4 ms·
I was trying to find what does happen physically according to you. For the time being, you've only explained what does not happen ("measurement does not cause t
by kgwgk 9y ago
I was trying to find what does happen physically according to you. For the time being, you've only explained what does not happen ("measurement does not cause the collapse of the wave function",
"When you measure a particle, nothing happens to that particle as a result of the measurement.").
Reading your paper I thought something happened, somewhere in the transition from page 6 to page 7, because I understood that you were getting a well-defined value out of the measurement. The paper you linked now makes clear that in this model nothing happens at all, ever. Anything less than the wave function for the whole universe is just an illusion, there is no classical world.
It's not an accident that your description looked like the standard measurement scheme from von Neumann, as they are just reproducing it. They seem to think that when von Neumann described the measurement process as an interaction of two quantum systems he didn't notice that this interaction was beyond the classical concept of correlations, and this is why he needed a second stage to perform the measurement and collapse the state vector.
In the pre-measurement step, the 'target' (system to be measured, with states |u> and |d>) and the 'probe' (quantum detector, with states |+> and |->) are combined. This system will be a superposition of the states |u,+> and |d,->. The density matrix includes the diagonal terms |u,+><u,+| and |d,-><d,-| and also the diagonal terms |u,+><d,-| and |d,-><u,+|.
Von Neumann introduces a projection step which keeps only the diagonal terms. The resulting density matrix is no longer a pure state but a mixed state (for a closed system, pure states correspond to eigenvalues of the density matrix and then a diagonal matrix has to represent a classical mixture of the corresponding pure states and cannot be a superposition). After the measurement following von Neumann we have a statistical ensemble of the possible outcomes and choosing one of them doesn't pose any conceptual problem.
Cerf and Adami avoid the second step by taking the entangled system, ignoring the state of the target and looking only at the probe. Mathematically, one obtains a reduced density matrix by tracing out one subsystem and the result is a diagonal density matrix which contains only |+><+| and |-><-| without any interference terms. However, this is an improper mixed state and cannot be interpreted as before (because it's not the description of a full system but the result of looking at a subsystem).
Their reduced density matrix does not represent a defined (but unknown) state because the subsystem remains entangled with the rest of the system (target+probe). They say that the full system continues to evolve in a unitary way without any kind of collapse, but then how is any measurement done at all? Their description of the detector is an (improper) mixture of |+> and |->, at what point do we get one or the other as a result?
Note that Cerf and Adami consider their model completely unrelated to Zurek's. Decoherence and einselection are interesting, provide a physical mechanism to explain how the interference terms become (close to) zero in the "correct" basis in a (practically) irreversible way, and have some experimental support. But it doesn't completely solve the problem of measurement: how does the system settle on one particular outcome?
- lisper 9y agoBefore I respond I would like to say that this interaction is tremendously helpful for me. You obviously know what you're talking about, and I appreciate you taking the time to engage on this. If you don't mind, I'd like to learn more about who you are IRL. If you want to do that off-line my contact info is in my profile. But to answer your question: > at what point do we get one or the other as a result? That is like asking "at what point does a blastocyst become a fully fledged human being?" There is no sharp dividing line between the quantum and the classical. There is not "point" at which the one transitions sharply to the other. There is a range beyond which the classical approximation is good enough for all practical purposes, but the physical world never "actually becomes" classical, just as gravity never "actually becomes" Newtonian. > Cerf and Adami consider their model completely unrelated to Zurek's I'm not sure that "completely unrelated" is a fair characterization. I think they would regard it as an "improvement". (But they are both still alive. We could ask them.) BTW, you might want to read this: http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar... and its precursor: http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/09/are-parallel-universes-real.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/09/are-parallel-universes-re... It may or may not answer any of your questions, but I would be very interested in your feedback either way. (And keep in mind that this was written for a lay audience.)
