4 ms·
Why do you assume that identical twins have identical brains? Brain physical structure is altered during lifetime experience, learning changes large physical p
by PeterisP 9y ago
Why do you assume that identical twins have identical brains?
Brain physical structure is altered during lifetime experience, learning changes large physical properties of neurons e.g. forming some new synapses and pruning others.
Even at birth, identical twins have different fingerprints, different retinas and yes, different cellular structures of their brains. And that only diverges later.
It's not a given that a brain "3D printed from a snapshot of the exact cellular structure of your brain" would be sufficiently good copy, we know that there are other things that matter (e.g. various intra-cell properties and chemical concentrations within particular locations of those neurons) and there likely are some other things that matter but which we don't know yet.
However, assuming that we could make a sufficiently good copy, it would be undistinguishable from you. It would have the same behavior, reactions, memories, skills and understanding; it would have the same beliefs as you do - including a belief that it's you and that it has been you since your birth, supported by memories of living your life. If the copy is sufficiently good, barring the signs of the operation itself (scar tissue? machinery? video evidence of it being done) neither your relatives nor (new?) you yourself would be able to make a distinction.
Yes, you could argue that the new copy is different from the previous one, that it's not the same, that it lacks continuity. But that's arguing about what do we mean when we say "the same". If you didn't know that your parents had died, you'd have no way to tell when their copies come to celebrate christmas with you.
- tritium 9y agoHey, wow. Amazing. Congratulations. You solved the problem. Right here on Hacker News.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't be a jerk in HN comments. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- perl4ever 9y agoSuppose someone invented a "matter transporter", that was to all external appearances approximately equivalent to the standard device that is a science fiction trope. But what actually happens with this device, is that once a person steps into the chamber, and is scanned, and the information to recreate them is sent to a receiver elsewhere, by some beaming method, the original is dropped into a "recycling chamber" where their body is shredded, compacted, and made into soylent green or something. Would you voluntarily use this device? All the people who go through it report at the other end everything went well, since it in fact makes perfect copies. One tangential idea I also want to mention is that there is a mental disorder where people perceive things incorrectly as false and strange. So, given your scenario of your parents coming to Christmas, there exists a disorder where your brain tells you they are some sort of duplicates or imposters, but you can't explain why. I don't have a reference offhand, but it's probably either something I read in a book by the neurologist Oliver Sacks, or some book about schizophrenia.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThere’s something circular about this argument, which reduces to “We can’t make perfect copies. But if we could, they’d be perfect.” Without evidence - unlikely anytime soon - there’s no way to know if a copy really would feel identical, or whether - more likely IMO - it might start “close enough” but errors would accumulate over time and lead to noticeable differences, which might be experienced in both subjective and objective ways. If there are quantum-level effects, consciousness will not be copyable. Even if there aren’t, we’re talking about exactly duplicating a specific arrangement of atoms in space to reproduce all the neuronal configurations and chemical gradients. And we’re talking about doing that with no significant errors. And implanting that configuration inside an extended nerve and tissue network it has to be matched to. At the very least, the functional information structures created by the chemistry and biology have to be duplicated exactly - probably instantaneously, to avoid mistakes - with no significant inaccuracies. All of that seems quite challenging to me.