4 ms·
Can a US city legally apply economic sanctions to another US city in another state, or would that be considered as affecting "interstate commerce" and preempted
by geofft 9y ago
Can a US city legally apply economic sanctions to another US city in another state, or would that be considered as affecting "interstate commerce" and preempted or something?
- pm90 9y agoI don't think US cities have that kind of power. Sanctions are considered a diplomatic tool when dealing b/w Sovereign Powers; City Governments can argue their dispute in US courts and get a binding resolution that both need to follow.
- buttcoinslol 9y agoDo you really think a city council/mayor has the power to enforce sanctions on another city? Generally, it's nation-states with armies that enforce sanctions, otherwise the target of the sanctions just says "Uh, no."
- danielvf 9y agoIt's already going on! PROHIBITION ON STATE-FUNDED AND STATE-SPONSORED TRAVEL TO STATES WITH DISCRIMINATORY LAWS (https://oag.ca.gov/ab1887 https://oag.ca.gov/ab1887) In effect, this law means that if any member of California government picks a contractor / supplier / conference in North Carolina, then that person has to pay for any related travel out of their own pocket. The idea is that this will hugely disincentize any one in the California government from doing business with companies located in North Carolina. I guess we'll have to see if there's ever a legal challenge to it.
- tptacek 9y agoThe law you posted prohibits the state of California from requiring that any of its own employees travel to a discriminating state, excepting a very broad list of essential purposes. I don't see the contractor thing you're referring to. You also seem to be describing a case where California is a direct market participant (they're paying the contractors). States are allowed to discriminate in favor of their own citizens (or, I guess, anyone else) when they themselves participate in the market.
- danielvf 9y agoYes, possibly legal. Still a form of economic sanctions though. It's not just that they don't require employees to travel there, they also don't pay for trips "This bill would prohibit a state agency from ... approving a request for state-funded or state-sponsored travel to ..." The bill doesn't explicitly forbid government employees (and by extension, the government of California) from doing business with North Carolina - it just adds personal, out-of-pocket cost for doing so. (which probably amounts to the same effect.)
- tptacek 9y agoIn the scenario you propose, California isn't prohibited from paying to fly NC contractors to CA. Travel from a prohibited state, including the return flight back, shall be construed as travel “to” the original destination.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- amyjess 9y agoIt also means that public universities in California can't send their student athletes to play away games in states such as North Carolina. (I don't follow college sports enough to know whether CA and NC even have any universities in the same conference, though, so it might be moot)
- ac29 9y agoNope, it only applies to "state employees, officers, or members", which students are not.
- tptacek 9y agoNo, not really: states (and by extension cities) are prohibited under the Commerce Clause from enacting burdens on interstate commerce of any sort unless they're authorized by Congress or they are themselves a direct participant in the market they're actually regulating, and not just a regulator.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 9y agoThe fact that states cannot do this is basically the root problem with the American system, and doomed the concept of federalism to failure.
- pjc50 9y agoStrongly disagree - you cannot have internal sanctions within a country, or it ceases to be a country. Essentially all modern nation-states have full free movement of goods and people internally(+). (+) China has limited internal free movement and some countries have "special economic zones", enclaves/exclaves and status anomalies like Guantanamo etc.
- rayiner 9y agoThe US wasn’t designed to be a country. It was designed to be a federation of sovereign states. But the constituent states often can’t practically exercise their sovereignty without being able to discriminate against other states. Voters in California can decide that they’re willing to bear the economic cost of stronger labor protections or higher minimum wages, but neighboring Nevada can easily capitalize on that to undercut Californian companies even in the Californian market. That forces myriad issues to bubble up to the federal level, which was the exact opposite of the federal design. For example, say we didn’t have the Fair Labor Standards Act, which includes a federal ban on child labor. States could ban child labor within their borders, but that policy would be undermined by neighboring states who could flood the market with cheaper goods produced using child labor. In fact, Congress proposed a Constitutional amendment in the 1920s to ban child labor. In the 1930s, FDR’s threats to pack the Supreme Court resulted in a dramatic expansion in the view of the federal government’s commerce clause power, which obviated the need for an amendment and child labor protections were included in the FLSA in 1938.
- rlanday 9y agoThe United States tried being a loose federation under the Articles of Confederation. It was a miserable failure, which led to the current Constitution, which was set up with the intention of creating a federal government strong enough to carry out essentially any function necessary to the success of the country. The United States has been a resounding success under the Constitution, growing to become the most powerful and richest nation in the world, and one of the most desirable nations for immigrants.
- jrs95 9y agoIt would definitely be illegal, and the current administration would almost certainly be hostile to that. We could potentially arrive at a situation where the courts would be willing to look the other way in certain cases though. Or Congress could delegate that power to state/local governments under certain circumstances.