3 ms·
There’s something circular about this argument, which reduces to “We can’t make perfect copies. But if we could, they’d be perfect.” Without evidence - unlikel
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
There’s something circular about this argument, which reduces to “We can’t make perfect copies. But if we could, they’d be perfect.”
Without evidence - unlikely anytime soon - there’s no way to know if a copy really would feel identical, or whether - more likely IMO - it might start “close enough” but errors would accumulate over time and lead to noticeable differences, which might be experienced in both subjective and objective ways.
If there are quantum-level effects, consciousness will not be copyable.
Even if there aren’t, we’re talking about exactly duplicating a specific arrangement of atoms in space to reproduce all the neuronal configurations and chemical gradients.
And we’re talking about doing that with no significant errors. And implanting that configuration inside an extended nerve and tissue network it has to be matched to.
At the very least, the functional information structures created by the chemistry and biology have to be duplicated exactly - probably instantaneously, to avoid mistakes - with no significant inaccuracies.
All of that seems quite challenging to me.