2 ms·
This is something I've wondered about when people start talking about capturing asteroids in Earth orbit and mining them. Mining is typically a dirty activity
by jandrese 9y ago
This is something I've wondered about when people start talking about capturing asteroids in Earth orbit and mining them. Mining is typically a dirty activity and most asteroids are more like a loose collection of gravel to begin with, and have such pitiful escape velocity that keeping them together is going to be a significant challenge. One high energy impact from an errant asteroid could make a tremendous mess in whatever orbit they are using, and to the extent that orbital mining makes sense at all it almost has to happen in LEO if you want to use the products on Earth or benefit from labor/equipment being launched from Earth.
- Symmetry 9y agoYou could plausibly get a nearby asteroid into a wide orbit of the Earth for 500 m/s of delta v. But getting it from there all the way down to LEO would take 3 km/s. So I expect most asteroid mining would take place fairly far out as a practical matter since the products of mining would be lighter and easier to move. The main downside would be days of travel time to and from the mining site. And there is a market for the products of asteroid mining in GEO in the form of commsats who might want to be refueled or someday maybe even have some parts make from asteroid stuff.
- jandrese 9y agoRefueling GEOs will probably never be profitable. They already last for 15+ years and are replaced by much improved satellites when they are retired. Keeping an old one running isn't worth it because the orbital slots they are in are too expensive. IMHO, asteroid mining only makes sense if you are also manufacturing things in orbit (like spaceships and orbital colonies). All of these plans to deorbit the mined materials are crazy talk IMHO. Even if you find some amazing near solid platinum asteroid nearly in orbit already the costs of mining it and bringing the material back to Earth make it extremely difficult to compete against terrestrial mining. If you are actually manufacturing stuff, then you are much more free to choose your orbit. You can even choose to orbit the moon instead to reduce the possibility of disaster.