3 ms·
I'm not a huge fan of The Verge and Vox, but this is clearly amoral - I'm not sure any reasonable argument could be made for involving someone in a sexual situa
by nailer 9y ago
I'm not a huge fan of The Verge and Vox, but this is clearly amoral - I'm not sure any reasonable argument could be made for involving someone in a sexual situation without their consent.
I'd expect the law to catch up soon, and that to happen after the issue is made more common once Reddit's non-consensual deepfakes goes more viral than it already has.
Edit: replying to the flagged response below, which I disagree with but which I think deserves a reply:
By immoral, I mean hurting other people without consent. I do not believe any activity that doesn't hurt other people is immoral, though I understand some people (orthodox religious people for example) do.
Someone masturbating to an image - a private mental image, or even a private image produced for their personal use with software - seems fine. But publishing a sexual image of someone else clearly does involve the person.
- golergka 9y agoYou're jumping from argument about something being "amoral" to the law - why? Thankfully, we don't expect the law to govern all this moral and immoral. Also, you're calling this "involving someone in a sexual situation" - but said someone is not involved, only his or her image is. By that logic, masturbating to someone's publicly available photos should be made illegal to the exactly same extent.
- Veen 9y ago> involving someone in a sexual situation without their consent That's rather a broad definition of "involving someone in a sexual situation". I think it's amoral too, but I don't think it's a sexual consent issue. My intuition is that it has more to do with inauthenticity and coopting a person's likeness, their public reputation. You could do the same sort of thing to have people endorse political candidates or products against their will.
- nailer 9y ago> That's rather a broad definition of "involving someone in a sexual situation". Why? The situation is clearly sexual. The person whose image is used is clearly involved. > You could do the same sort of thing to have people endorse political candidates or products against their will. You could make a video of comsone endorsing a political candidate that they don't endorse, label it prominently as a fake, and it woulnd't have much effect - nobody would be misled. Whereas publishing a video, labelled as fake, of someone engaging in a sex act they didn't actually engage in still arouses people.
- nailer 9y agoRe-reading your post, I just realised by 'sexual consent' you meant rape. I'm not comparing this to rape at all, I mean consent as in consent. Same as the political didn't consent to being videoed or the model didn't consent to be used in the documentary.
- Veen 9y agoI still have the same disagreement with your point. The person is not being involved in a sexual situation. A person is not the same thing as a representation of a person. An image or representation is being involved in a sexual situation, the person is not. It's an important distinction to make because the language we use affects how we think and argue about the wrong being done and what should happen to punish or prevent it. I think we agree that it's a shitty thing to do with someone's image, and it will become more shitty as the technology improves to the point at which it's difficult to tell the fake from the real.
- Slansitartop 9y ago> I'm not a huge fan of The Verge and Vox, but this is clearly amoral - I'm not sure any reasonable argument could be made for involving someone in a sexual situation without their consent. Do you really mean "amoral" or did you intend to use "immoral" instead?
- nailer 9y agoI meant amoral. See the first definition in the OED, at https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/amoral https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/amoral
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I'm not a huge fan of The Verge and Vox, but this is clearly amoral I think you mean “immoral” (which you use in your added material at the end.) “Amoral” is usually used of a person rather than an act, but it means “not concerned with morality” rather than “contrary to morality”. If it were to make any sense applied to an act, it would designate an act with no (positive or negative) moral status in itself, which doesn't seem to be your claim here.
- PeterisP 9y agoAfter the edit your comment makes a lot of sense. I'm thinking of this in context of handmade drawings. It would be (as far as I know) generally permissible for me to make a lewd, sexualized, perverted drawing with your face, as accurate as I'm able to draw, and look at it with whatever thoughts I might have. However, publicizing this image has quite different norms. Those may be different for different people (for example, distributing caricatures of public figures such as politicians, presidents and other figures of power, e.g. Pope, Mohammad, etc should be allowed even if normal people are not), but they certainly would be much more restrictive than the actual making of such depictions.
- nailer 9y agoThanks and agreed completely with your 'However, publicizing this image has quite different norms' point.