3 ms·
I've met a backpacking couple who never filter. They fill their water bag from any deep source (lake or river) by swimming out, diving deep and filling the bag
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
I've met a backpacking couple who never filter. They fill their water bag from any deep source (lake or river) by swimming out, diving deep and filling the bag there. Because they believe most organisms live in the top few inches. Worked for them; a decade of backpacking all over the world.
On the other hand, one of our Scout leaders got giardia at Boundary Waters, due to incorrect filtration habits. So the article claiming no correlation exists may be an exaggeration.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI have heard it the other way. Supposedly UV will kill germs in the top layer of a lake so you should use that water :)
- DarronWyke 9y agoUV will kill most microbes, which is why things like the UV pens are good for purification. However you need to at least run it through a filter first to remove large particulate matter, as the UV won't penetrate into those and kill the microbes inside. Most filters also won't catch viruses and bacteria, just protocysts and dirt.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> On the other hand, one of our Scout leaders got giardia at Boundary Waters, due to incorrect filtration habits. So the article claiming no correlation exists may be an exaggeration. Am I not well educated on filtration. I did become terribly ill after drinkring unfiltered stream water. Given the outcome, I won’t ever do so again unless I’m hopelessly lost without provisions.
- troyvit 9y agoSame here. I get the feeling that whoever wrote the slate article hasn't been where we have. Filtration is worth it for my weak biome.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoIn Norway, where statistics show about 80%(!) of the population go hiking in the mountains at least once a year, almost nobody uses a filtration device. And we don't all get sick. Official advice is that drinking from streams is fine when you're not downstream from human habitation or livestock grazing areas.
- mmagin 9y agoOr these relatively cold streams harbor few parasites evolved to thrive at human body temperatures -- I would not carry this practice to warmer areas of the world.