11 ms·
New Service, Same Old Equifax: Credit Locking App Freezes Up
- username223 9y agoYou can't opt out of being stalked by these evil clowns, but there are ways to hurt them. Your employer probably uses something called "Work Number," which basically involves sending Equifax your pay stubs. When presented with repeated proof of Equifax's staggering incompetence, your company may discontinue the service. See https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/26/your-money/equifax-breach.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/26/your-money/equifax-breach... .
- jstarfish 9y agoThe Work Number is just a particular product within their Workforce Solutions employee-intelligence business unit. Pay stubs aside, if your employer uses it then they likely also have your direct deposit account, all your personal PII, and your W2s among other things. It's a goldmine for fraud.
- username223 9y agoExactly. The Work Number is a goldmine for fraud, and Equifax's guards on that mine are about as effective as a couple of guys sleeping off a hangover in the corner. Your employer should not trust them.
- moonka 9y agoI didn't know what the difference between a freeze or a lock is, but the article mentions it about halfway down. >Equifax’s new app offers a lock instead of a freeze. Locks works similarly to freezes — both restrict access to your credit file — but it should be easier to unlock your credit file since you can do it from your phone with a swipe, and doesn’t require a 10-digit pin or a fee. >What is not clear, however, is what disadvantages may come with locks. Many state laws exist that govern freezes, offering consumers protection. By creating locks, the companies avoid them. Looks like it's a nice end run around existing laws. I don't understand why they are allowed to do things like this without any consequences.
- sparky_z 9y agoI hate the credit agencies as much as anyone (and the poor quality of the app is shameful), but the "skirting the law" angle smells like an unfair criticism to me. Surely the heavy amount of regulation around credit freezes prevents an app like that from being created in the first place. The simplicity and ease of switching it on and off probably conflicts with some regulation or another. (Anybody in the know want to fact check me on that?) And it's not like they did away with freezes. They just added a alternative alongside. I've never frozen my credit because I didn't want the pain of having to unfreeze it at an inopportune moment. The concept (if not the implementation) of having locks as an alternative might convince me to actually use them. I hope it catches on.
- moonka 9y agoI think it's fair to view anything they do with suspicion after their mishandling of the leaks. They haven't shown me any reason to give them the benefit of the doubt, and ample reason not to do so.
- sparky_z 9y agoOkay, fair enough. If there's the slightest whiff of anctual wrongdoing related to the creation of credit locks, by all means, rake them over the coals. But, really, what should they have done instead? Do you think they shouldn't have implemented credit locks at all? Because I'm sure then you would get articles about how they weren't doing enough to help consumers secure their credit, just the same old inconvenient credit freezes (and I would agree). I think that, for a person's criticism to carry any weight, there has to be a course of action that that person wouldn't criticize.
- rectang 9y ago> But, really, what should they have done instead? Let me opt out, dammit. Permanently delete my data. It's not like I'm alone in that thought: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/06/your-money/credit-scores/equifax-hack.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/06/your-money/credit-scores/... "And though the words differ (and some are unprintable in this space), the messages all end with the same demand: I want out." Even better, require opt-in, thus driving the credit raters out of business. These enablers of identity theft cause more misery than they provide value, it's just inconvenient to sue them. They should not exist.
- exabrial 9y agoCredit locking app freezes up... the irony.
- hashkb 9y agoI think on the roadmap is a credit freezing app that locks up, as well.
- pasbesoin 9y agoSomebody put them down, already. And, if the U.S. presidential election had gone the other way (however you feel about that), we might currently have an effective CFPB that was on its way to forcing these companies to perform freezes for free and to place control of access (for credit assessment) into the hands of those to whom the records pertain. I don't care whether you're Democratic or Republican or Librariantarian (yeah, not real, but it should be!). This would be a good, cost effective means of at least partially mitigating a lot of current problems with related data theft and fraud / identity theft. And to the extent it added a bit of cost, that would probably impact the current uses that are least beneficial. E.g. less hits to ratings for "excessive" credit checks, when a company can't perform them without first soliciting access from the target.
- superioritycplx 9y ago>if the U.S. presidential election had gone the other way ...then we'd be too busy waging wars overseas.
- djrogers 9y ago>if the U.S. presidential election had gone the other way (however you feel about that), we might currently have an effective CFPB that was on its way to forcing these companies to perform freezes What on earth gives you the impression that either party cares about personal data privacy or free credit freezes? They’re both happy as long as the debt-driven economy continues to roll...
- flaque 9y agoThe CFPB (consumer financial protection bureau) was the brainchild of Elizabeth Warren and implemented under Obama. It was and still is heavily disliked by numerous Republican members and is being stripped of a lot if it’s powers by the current administration. Claiming “both parties are the same” is just false in this case.
- partycoder 9y agoSoftware can be shipped at any level of completion. Initially, software could only be distributed over physical media like disks. And because of this, it had to be stable enough. Today, software is distributed over the internet, and you can amend mistakes. This has enabled the release broken of software, that over time becomes better. This doctrine is seen as efficient, but is not good faith and not the best interest of the user in some cases (e.g: Equifax).
- anonacct37 9y ago> This has enabled the release broken of software, Yes. > that over time becomes better. Debatable.
- paulie_a 9y agoWhy would anyone install their app?
- patcheudor 9y agoFreezing and locking up would be preferable to what their last mobile application did: https://www.fastcompany.com/40468811/heres-why-equifax-yanked-its-apps-from-apple-and-google-last-week https://www.fastcompany.com/40468811/heres-why-equifax-yanke...