7 ms·
The Kessler Syndrome Explained (2014)
- chillydawg 9y agoI wonder if there's a bit of a land grab going on right now to claim as much LEO and geosync spots as possible before they dry up and become too crowded to operate in safely. Maybe a secondary market of orbital slots will open up where current operators sell their huge chunks to new entrants. Just like good old ipv4.
- diamondo25 9y agoThere's not really a land grab, and you better be sure to have propulsion on board in the coming years, as youll most likely have to evade other defunct satellites. The ISS is actually in a bad position, as satellites tend to go to earth, and the ISS is between earth and most LEO sats (400km vs 600-800km).
- snrplfth 9y agoThe ISS is in a great position, because it's in an altitude with such high drag that small objects and uncontrolled fragments deorbit very quickly. Even the ISS loses 50 - 90 m of altitude a day. Satellites passing through the ISS's orbit do not tend to spend that many orbits there.
- azernik 9y agoIn LEO it's not about orbital slots - it's about frequency bands. Claims on frequency bands in orbit are governed by the ITU; because of its international nature, there aren't agreed-upon policies for frequency assignments, so instead the rules are simple and competitive. The first entity to get a satellite in orbit using a specific frequency band gets the exclusive rights to that band, so there's a lot of pressure to get a symbolic bird up early to stake your claim.
- jandrese 9y agoGEO sats have been slot limited for decades. The birds need to be spaced roughly 1 degree apart in the sky to avoid the need for massive ground antennas to talk to them. A few birds get slotted in half degree slots, but they aren't popular. You can have two birds share a slot if they operate on different bands (L vs. Ku for example), but there are basically only three popular bands currently in use (L, Ku, and Ka) and using a different one would mean custom designing hardware and negotiating with the FCC and nobody wants to deal with that. Ka is also a bit exotic currently, although it's way more widespread now than it was a few years ago. This is why some of the biggest satellites we launch are GEO bound communication sats. They're like luxury condos in a high priced neighborhood. Because the land (orbital slot) is so expensive the developers want to make the most of it. Things can be a lot more amateur down in LEO where your freespace loss is so low you can talk to your bird over an omni antenna. There your bigger concern is just getting bandwidth on a usable frequency.
- alex_duf 9y ago>prepare to spend a few years without cell phone reception, Internet, and a five-day weather forecast. Aside from the weather forecast the rest doesn't need any sort of satellite. It's incredible how many people still think mobile phones are using satellites! It's a ground antenna, connected via copper or fiber to a wider network of... antennas. If you call abroad, 99% chances your call goes through a submarine cable which is again copper or fiber. Same with Internet, unless you really are in the middle of the Amazon forest, or (live in country side in the states)
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI still think there's lots of benefits to be had (and lots of money to be made) from replacing many of current satellites with high-altitude solar-powered UAVs. They'll be much cheaper to design and manufacture (no need for satellite-grade sterility, or engineering for microgravity environment), much easier to service and replace, and they'd offer some capabilities impossible for satellites (like not flying around the globe). I've said that before, and got plenty of skeptical looks. I recently learned, however, that I'm not the only one thinking this - in fact the concept has been dubbed "atmosats", "pseudosats", or "HAPS". ESA seems to be into it now: http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Navigation/Crossing_drones_with_satellites_ESA_eyes_high-altitude_aerial_platforms http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Navigation/Crossing_drones...
- flashmob 9y agoHave you heard of Facebook's Aquila drone? Sounds like something you are describing. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook_Aquila https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook_Aquila Also, Google's project loon comes to mind.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoYeah, they would both be good examples qualify.
- c3833174 9y agoI think some base stations use GPS time as time/frequency reference.
- venning 9y agoNeeds a (2014) tag.
- farseer 9y agoSo if North Korea launches one of their ICBMs into LEO with a billion metal pellets, would it be the end of the space age?
- beobab 9y agoIt might make things harder, but it probably wouldn't end it entirely. These humans we have here are remarkably ingenious, have a high risk tolerance, and would probably come up with some way of dealing with it.
- lou1306 9y agoAnd LOE still has some atmospheric drag, which means that debris will eventually fall to Earth. So that would be more of a "space age hiatus". By the way, we already have some ideas on how to deal with debris [0], so in the event of an actual Kessler Syndrome we could try them out. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_broom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_broom
- TeMPOraL 9y ago"Space age hiatus" would be a serious blow to our future as a species, though. It seems that over the last few years, all the necessary components required to bootstrap an economy in Earth's orbit / cislunar space have been coming together. This peculiar synchronization may completely collapse if we were to suddenly lose space access for couple of years (or decades).
- mnw21cam 9y agoIt takes more rocket to launch into LEO than it does to get a ballistic trajectory to your nearest enemy. Your average ICBM doesn't have the oomph to do it. If it did, then it could target any point on the planet, and we are fairly sure the North Korea ICBMs can't do that. Yet. Also, once you have got your pellets into LEO, you need a way to spread them with a variety of relative velocity. A satellite-satellite collision or a rocket explosion does this very well - the models give the individual fragments 1km/s relative outward velocity from the incident, so you basically need to make a nail bomb. Some of the fragments will be blown in the backwards direction, and may re-enter the atmosphere on the first orbit. Interestingly, because reasons, fragments that are blown upwards and downwards may also re-enter on the first orbit too.
