4 ms·
It's a tragedy that the country of Nye Bevan and Clement Attlee has come to this. I'm reminded of a quote that I think I first read in "Chavs: The Demonization
by arethuza 9y ago
It's a tragedy that the country of Nye Bevan and Clement Attlee has come to this.
I'm reminded of a quote that I think I first read in "Chavs: The Demonization of the Working Class" (NB strongly recommended):
"There’s been class warfare for the last 20 years, and my class has won"
Warren Buffet
Edit: I'm in the middle of reading "Citizen Clem" and what an extraordinarily capable chap Attlee was. Here's a good article on him in (of all places) the Daily Mail:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-3174009/DOMINIC-SANDBROOK-Labour-s-greatest-leader-teach-squabbling-pygmies.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-3174009/DOMINIC-SA...
Edit2: Even Thatcher was a fan of Attlee: "Of Clement Attlee, however, I was an admirer. He was a serious man and a patriot. Quite contrary to the general tendency of politicians in the 1990s, he was all substance and no show."
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> Even Thatcher was a fan of Attlee We don't hold that against him, though.
- Nursie 9y agoI've not read "Chavs: The Demonization of the Working Class", but from what little I know of it one (probably minor) thing that Jones tries to establish is that the very word "Chav" is a classist acronym for "Council Housed And Violent". This is a retrofit for narrative purposes, invented by Jones, who seeks to demonise the word and in doing so police its use. The origins of the term are much older (before council houses in fact). Having read quite a number of his columms for the guardian, he seems to represent a lot that I dislike about the UK left and their tendency to try to redefine popular terms in such a way as to demonise their users. It's straw-man fallacy writ large - you said "chav" therefore you are classist (Tory) scum. Actually I said chav because that group of loud, ridiculously dressed arseholes over there is starting to kick off, I don't give a shit what their socio-economic background might be. I have left-leaning tendencies, I think the benefits system in the UK is a f*cking shambles, the NHS needs help and is an essential service, that there's a lot more we can do to help our people thrive and succeed. But this vein of pious language-warping really puts me off from identifying with the self-identified left or the Labour party.
- arethuza 9y agoI'm no fan of that type of linguistic policing either (e.g. "neds" here in Scotland) - I don't think the argument around the term makes up much of the book though.
- gcb0 9y agothen you should read the book. the cover is the stereotypical 'chav' clothing, which you internalized so well in your discourse. And one (or more) chapter is dedicated to micro aggression (as defined be Strauss(?) where every argument has an oppressor and a oppressed) and culture wars that defined that chavs and irishs are dumb and irresponsible and that's why society needs the oh so justified ruling class to watch out for those too dumb to watch out for themselves, in all their best interest.
- Nursie 9y agoUgh, the whole concept of 'microaggression' can f*ck off, IMHO. And no, it's not culture war. The whole narrative that you can't criticise people who dress and behave like dickheads because you might be displaying class privilege is nonsense. Plenty of people from the very poorest and most deprived backgrounds don't do that.
- aninhumer 9y ago>The origins of the term are much older (before council houses in fact). This may be true, but FWIW, the first time I heard the term it was introduced to me with a similar backronym. And not as some "isn't this awful classism" disclaimer, but as a gleeful denigration of the people it referred to. That there is an older etymology does not necessarily mean Jones invented the backronym. >Actually I said chav because that group of loud, ridiculously dressed arseholes over there is starting to kick off While I too have used the term, and feel like I was doing objection to genuinely unpleasant people, I remain suspicious of this argument, because it sounds a lot like "I don't mind black people, I just don't like black culture". A lot of what gets read as obnoxious is just cultural differences, and this is especially true of judgements like "ridiculously dressed".