7 ms·
Writing this from a squeaky recliner set beside my wife’s bed in the oncology department of a local research hospital. Three weeks ago she had a radical hyster
by jcims 9y ago
Writing this from a squeaky recliner set beside my wife’s bed in the oncology department of a local research hospital.
Three weeks ago she had a radical hysterectomy and partial lymphadenectomy to treat stage IIIc ovarian cancer, and we’re back to try to aid her in her recovery to prepare for chemotherapy. Chemo should start next week, but we are hoping to also participate in a clinical trial for atezolizumab. This is a drug that essentially blocks the cancer cell’s immunosuppressive mechanism (expression of PD-L1) and allows the body’s natural immune response to do work on the disease.
Suddenly inspired to learn more of the nitty gritty around how cancer and the associated therapies work, I’m shocked at how sophisticated the battle is. At least in this case, the unregulated reproduction of cells is just the beginning, and my lay mind can’t grasp how simple mutation is responsible for it. If someone told me cancer was sentient with a will to thrive, I’m now much less inclined to laugh them off.
Therapies that arm our own immune syatem in the fight against this monster really seem like the light at the end of the long, dark tunnel.
- agumonkey 9y agoI had the same reaction after hearing about the warburg effect. Basically the synergy of all the bugs that are necessary and maintained by cancerous tissue for it to avoid dying, it's eerie. I hope your morale is as high as possible, faith and energy are useful to help your loved ones heal in order to endure side effects of treatments. Also it seems immunotherapies are often well supported by patients across the board, so hopefully it will be easier to fight.
- wiz21c 9y agoFor some reason I wanted to study what cancer and therapies are all about. I reached the same conclusion as yours. The thing is incredibly complex and thus fascinating. After 20 years in IT, I'm seriously considering moving back to university to work on that. All the best for your wife.
- hunta2097 9y agoIf you haven't already read it, "The Emperor of All Maladies" (B004MPR80E) is a really great book about the history of Cancer and Cancer-like diseases. The author concludes the autoimmune system is key to beating cancer. Be strong, be lucky and hang in there.
- epmaybe 9y agoSiddhartha Mukherjee is a fantastic author. If you liked Emperor of All Maladies, check out The Gene: An Intimate History.
- jcims 9y agoI bought Gene after litening to him on Sam Harris’ podcast (just looked it up, episode 77). Definitely worth a listen, he’s an equally impressive conversationalist. Love him or hate him, Sam’s no slouch either and I left the end of it wishing I had a brain.
- kup0 9y agoI'm curious if there will can ways to use the autoimmune system to fight cancer in people with autoimmune diseases. Knowing someone with RA that has had cancer in the past it really complicates things because stimulating the immune system flares up RA. Often RA treatments involve suppressing the immune system.
- superb_herb 9y agoWhat a horrific double whammy — an autoimmune disease AND cancer.