- kitbrennan 9y agoHow long would it take for orbit decay to bring these objects back into the atmosphere?
- danielvf 9y agoThat’s one of the key factors. It depends on the how high the orbit of the satellite is. For ones in LEO - below 350 km, months - 400km a year - 500km five years - 600km ten years - 700km twenty five years Etc. However, when a satellite breaks up, the small pieces are much more affected by drag. Another is effect is that an explosion results in approximately 50% of the pieces having a lower orbit. So even though the Cosmos-Irdium collision happened at 700km, which would take about twenty five years to deorbit, in just five years, more than a quarter of the debris had deorbited.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoWhen you put it like that, it doesn't sound as bad as, say, nuclear winter. 25-50 years of high debris, then slowly reducing remains. It's weird to imagine that if humanity would die out suddenly, our satellites and orbital space waste would only stay up there for what, 100 - 200 years more?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoGEO stuff would stay for much longer, though; it's 36Mm up.
- jandrese 9y agoKessler Syndrome is very unlikely in GEO orbits. The reason is twofold: first the distances are enormous, but more importantly all of the satellites are traveling at the same speed in the same direction. Even a defunct satellite that didn't get put in a parking orbit and starts drifting will take years before it even has a chance of colliding with another satellite, and the odds of that collision are infinitesimal. In LEO you have a completely different story. The distances are still large, but not as overwhelming as they are in GEO. Also, satellites are flying in every direction at very high relative velocities to one another. A piece of space trash could have thousands of potential collisions per day, so even if the odds of any one collision are small the cumulative odds start to add up over time. Of course the other problem is that when we put people into space we put them in LEO. People have not ventured beyond LEO since the Apollo program. In the event of a full blown Kessler syndrome manned space flight would have to be put on hold for decades while we wait for the skies to clear up.
- alkonaut 9y agoSo a tragedy of the commons, like any other. The best way to solve it would probably be to have all actors agree on some rules (no rocket bodies left in orbit etc) and some economic incentives such as "for every kg put in orbit you have to pay $X to a fund for the cleanup". And just like with CO2, the countries responsible for the last 50 years of launches should prime this fund with money for past launches, because the countries that just started launching won't agree to the scheme otherwise. So basically: US, EU and Russia pay billions to a fund in exchange for India and China agreeing to start paying for future launches.
- Already__Taken 9y agoThere are rules for satellite designs in place and evolving to address this. You can't just leave things in GEO they must have been launched with a lifecycle plan and suitable fuel/propulsion to move to a dead parking orbit.
- alkonaut 9y agoI think I heard of that too. But in order to improve these rules need to be extended to fund the cleanup (i.e. a fund for cleaning up any old debris + the fraction of satellites whose decomissioning doesn't work). Otherwise, the situation is slowly getting worse anyway. Do you know if the rules also mandate that you can't leave fairings, rocket parts etc. in orbit?
- GlenTheMachine 9y agoFor the most part, it really isn’t possible to clean up space debris. The fuel requirements are orders of magnitude too high.
- SilasX 9y agoEnforced by what bodies? (Not trying to be cheeky, I really want to know. The primary problem here isn’t specifying rules but enforcing them among superpowers.)
- jandrese 9y agoThis is something I've wondered about when people start talking about capturing asteroids in Earth orbit and mining them. Mining is typically a dirty activity and most asteroids are more like a loose collection of gravel to begin with, and have such pitiful escape velocity that keeping them together is going to be a significant challenge. One high energy impact from an errant asteroid could make a tremendous mess in whatever orbit they are using, and to the extent that orbital mining makes sense at all it almost has to happen in LEO if you want to use the products on Earth or benefit from labor/equipment being launched from Earth.
- Symmetry 9y agoYou could plausibly get a nearby asteroid into a wide orbit of the Earth for 500 m/s of delta v. But getting it from there all the way down to LEO would take 3 km/s. So I expect most asteroid mining would take place fairly far out as a practical matter since the products of mining would be lighter and easier to move. The main downside would be days of travel time to and from the mining site. And there is a market for the products of asteroid mining in GEO in the form of commsats who might want to be refueled or someday maybe even have some parts make from asteroid stuff.
- jandrese 9y agoRefueling GEOs will probably never be profitable. They already last for 15+ years and are replaced by much improved satellites when they are retired. Keeping an old one running isn't worth it because the orbital slots they are in are too expensive. IMHO, asteroid mining only makes sense if you are also manufacturing things in orbit (like spaceships and orbital colonies). All of these plans to deorbit the mined materials are crazy talk IMHO. Even if you find some amazing near solid platinum asteroid nearly in orbit already the costs of mining it and bringing the material back to Earth make it extremely difficult to compete against terrestrial mining. If you are actually manufacturing stuff, then you are much more free to choose your orbit. You can even choose to orbit the moon instead to reduce the possibility of disaster.
- breakyerself 9y agoHow long can something stay in low earth orbit without propulsion?