3 ms·
So the "bad UI" thing was fake news, it seems.
by dboreham 9y ago
So the "bad UI" thing was fake news, it seems.
- shepardrtc 9y agoI really hate the term "fake news". It implies that someone created the whole story on purpose to deceive people. I think the "bad UI" thing was just someone trying to figure out what really happened and noticed that the webpage for the alerts was atrocious. They incorrectly thought that this could have been the reason for the mistake. By no means was it fake, rather it was simply a mistake. There's nothing malicious about that.
- glenneroo 9y agoThe screenshot was not a real screenshot. As a result, all news about "bad UI" could be considered to some degree fake, since it was based on fake screenshots.
- shepardrtc 9y agoAfter looking into it some more, it appears as though that screenshot was an attempt to simulate what the user may have seen because the agency did not release any sort of official images. Anecdotal evidence led everyone to speculate on what the "bad UI" may have looked like. I still wouldn't call it "fake news", just a half-assed attempt to try to mock-up what the operator saw with little information. Its bad journalism (and should be called out as such!) but its not malicious. And that's why I hate the term "fake news" so much: it carries a negative overtone but it can applied to ineptitude and/or stupidity. Seeing as ineptitude and stupidity are rampant in life, assigning malice to them could be used as a rhetorical technique by a bad actor. For example, a politician wanting to bring down news groups that don't support him/her could say that all news is "fake news" and offer up examples such as the "bad ui".
- dboreham 9y agoI think it is worse than that because the screen shot originated with the Hawaii state government, but it turns out to be not genuine, AND they took no steps to debunk the resulting widely circulated stories that bad UI had been the root cause. http://www.ajc.com/news/national/photo-hawaii-missile-warning-system-was-fake-officials-say/L9A1wQTNVRpGMcKupM61YJ/ http://www.ajc.com/news/national/photo-hawaii-missile-warnin...
- xupybd 9y ago>I really hate the term "fake news". It implies that someone created the whole story on purpose to deceive people No it just means someone published the story without proper fact checking.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mortehu 9y agoBack in 2016 it meant fabricated news, usually about politics. Donald Trump started abusing the term not long after it was revealed that the fabricated news at the time was mostly successful in targeting his followers, presumably to dilute the term. See https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XoLHF3Z9eMg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XoLHF3Z9eMg or Google "Jestin Coler"
- xupybd 9y agoI stand corrected.
- theossuary 9y agoMaybe, maybe not. For some reason the guardian thought it'd be okay to go to publication without interviewing the officer who actually clicked the button, so they only reported the agencies version of events. Feels like they're just making him a scapegoat, and the guardian is helping. Either way, you shouldn't say "this is not a drill," when, you know, it's a drill.
- bigtones 9y agoThat officer refused to talk to reporters (which is his right), but also refused to be interviewed by the Federal Communications Commission as well, as part of their investigation. He was fired for that reason.
- bloak 9y agoArguably, if you don't include the words "this is not a drill" in your exercise then your exercise is not sufficiently realistic. The real question is: why include those words in a real announcement?
- hinkley 9y agoRoot cause analysis is not mandated to finding one flaw and fix it. It’s mandated to find at least one flaw. The problem identified earlier still needs to be addressed because the same outcome can arise from two causes.