2 ms·
I agree that Christians (cue #NotAllChristians) have something that could be called a "victimization fetish". I agree that many couple the Holocaust of the Jews
by eesmith 9y ago
I agree that Christians (cue #NotAllChristians) have something that could be called a "victimization fetish". I agree that many couple the Holocaust of the Jews with anything they see as a diminishing of their faith, including equating the removal of special privileges that Christianity has had over other faiths with the Holocaust. I'm willing to call this a victimization-by-proxy.
What I disagree with is that your example, as originally described, shows evidence of a victimization fetish-by-proxy towards Jews.
Most of what you wrote just now also fits into a Christian Zionism interpretation.
The 'special status' of Jews in the US is of course partially to do with the Holocaust and Zionism, as well as a response to the disgraceful way the US dealt with Jews who tried to escape by immigrating to the US.
But I think we should also interpret it as an attempt to unify disparate branches of Christian faith under the banner of so-called "shared Judeo-Christian values". It's a way to brush doctrinaire differences under the table.
When people claim that "Merry Christmas" is part of our Judeo-Christian values then I can't help but think they are including "Judeo" as a fig leaf.
Given that you know the context, and since what you described is a friend-of-a-friend account, where you don't recall the specifics, I think you can understand why I don't agree with the conclusion you drew from the recollection you gave, even if I can agree with your overall thesis.