3 ms·

That's not true. Almost every person I know in my generation is working hard to buy a piece of land in a rural community.

tjr225 9y ago
While your experience might tell you that the reality is that is simply not true. You're countering a statistically sourced statement with an anecdote.
- bonesss 9y ago
  There are two actually statistics underlying the discussion here, and from my reading both points are right (though disagreeing that we're urbanizing is incorrect)... 1) Our general trend is towards urbanization, humanity is now more urban than rural, and every quality of life index shows cities give more good to more people better. 2) Millennials, hipsters in particular, in American markets with crushing real estate prices have recently begun reverse-migrating away from the cities and to more rural areas with romanticized lifestyles creating some new demographic, and real estate, trends. In terms of pure statistics we're looking at a sub-group with a different trend than the overall group. Most potatos aren't from my backyard, but those potatoes are only getting prettier while the many thousands at the market are getting uglier ;)
  - tjr225 9y ago
    I'm totally in the camp who wants to move back to the Midwest and buy some acreage- my point was mainly that the person I responded to flat out stated that the parent commenter was wrong which is not the case.
    - adreamingsoul 9y ago
      Statistical significance aside, blanket statements such as what I responded to are simple, not true when compared to reality. I do not believe that humans can be unbiased when interrupting data to form a conclusive hypothesis. This is why the scientific community has a peer-review process to filter out biases. However, I will agree that my initial response was lacking and would have been better if not stated at all.
      - tjr225 9y ago
        :thumbsup:
sagichmal 9y ago
And every person I know in my generation is working hard to buy a flat in a major urban center. The plural of anecdote is not data.
deleted 9y ago
[deleted]

tjr225 9y ago

While your experience might tell you that the reality is that is simply not true. You're countering a statistically sourced statement with an anecdote.

bonesss 9y ago
There are two actually statistics underlying the discussion here, and from my reading both points are right (though disagreeing that we're urbanizing is incorrect)... 1) Our general trend is towards urbanization, humanity is now more urban than rural, and every quality of life index shows cities give more good to more people better. 2) Millennials, hipsters in particular, in American markets with crushing real estate prices have recently begun reverse-migrating away from the cities and to more rural areas with romanticized lifestyles creating some new demographic, and real estate, trends. In terms of pure statistics we're looking at a sub-group with a different trend than the overall group. Most potatos aren't from my backyard, but those potatoes are only getting prettier while the many thousands at the market are getting uglier ;)
- tjr225 9y ago
  I'm totally in the camp who wants to move back to the Midwest and buy some acreage- my point was mainly that the person I responded to flat out stated that the parent commenter was wrong which is not the case.
  - adreamingsoul 9y ago
    Statistical significance aside, blanket statements such as what I responded to are simple, not true when compared to reality. I do not believe that humans can be unbiased when interrupting data to form a conclusive hypothesis. This is why the scientific community has a peer-review process to filter out biases. However, I will agree that my initial response was lacking and would have been better if not stated at all.
    - tjr225 9y ago
      :thumbsup:

sagichmal 9y ago

And every person I know in my generation is working hard to buy a flat in a major urban center. The plural of anecdote is not data.

deleted 9y ago

[deleted]