3 ms·
I wasn't suggesting that you were. It's a caution that the term "outsider" likely isn't the right word, because it's close to historical racist stereotypes, and
by eesmith 9y ago
I wasn't suggesting that you were. It's a caution that the term "outsider" likely isn't the right word, because it's close to historical racist stereotypes, and from my admittedly poor understanding, might bring with it other connotations than what you mean.
As I understand your use of 'outsider', a person with a white background is an outsider to blacks, and will be disfavored for that reason by blacks, and a person with a black background will be an outsider to whites and disfavored for that reason.
In colonial countries the whites had the power, so even if what you say is true, it's a relatively small component to the power structure of the culture.
What usually happens is that mixed race people form their own group, historically identified with terms like "mulatto" or "brown" or "coloured". They are not outsiders to other members of that group, and as a group have a privilege level between those of whites and of blacks.
Your construction didn't seem to consider that a new racial group might form.
The "tragic mulatto" concept, as I understand it, is based on the premise that there are only whites or blacks, that whites and blacks will both disfavor mixed race people, and that mixed race people will not form their own racial group with in-group privileges.
This is why I believed a caution was in order.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> In colonial countries the whites had the power, so even if what you say is true, it's a relatively small component to the power structure of the culture. I'm not making a commentary on the power structure of national level society, I'm making a commentary on the way mixed race people are often treated by various subcultures within that society. > Your construction didn't seem to consider that a new racial group might form. I think you have mistaken the word “often” in my post for the phrase “without exception”. Trust me, had I meant the latter, I would not have said the former.
- eesmith 9y agoI think my confusion lies in that magic_beans was talking about power structure, and specifically privilege. I continued on in that track not realizing that you had changed to an orthogonal topic.