4 ms·
So far, all of the gloom and doom scenarios from the repeal of net neutrality have failed to emerge. More people have been inconvenienced by the pro net-neutral
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
So far, all of the gloom and doom scenarios from the repeal of net neutrality have failed to emerge. More people have been inconvenienced by the pro net-neutrality protesters than have been harmed or inconvenienced due to ISP action post-repeal.
These net-neutrality protesters are akin to the anti-fur protesters running around throwing blood on people. It may make them feel good about their virtue and that they are doing something, but it is unlikely to change minds.
- claytonjy 9y agoDid you expect downsides to be realized both completely and immediately? I think some of the doom scenarios were far overblown, but surely it's far too early to claim the naysayers were totally wrong.
- pyre 9y ago> So far, all of the gloom and doom scenarios from the repeal of net neutrality have failed to emerge How quickly do you expect these things to happen? Overnight? This isn't Hollywood. The moment the decision is made storm clouds don't appear overhead to signify the ominous direction that things have gone.
- TehCorwiz 9y agoYet. They know it would be suicide to implement anything like that while it's so fresh in people's minds. Just because they haven't doesn't mean that they won't. It was famously said (although by whom is debated) that 'Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.' To prevent the feared negative consequences we need to keep the public engaged and educated on the topic.
- wtallis 9y agoDraconian throttling is not step one of any sane business plan to exploit a lack of net neutrality regulation. The first phase is to start soliciting the protection payments from your intended victims, and that's not a very public process. Actually following through on the threats of throttling is a lower priority, and takes time to deploy.
- eesmith 9y ago"More people have been inconvenienced by the pro net-neutrality protesters than have been harmed or inconvenienced due to ISP action post-repeal." As I understand it, the repeal order hasn't yet taken effect. If nothing has changed (yet) then of course no one has been harmed or inconvenienced by it, which would make your argument pointless. My understanding is that there was a vote to repeal in December. The final order was published in the Federal Register on January 4, 2018. It then takes 60 days until the repeal order takes effect.
- 0xfeba 9y agoISPs have been sued multiple times in the past for throttling traffic. Examples are not hard to find. The fact that dial-up ISPs are still required to submit to NN, but cable-based ones are not seems odd, wouldn't you think?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> So far, all of the gloom and doom scenarios from the repeal of net neutrality have failed to emerge. With the repeal being challenged in the courts and states adopting net neutrality policies by law and executive action, ISPs are unlikely to make major changes outside of what they were doing for the decade+ when neutrality, enforced by different means, was FCC policy is until the legal landscape is more clear, even once the repeal formally takes effect (which, barring a preliminary injunction, it will in, IIRC, mid-March.) So, yeah, barring an ISP deciding to take a huge risk by setting up an extreme test case in an uncertain legal environment, the full effect (or even any major effect) is unlikely to be felt for quite a while.
- andymal 9y agohttps://www.vox.com/2017/12/14/16774148/net-neutrality-repeal-explained https://www.vox.com/2017/12/14/16774148/net-neutrality-repea... Read #7. The repeal has not taken effect yet.