognitive load of individuals in mind. The time scales around which these technologies are designed are FTE-months or years.
If a two pizza team can get up to speed in a month, it means an individual will probably take about a year. Given equal cognitive efficiency.
- mancerayder 9y agoThese are excellent points and very interesting food-for-thought, the 'organizational thinking' that leads to the tools being terribly complex and steep to learn for individuals. But don't these tools have product managers, and don't product managers create tools to serve customers? The only cynical viewpoint that I can think of for artificial (or lazy) complexity is consulting dollars.
- icebraining 9y agoGoogle does consulting now?
- jweir 9y agoI disagree on Go. Go is well designed and takes upgrading into consideration. Upgrades very rarely break anything. You should just be able to recompile that 1.3 code on 1.8, etc.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bazfoo 9y agoI concur with the sentiment. The risk is still there for dependencies, but it helps that the community for the most part follows "a little copying is better than a little dependency" as an adage.
- kuschku 9y agoOn the other hand, dependency management in go in any sane way is such a byzantine task that it takes ages to get working, and even then it still doesn't. Given an empty set of environment variables, setting up a new go project with dependencies and all in a way that people cloning it later on can also use the dependencies in a single command, without vendoring dependencies, without building custom scripts, is impossible.
- bpicolo 9y agoIt's impossible with first party tools, but I've had a great experience with Glide. That said, go drives me up a wall. Using interface{} to muck with JSON and typecast every step of the way is just my nightmare. It's inelegant in every way
- sethammons 9y agoType cast every step of the way? Methinks you are either doing something wrong or dealing with unstructured json.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- digi_owl 9y agoBeen my building worry as i have watched the ongoing changes is the Linux ecosystem in recent years. It feels like thereis a echo chamber happening, where a small group of peope working for maybe 2-3 companies have decided that their vision is the correct vision. And everyone that says otherwise are haters and fossils.
- Santosh83 9y agoWell, hundreds of medium and large companies now rely critically on Linux so it was expected that slowly they will cooperate to steer its further evolution. People do respond that the whole codebase is open source and hence if some really bad change happens the community can always fork from the last known good commit. But this ignores a subtler issue: soon enough so many of the critical subsystems and so many of their contributions will come from individuals directly or indirectly working for corps that if/when those subsystems start adversely impacting the original Linux philosophy, stripping them all out and starting over again would be not much better than abandoning the whole platform. This is exactly why alternative efforts that seek to maintain working and up-to date alternative init systems, display managers and desktops are critical to the long-term health of Linux. Linux thrives on multiplicity of choices, which is anathema for corps who always want to consolidate. But that road eventually will weaken Linux for the general community and varied use cases.