- baldfat 9y agoSo sorry to hear your story. Cancer just plan old sucks. It has impacted my family and one of my adopted children. My mom had pancreatic cancer (The deadliest of cancers) in 2017 and she is absolutely fine and cancer free a year later. Numbers don't mean anything to the individual and don't look them up is always my recommendation. As a non-medically trained support member I have gotten pretty good in talking with the doctors about my family members cancers. I help explain them to others in my family and when I sit in the conversations with the doctors I stop them talking to make sure the patient is taking it in and understanding. I have unfortunately worked with many doctors and I have never had a negative experience with one when I stop them and ask the patient do you under stand and have them repeat what they heard. I even did this with my son when he was 8 because it was his body. I would than have a notebook and have them write down their questions throughout the day for when the doctors showed up (Usually around 6 or 7 AM) I encourage everyone that enters the cancer world, as either a parent, spouse or close friend, to learn everything they can. The more you learn the madder I get at cancer research and specifically about pediatric cancer research. There is a Radio Lab Podcast and it got pretty intense for me to listen but I also understood cancer at a much better concise way after listening to this and specifically how cancer spreads. http://www.radiolab.org/story/91714-devil-tumors/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/91714-devil-tumors/ Three piece of information I always give to everyone: 1) The most important staff member of any doctor or surgeon is the Nurse Practitioner. They are the Master Sargent of that practice. Get their contact information and always make sure they are informed of what is happening. 2) Never assume that the different doctors are communicating, because 90% of the time they don't. Not between the surgeon and oncologist and even residents to other residents. Always ask question to make sure they know what is happening to you. Your the one making sure the different silos are talking. 3) Have two people you can call if you have any concerns. You get a gut feeling you don't ignore it. Doctors miss things all the time and you call that person that you trust. My mom started coughing after surgery and I knew it was serious. Two doctors from the surgeon's team show up and basically don't think it is serious. In the room I calmly said that we both have concerns and think someone else needs to see this. They were figuring out someone else to come to look at her. In the mean time I walked out of the room and called the surgeons nurse practitioner directly and state that I thought my mom's vocal cords were paralyzed, which I already ask the two doctors if they thought that was the issue. We were in the ICU within 10 minutes after that call and we were there for 4 days. My mom's voice came back 2 weeks later, she is a license counselor and her voice is her job. The thing is have a plan on who you can call if you get scared about something.
- mark212 9y agoMy wife and I are about one year ahead of you with the same diagnosis, currently fighting a recurrence. Keep fighting, stay positive. (And yes the science is astounding and rapidly developing.)
- jcims 9y agoThank you brother. Best wishes to you and yours as well, may you come out the other side even stronger in your relationship to each other and your collective resolve to squeeze every drop out of this life we've been graced.
- kkartik 9y agoReplied earlier, same to you. ---- Sorry to know of your situation. If you want to learn more about a trial in this space (currently enrolling) let me know, I can help.
- bradleyjg 9y agoMy best friend is 8 years and counting with stage III (not sure about the sub-stage) ovarian. Both of you, hang in there!
- chiefalchemist 9y agoMy thoughts and prayers to your wife, you, and your families. My question is: if we boost the immune system, what are the side effects? Is an immune system that's compromised (e.g., loses battle with cancer) indicative of other problems? In other words, in a way, is cancer actually a symptom? Good luck. And God's speed.
- jonloldrup 9y agoAs to the side effects of immune activation, here's a long article on that: https://healthcareinamerica.us/did-chinese-scientists-find-autisms-missing-puzzle-piece-2d50be5b9122 https://healthcareinamerica.us/did-chinese-scientists-find-a...
- hwillis 9y agoSqueeze her hand for a stranger. Every person who has lost someone to cancer, and everyone who has survived it, and all of the people who watched that fight- all of us have her back and stand with her. She's fighting one of the hardest battles put to a person, and she has our respect and awe. I saw my friend at his weakest, and also when he was stronger than anyone I've ever known. It's been years but still, I'm crying. Cancer is personal. Once it touches you, and you see the enemy, you see how everyone is fighting your enemy. I'm grateful to her. We'll be cheering when the bell rings for her- all of us. Fuck cancer.
- jcims 9y agoThanks so much for this heartfelt comment. The personification of cancer as an enemy didn't really click with me until my family was directly threatened by it. Reading through the drugs in her chemo cocktail, I come across bevacizumab. A little bit of googling and: A cancer needs a good blood supply to provide itself with food and oxygen and to remove waste products. When it has reached 1 to 2mm across, a tumour needs to grow its own blood vessels in order to continue to get bigger. Some cancer cells make a protein called vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF). The VEGF protein attaches to receptors on cells that line the walls of blood vessels within the tumour. The cells are called endothelial cells. *This triggers the blood vessels to grow so the cancer can then grow.* Wait...what?!?! OK, what about this trial...atezzolblablblah.. What's it do? Programmed cell death protein 1 is a cell surface receptor that plays an important role in down- regulating the immune system and promoting self tolerance by suppressing T cell inflammatory activity. PD-1 is an immune checkpoint and guards against autoimmunity through a dual mechanism of promoting programmed cell death in T-cells in lymph nodes while simultaneously reducing cell death in regulatory T cells. ... PD-L1, the ligand for PD1, is highly expressed in several cancers *and hence the role of PD1 in cancer immune evasion is well established*. Seriously? This thing isn't just some dumb pathogen floating around that just DoSes your body. It's digging tunnels and cutting phone lines. It has strategy.
