3 ms·
This line of reasoning suggests that euthanizing the elderly is a net saving, which is quite a dangerous direction.
by tinus_hn 9y ago
This line of reasoning suggests that euthanizing the elderly is a net saving, which is quite a dangerous direction.
- probablynot 9y agoI feel like it's several steps removed from that. All of civilization is about weighing cost versus benefits -- there's no reason to assume we'd cut old people loose first over the disabled.
- ben_w 9y agoOnly when “saving money” is the entirety of your decision-making does that become dangerous. Ultimately, money is only useful when spent — and despite intergenerational cultural difference, I think quite a lot of younger people like myself still want to be in a society that spends some of its wealth looking after the elderly.
- MaysonL 9y ago"All Social Security and Medicare need to become totally solvent for the next century is one good flu epidemic." /s
- zaroth 9y agoOf course a rote analysis would show tremendous cost savings to just denying everyone health care or insurance coverage after the age of ___, if all you are counting is the dollars spent to extend life versus the economic productivity measured as annual income over the years that person's life was extended. The glaring and obvious problem with such a naive analysis is the associated costs to society of actually implementing such a program. We can conclude that smokers aren't exerting a net direct cost to the health care system due to their smoking, while simultaneously concluding that it's in the interest of public health and overall society to reduce smoking. Just don't tell me you're doing it as a cost saving measure!