3 ms·
Since there's likely to be people that do not consider this sufficient, a question out of personal interest: what could Mozilla do/have done to sufficiently pre
by Vinnl 9y ago
Since there's likely to be people that do not consider this sufficient, a question out of personal interest: what could Mozilla do/have done to sufficiently prevent something like this from happening in the future?
- sho_hn 9y agoDon't promote non-Mozilla products via your web browser. It's a conduit for content, not a content showcase. Come up with an idea of "browser neutrality".
- Vinnl 9y agoWhile I understand the sentiment, does that mean they should also remove the search box/ability to use a search engine from the address bar? And what if the search engine they promote is e.g. DuckDuckGo? And what should be their source of funding?
- sho_hn 9y agoA search engine frontend produces content in response to a user query, not proactively. Even before the first query I get an option to choose. It's not the same thing. It's more on the content conduit side than operator-run showcase. Has the idea that Mozilla won't survive without advertising income been substantiated somewhere? (This ad was unpaid, though.)
- Vinnl 9y agoBut by those lines, wouldn't it be fine to show some Mr. Robot-related content if the user has to proactively flip a switch in about:config?
- sho_hn 9y agoAs long as there's a reasonable way for others to provide opt-in TV show extensions as well (otherwise it's not a neutral conduit again), sure.
- Vinnl 9y agoAlright, but then isn't that exactly what happened here?
- andrewjw 9y agoNo, because it was emphatically not opt-in, nor was there an open conduit for others to provide alternatives.
- sfink 9y agoInstallation of the addon was not opt-in. Receiving any form of promotional content was opt-in via about:config. There is an open conduit; anybody else could offer an addon. So I agree that it was not neutral, because there was more of a barrier to other advertisers than to Mr. Roboto. The right thing would be to have hosted the addon on addons.mozilla.org, same as for anyone else. But it's not a dramatically uneven playing field, given that an open conduit does exist and the reception of any actual advertising was opt-in. (I'm not saying it was ok; it wasn't. But it's not as black and white as you are saying.)
- hawski 9y agoWith Mozilla's current financing model Firefox can't be a "neutral browser", can it?
- mcny 9y agoAll the more reason to shut down all non essential operations, focus on the core, and radically reduce expenses.
- Fnoord 9y agoOr all the more reason to try to gain more users via a promotional ad like this one in order to stay relevant and not go the Opera route. In hindsight it backfired, but hindsight 20/20 is easy. Thing is, why assume malice?
- genghizkhan 9y agoThere's a certain point at which it's important to forgive the offender. Mozilla does not usually make mistakes that compromise user privacy/security. To their credit, this mistake didn't do that either. While it may have led users to suspect many things, this particular Shield Study was not sent maliciously, nor did it lead to any malicious activity. Mozilla acknowledge this, have repented for their actions, and issued a set of rules for these studies which are clear and transparent. I'm not sure they could have done anything more short of going back in time and reversing their stupid decision.
- nindalf 9y agoIf someone fucks up, and then stands up and says "I fucked up, I'm sorry, it won't happen again" then the best thing to do is to give them a chance. If we were to crucify everyone regardless of whether they apologised or what they promise for the future, the incentive for improving behaviour is low.
- mcny 9y agoI am not trying to crucify anyone but Mr CMO is definitely not a good match for the vision I want at Mozilla. As such, I want him to step down from all responsibility at Mozilla. I'm sure he is a good person and means well. I'm sure he is very good at what he does and I appreciate his contributing to Mozilla but I think he'd be more valuable outside a leadership role at Mozilla.
- kuschku 9y agoMozilla still runs Google Analytics on about:addons "Discovery" page, saying that they have a contract with Google that Google won't abuse that data, and if we don't trust Google to uphold our privacy, we shouldn't use Firefox. (Statement given on the AMO bugtracker about this). It's important not to forgive Mozilla, and to constantly remind them of CliqZ, the tracking in Firefox Focus (also using Google Analytics) and about:addons Discovery page, and of Mr Robot. Only then, maybe, will they learn something from this. For now, it looks like they don't give a shit.
- Angostura 9y agoTo me, it does look sufficient to prevent something like this happening in the future. The arguments will be over whether sufficient contrition has been shown and whether someone needs to be placed in the stocks. It was a bad, bad mistake. I think they've learned their lesson.
- hateduser2 9y agoTheres no pleasing everyone. There will always be people who reject them.
- contrast 9y agoThere is no simpler lesson than "don't install unexpected software on your users machines". So simple. So obvious. So necessary, if you value privacy. Yet they have not acknowledged the mistake or shown any signs of willing to listen to the complaints - their entire explanation is about something else that people weren't even aware of! Given the level of feedback and the intelligence of the recipients, this is unlikely to be a mistake or a coincidence. It is reasonable to conclude they fully intend to repeat this behaviour in future.
- mcintyre1994 9y ago"SHIELD was an inappropriate channel to use to ship this. We don't believe there is any appropriate channel for us to ship this other than an opt-in add-on in the add-ons-store, and will never ship software of this nature through any other channel in future." As is I trust they won't use SHIELD next time (and have opted back into their studies based on the policy change), but my expectation is that next time they want to ship some garbage like that they'll use some other channel and marketing have probably already identified it.