4 ms·
"Beecher created a committee comprising men who already knew one another: ten doctors, one lawyer, one historian, and one theologian." I find it very sad that
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"Beecher created a committee comprising men who already knew one another: ten doctors, one lawyer, one historian, and one theologian."
I find it very sad that the people that are making these critical decisions that could affect my life are some randomly appointed panel of "experts".
Why should these people in particular have any say in the matter? Or have more say than I do about whether I live or die?
It's also sad how so much of the medical community tries to hand over the ethical decisions to others, and treats their words as inviolate truth instead of thinking for themselves.
- baxtr 9y agoWhat’s your suggestion then?
- pmoriarty 9y agoThese are just my opinions, but you asked for them... First, I'd recommend everyone (but especially people like doctors, who are in positions of trust and power) take philosophy and ethics courses so that they're better equipped to understand ethical arguments and make their own ethical decisions, without feeling that they must defer to the judgment of "experts". Second, on the specific issue of when to end care, I think that living wills (when they exist) should be respected and otherwise the judgment of the family should be respected, though the necessary course of action becomes murkier when, for example, the family is estranged from the patient or can't be reached.
- rayiner 9y agoWhen other peoples’ money is at issue, as it almost always is, the wishes of the patient or family should be given no weight (unless they’re willing to pay). That sounds callous, but it’s the humane thing to do. Money spent keeping someone alive who has no chance of recovery is money that’s stolen from the treatment of people who could benefit the most from it.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Money spent keeping someone alive who has no chance of recovery is money that’s stolen from the treatment of people who could benefit the most from it." There are people who everyone agree are alive (ie. no brain death, can communicate without problems etc) but who are suffering from a terminal illness and therefore have no hope of recovery. Should their medical care not be paid for by insurance? Would you characterize insurance money used for their care as "stolen"?
- dsacco 9y agoI think rayiner is talking about keeping braindead patients alive using life support. Assuming that’s what he meant, your example of a terminally ill but otherwise conscious patient isn’t comparable. I’d also agree that it’s mostly pointless and wasteful to keep a braindead patient alive at the hospital’s expense.
- pmoriarty 9y agoIf he thinks braindead patients without a chance for recovery should be treated differently than non-braindead patients without a chance for recovery, he should make the case for that.
- dsacco 9y agoI don’t really think that case needs to be made - you either agree with it axiomatically, or you don’t. My comment you just replied to nearly lays it out already. A terminally ill patient cannot recover, but is functionally alive. A brain dead patient cannot recovery, and is not even functionally alive. I realize this comes across as harsh, but if you’re intubating a brain dead patient, you’re just circulating air through a warm corpse. One demonstrates obvious interiority, the other doesn’t exhibit anything except basic reactions that will permanently cease within minutes, if unaided. If you want to reduce it to ethics, based on the definition of braindeath, one case involves the legitimate moral quandary of whether or not (and when) to allow a thing to die. The other case has no such moral quandary, because the thing is already (definitionally) dead. Whether or not we like doing it, our medical system depends upon us making valuations about human life, even if only implicitly. If we allocate resources to keep a functionally dead object breathing the way a human being does, we’re taking away resources from a human being that is alive. It’s not rational if you accept the axiom that a braindead human is dead.
- rflrob 9y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted here—I disagree with you, but nothing you're saying is objectively unhelpful. > I find it very sad that the people that are making these critical decisions that could affect my life is some randomly appointed panel of "experts". Two things there—first, they aren't "experts", they're just experts. These are people who had access to the best literature on what is possible and were respected in the field for their opinions. This is evidenced by the fact that the report they issued was not forced upon anyone. The 27 states that issued new definitions of death were not under some external pressure to adopt those definitions. If there was some deep controversy about the report, then it doesn't have to lead to anything. These experts were empowered to do precisely one thing—issue their opinion. That so many states adopted their opinion suggests that it was pretty good. > Why should these people in particular have any say in the matter? Or have more say than I do about whether I live or die? If you are permanently comatose, then those experts, by virtue of having thought about the issues deeply and also having viable brain function should have more say than you do while you have no brain function. If you provide advanced directives about what should be done in case of catastrophic brain damage, then that should by all means be taken into account as well. > It's also sad how so much of the medical community tries to hand over the ethical decisions to others, and treats their words as inviolate truth instead of thinking for themselves. The medical community does this because they are in an emotionally compromised position. Because they have a relationship with the person their family, they might ignore what is medically possible or likely and attempt heroic measures that would lead to huge expenses and/or lead to an undesirable outcome. Asking dispassionate outsiders for their opinions should improve the overall outcomes. I also would
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Two things there--first, they aren't "experts", they're just experts. These are people who had access to the best literature on what is possible and were respected in the field for their opinions." What makes you think these people were respected in the field for their opinions? I see no evidence of that in the article. They're just described as "men who already knew one another: ten doctors, one lawyer, one historian, and one theologian." To me that doesn't make them any more an expert than anyone else. As for "access to the best literature on what is possible", who in this era of the internet doesn't have such access? Again, this is no indication that they're an expert. Then you say that the above qualifications are "evidenced by the fact that the report they issued was not forced upon anyone. The 27 states that issued new definitions of death were not under some external pressure to adopt those definitions. If there was some deep controversy about the report, then it doesn't have to lead to anything. These experts were empowered to do precisely one thing--issue their opinion. That so many states adopted their opinion suggests that it was pretty good." Legislators pass all sorts of stupid laws all the time, often without even reading them. I don't take the lack of "deep controversy about the report" (if there really was none) to be evidence of anything but just that. The reason for such a lack could be anything from lack of publicity to having hired a good PR agency, to having biased or ignorant legislators, etc. Anyway, there's a section of the article in which even one of the "experts" admitted that he was being disengenous: "The commission’s staff philosopher, Daniel Wikler, a professor at Harvard and the first staff ethicist for the World Health Organization, told me that he didn’t think the commission’s theory of death was supported by the scientific facts it cited. "I thought it was demonstrably untrue, but so what?" he said. "I didn’t see a downside at the time." Wikler told the commission that it would be more logical to say that death occurred when the cerebrum--the center for consciousness, thoughts, and feelings, the properties essential to having a personal identity--was destroyed. His formulation would have rendered a much broader population of patients, including those who could breathe on their own, dead. "Despite Wikler’s reservations, he drafted the third chapter of the report, "Understanding the ‘Meaning’ of Death." "I was put in a tight spot, and I fudged," he told me. "I knew that there was an air of bad faith about it. I made it seem like there are a lot of profound unknowns and went in the direction of fuzziness, so that no one could say, ‘Hey, your philosopher says this is nonsense.’ That’s what I thought, but you’d never know from what I wrote." You wrote: "The medical community does this because they are in an emotionally compromised position. Because they have a relationship with the person their family, they might ignore what is medically possible or likely and attempt heroic measures that would lead to huge expenses and/or lead to an undesirable outcome." Huge expenses? How much is a life worth? And if the person is already dead, in the eyes of the doctors, what "undesirable outcome" could their measures have?
- tootie 9y agoThey weren't "random" they were experts. And their findings were never official policy which is part of the point of the story. They convened to update the medical understanding of death given new information and published their results. The official government definition came later and was less precise and has led to this current quandary.