- stochastic_monk 9y agoThis cancer is being evolutionarily selected for proliferation and resistance to regulation. It is being constantly engineered to destroy. See also epithelial to mesenchymal (ETM) transition, in which cells lose their anchors and become an entirely different kind of cell so that it can better infiltrate other parts of the body. It's pernicious and highly specialized because that's why it survives. And that's why everyone will die of cancer if something else doesn't kill you first.
- pharaohgeek 9y agoCancer is a horrible disease. And the current treatments are barbaric. As someone who just finished chemo a year ago, I can't wait for treatments like this to become effective and more mainstream. Best of luck to your wife, and tell her to stay strong!
- kkartik 9y agoSorry to know of your situation. If you want to learn more about a trial in this space (currently enrolling) let me know, I can help.
- jcims 9y agoAlways interested in learning our options, thank you!
- kkartik 9y agoSorry for the delay. I don't check HN often. Pls email me on kkartik@gmail.com with subject line Ovarian Cancer Trial. I can put you in touch with the Professor conducting it. https://today.uconn.edu/school-stories/recruitment-begins-worlds-first-ovarian-cancer-vaccine-trial/ https://today.uconn.edu/school-stories/recruitment-begins-wo...
- nsxwolf 9y agoA different monoclonal antibody treatment successfully treated my grandfather’s lymphoma 10 years ago. It had spread to occupy large portions of his lungs and this treatment was nothing short of miraculous. We watched in awe as the tumors shrunk away. I hope it works as well for her.
- lr4444lr 9y agoI don't like to pry, but since my father had rare inoperable non-metastatic brain lymphoma and I have genetic concerns, is he still alive? What is his prognosis? How did he tolerate the treatment? (My apologies if it's too personal to discuss.)
- nsxwolf 9y agoHe passed away a few years ago from congestive heart failure at 97. But he enjoyed a good last 10 years cancer free. He tolerated the treatment very well.
- bitwize 9y agoHope your wife pulls through. Shit's gotta be rough.
- WilliamSt 9y agoIf you haven't already, read: Tripping Over the Truth: The Return of the Metabolic Theory of Cancer Illuminates a New and Hopeful Path to a Cure (ISBN: 9781603587303). It is a great review of the history of Cancer. It concludes that the reason for the failed war against cancer stems from a flawed paradigm that categorizes cancer as an exclusively genetic disease and explores therapies born from the emerging metabolic theory of cancer.
- edgesrazor 9y agoWishing you both all the best.
- cryoshon 9y agoas a former scientist in immunotherapy/immunooncology research: we are going to win against cancer. and very importantly for you and your wife, many of us consider the PD-1 therapies as the biggest battles and biggest victories that we've ever won against cancer. it is extremely difficult to overstate how powerful the anti-PD-1/L1 biologics are. and it's also extremely hard to overstate how much research scientists in the field live and breathe and toil to harness nature. you have a care staff of perhaps a dozen at the hospital, but just remember that there are tens of thousands of people working day and night to find better therapies and cures. nature is always throwing us curveballs, and in the words of rich feynman, "she's never gonna let us relax." but we'll figure it out, and win. in the meantime, that clinical trial you mentioned is investigating the true power of our biggest achievement to date. it isn't ethical to push your wife into the trial, so i'll just say this: if i had serious cancer, i'd find more than one anti-PD-1/L1 trial to try to enroll in simultaneously. that way if i got excluded from one because i didn't meet the criteria, i have a next step in hand without thinking about it any more. if by chance i got into more than one, i'd withdraw from the others (obviously). just my two cents. good luck.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stryk 9y agoI wish the best for you and your loved ones, and genuinely hope your wife beats the shit out of this cancer and I hope she beats it so badly that it never returns. My mother went through ovarian cancer, including the hysterectomies, chemo, and associated therapies. I wish I could tell you it was easy, but I would be lying, it's not. Incidentally, at least for my mother, the injections she would get shortly after her chemo treatments -- if I remember right these were referred to as "white cell-count booster shots" although I don't remember their actual medical terminology -- these left her feeling far worse than the actual chemotherapy. It most affected her appetite, namely she didn't have one for 3-4 days after getting the injections. We tried everything the doctors and nurses recommended, and a few that the internet recommended [don't do this, but we were desperate], all to no avail. Finally, I talked her into smoking a joint -- and this woman never drank anything other than communion wine or did any drugs in her 55+ years of life before this. Appetite problem solved. It was back in spades, almost like never before. I guess what I'm saying is, if your wife finds herself with the same issues [and I hope she does not] never mind the 'stigma' associated with it -- weed works.