- kgwgk 9y agoOn the relation to decoherence, maybe "completely unrelated" is too strong but they say their model is "distinct from" and "not in the class of" environment-induced decoherence models. I think it's debatable if it is an "improvement" or not, but I don't think they get any closer to "solving" the measurement problem than Zurek does. I find interesting that London and Bauer proposed a similar model already in 1939 (ref. [12] in the "Quantum mechanics of measurement" pre-print): [9. Statistics of a System Composed of Two Subsystems] "The state of a closed system, perhaps the entire universe, is completely determined for all time if it is known at a given instant. According to Schroedinger's equation, a pure case represented by a psi function remains always a pure case. One does not immediately see any occasion for the introduction of probabilities, and our statistics definitions might appear in the theory as a foreign structure "We will see that that is not the case. It is true that the state of a closed system, once given pure, always remains pure. But let us study what happens when one puts into contact two systems, both originally in pure states, and afterwards separates them. [...] "While the combined system I + II, which we suppose isolated from the rest of the world, is and remains in a pure state, we see that during the interaction systems I and II individually transform themselves from pure cases into mixtures. "This is a rather strange result. In classical mechanics we are not astonished by the fact that a maximal knowledge of a composite system implies a maximal knowledge of all its parts. We see that this equivalence, which might have been considered trivial, does not take place in quantum mechanics. [...] "The fact that the description we obtain for each of the two individual systems does not have the caracter of a pure case warns us that we are renouncing part of the knowledge contained in Psi(x,y) when we calculate probabilities for each of the two individuals separately. [...] This loss of knowledge expresses itself by the appearance of probabilities, now understood in the ordinary sense of the word, as expression of the fact that our knowledge about the combined system is not maximal." [10. Reversible and Irreversible Evolution] "I. Reversible or "causal" transformations. These take place when the system is isolated. [...] "II. Irreversible transformations, which one might also call "acausal." These take place only when the system in question (I) makes physical contact with another system (II). The total system, comprising the two systems (I + II), again in this case undergoes a reversible transformation so long as the combined system I + II is isolated. But if we fix our attention on system I, this system will undergo an irreversible transformation. If it was in a pure state before the contact, it will ordinarily be transformed into a mixture. [...] "We shall see specifically that measurement processes bring about an irreversible transformation of the state of the measured object [...] The transition from P to P' clearly cannot be represented by a unitary transformation. It is associated with an increase of the entropy from 0 to -k Sum_n |psi_n|^2 ln |psi_n|^2, which cannot come about by a unitary transformation." [11. Measurement and Observation. The Act of Objectification] "According to the preceding section, [the wave function after the measurement] represents a state of the combined system that has for each separate system, object and apparatus, the character of a mixture. [...] But of course quantum mechanics does not allow us to predict which value will actually be found in the measurement. The interaction with the apparatus does not put the object into a new pure state. Alone, it does not confer on the object a new wave function. [...] "So far we have only coupled one apparatus with one object. But a coupling, even with a measuring device, is not yet a measurement. A measurement is achieved only when the position of the pointer has been observed. It is precisely this increase of knowledge, aquired by observation, that gives the observer the right to choose among the different components of the mixture predicted by the theory, to reject those which are not observed, and to attribute henceforth to the object a new wave function, that of the pure case which he has found." They go on to discuss how "the observer establishes his own framework of objectivity and acquires a new piece of information about the object in question" while there is no change for us if we look at the "object + apparatus + observer" system from outside. The combined system will be in a pure state and we will have correlated mixtures for each subsystem. London and Bauer say that the role played by consciousness of the observer is essential for the transition from the mixture to the pure case. Cerf and Adami claim to do without the intervention of consciousness but it's not clear how do they explain the transtion from the mixture to something else. They say things like the following, which doesn't look different from London and Bauer to me: "The observer notices that the cat is either dead or alive, and thus the observer’s own state becomes classically correlated with that of the cat, although, in reality, the entire system (including the atom, the γ, the cat, and the observer) is in a pure entangled state." From a very superficial look at the blog posts you linked to, I think I agree with some things (v.g. that most of this ideas have been around for quite some time), I disagree with others (v.g. that there is no measurement problem) but I guess most of the discussion is meta-physical so it cannot be "wrong". I think dodging the measurement problem is not solving it. The core of the problem is here: "But, while QM predicts that you will be classically correlated, it does NOT (and cannot) predict what the outcome of your measurements will actually be." QM does not predict that the measurement will have an outcome. The transition from that probability distribution to one definite result is the measurement problem.