2 ms·
This argument did not exist with BTC at two- and three-digit price levels. Instead BTC was advertised as useful for (a) microtransactions on the Web, such as pa
by prostoalex 9y ago
This argument did not exist with BTC at two- and three-digit price levels. Instead BTC was advertised as useful for (a) microtransactions on the Web, such as paying Web publishers or e-mail recipients (21.co second business model), (b) buying a drink at the trendy neighborhood coffee shop that accepted BTC, (c) transacting with strangers on sites like Silk Road, (d) buying stuff from Newegg, Overstock and ever-expanding universe of e-commerce shops accepting BTC, (e) international money transfers and remittances, where fees historically have been quite high.
All of that activity has died down due to better ROI on hoarding (whoever spent 2,739 BTC on this house must have quite a buyer’s remorse by now https://www.wsj.com/articles/lake-tahoe-property-sells-for-1-6-million-in-bitcoins-1407534997 https://www.wsj.com/articles/lake-tahoe-property-sells-for-1...) and high transaction fees. The only argument one reads nowadays online is based on the bigger fool theory - buy now, sell later, pocket the profit.
You’re right that fiat currency has little of intrinsic value, but nobody with large enough wealth treats it as such. People might have 1-, 3-, 6-, 12-month cash cushions but (outside of people on ForEx forums) nobody is entertaining an idea of selling everything and investing in a large bag of GBP or CAD. Or telling their friends to buy NZD because it’s bound to go big.
Fiat currency is a plain transaction medium that people are quick to diversify from once they have accummulated decent amount of it to cover the everyday stuff. And those other investment mechanisms generally do have intrinsic, or backstop, value.
- ThomPete 9y agoGold wasn't originally a store of value nor used in technology. The world is filled with companies that started as one thing and ended up completely different. In reality, it's not an argument, there isn't some supreme court of judges sitting there valuing the intent vs. the outcome. You are creating your own arbitrary rules for judging BTC. That's fine but it's not an argument.
- prostoalex 9y agoLet’s say the BTC network moves towards store of value instead of “Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System“. Fewer transactions result in fewer blocks. Fewer blocks result in fewer miner rewards. Decreased profitability of block creation will have to be compensated by increased transaction fees. Increased transaction fees will lead to fewer transactions. What’s the incentive for miners to stick around in a store of value environment?