- FiveSquared 9y agoStay strong!
- f_cancer 9y agoI’m sitting in the operating waiting room as I type this while my wife is getting her uterus and right ovary removed, the tumor that consumed the left ovary having been found to be clear cell carcinoma. Her surgeon thinks it was caught at Stage Ia, thank god, but still—fuck cancer so so hard. Very best of luck to you and your wife.
- itchyouch 9y agoApologies to hear about your wife's cancer. Hope the best of luck fighting to fight. For adjuvant therapies for cancer, I highly recommend looking into sulforaphane. Dr. Rhonda Patrick has a tremendous corpus of scientific research and plenty of anecdata on the internet about how it is helpful and has helped others with cancer.
- karmajunkie 9y agoEchoing the other sentiments here for you and your wife—this is the club nobody wants to join, but we all want to give you a big hug. Its a shitty, scary fight, but some of the therapies coming out now are truly amazing in their potential. My own wife was diagnosed with an immune-mediated cancer a few years ago, and I went pretty deep into the research when that happened. 10 years ago, her diagnosis (melanoma IIIa) had a pretty discouraging prognosis based purely on stats. Today, they're going to have to rewrite a lot of textbooks around those stats. Hang in there, and don't forget to take care of yourself too. Being in the role of caregiver is fucking exhausting at times. If you're like me, it falls to us to be the shield against well-meaning but poorly informed acquaintances shilling this herbal remedy or that metabolic supplement or this fantastic ketogenic diet backed by the research of some doctor nobody's heard of because Big Pharma... Just nod and smile and say you'll look into that and give them the middle finger in your minds eye. Try and find some support system, whether its a caregivers group or friends who have been through it, or even friends who haven't that you can still vent to. There's a lot coming at you, and more to come. Its ok to take some time for yourself some too. Best wishes, man—I'll be thinking about your family.
- vonseel 9y agoLost my mom 19 years ago to cancerous brain tumors. She was 46 years old (I was 10). Her loss ripped my family apart. Each family's experience is unique and I can't begin to imagine what it's like to fight the sickness for years. My heart goes out to the OP's family, and anyone else with an unforgiving disease. I am not a religious man, but I wish your wife the best of luck in her recovery.
- adbachman 9y agoWe’re 7 years on from stage 1b, similarly drastic surgery (“the works”), eternally grateful that we had kids before. No recurrence but we’ll be watching and waiting forever. My wife is still the youngest person at her doctor’s office by ~20 years so it’s a long goddamn road ahead. I knew cancer was bad and had a lot of research surrounding it, but I was blown away by the uncertainty for patients and the incredible amount of resources put into solving/treating the disease and supporting the people going through it. After immunization, chemotherapy is probably the most important medical discovery in human history. If immunotherapy can carry us past that, how amazing! The immunosuppressive therapies are new since we went through treatment and I’m hopeful. If or when we have to fight again, we’ll have new weapons, I’m optimistic. I hope you find strength, comfort, and support enough to be a support for your wife. Others have gone through it, empathize, and are rooting for you. Fuck cancer.