5 ms·
Until the details are revealed, I won't buy this. It seems to have been introduced to take advantage of upcoming elections. The reason I'm skeptical about this
by allpratik 9y ago
Until the details are revealed, I won't buy this. It seems to have been introduced to take advantage of upcoming elections.
The reason I'm skeptical about this step is because there are simply no specific blueprint whatsoever. And with recent government implementations, their biggest failure turns out to be ambiguity. Good example is GST. After it's launch several month's ago, almost every big/small industry is finding it hard to get the specific details.
I highly doubt about government's ability to implement it. This insurance should have been given on basis of economical standing. Choosing a random 500M number is good for making headlines but again it is not clear on who will gain this insurance benefits?, what will be covered?, how to claim it? I foresee, "divide and rule" :p
On another note, please have a look at Sensex. It's near all time high. The reason behind such rally is not FII but DII. Infact, FII has actively removed over $20Bn since 2015. There was slight influx of FII money post two months of demonetisation but again outflow increased in following months. But still Sensex didn't crashed because of the counter balance from DII or read it as mostly mutual fund companies. Also, I had noticed an increased expenditure in mutual fund investment ads on TV and almost all types of media. And these ads were sponsored mostly by govt bodies and associations. There is nothing wrong to invest in mutual funds. But when I heard about long term and short term capital gains tax today, things got much clearer for me as to why DII raised some much cash in very short period of time.
To check the validity of above numbers, you can refer to sensex related stats on moneycontrol.com and check out the YoY sensex FII/DII activity. It has a very well explanatory chart about it.
- shripadk 9y ago> Good example is GST. After it's launch several month's ago, almost every big/small industry is finding it hard to get the specific details. I don't get what problems does industry have with regards to GST apart from simpler return filing and changes in rates. The implementation was itself smoother than expected. Just compare with other countries that implemented GST and you'll realise that it took almost 2 years for things to stabilize. Comparatively, the implementation and addressal of most issues took only few months! Today, Hasmukh Adhia also hinted at automatic preparation of GST returns and simplification of invoice entry by directly entering details into the system which is pretty amazing if you ask me. I'm actually quite happy with how GST has shaped. Especially when compared to other governmental bodies which have error prone systems. I have faced no issues filing GSTR-3B returns and with simplification of GSTR-1 and GSTR-2 I guess all worries are taken care of.
- sbmthakur 9y agoGST is only complex for people who don't have to file it.