3 ms·
I don't see where "victimhood by proxy" fits into your example. I thought the Christian Evangelical support of Jews and Israel was more from other reasons. I
by eesmith 9y ago
I don't see where "victimhood by proxy" fits into your example.
I thought the Christian Evangelical support of Jews and Israel was more from other reasons.
I was brought up in a strongly Christian family. When I think of a shofar, the first thing that comes to mind is the Battle of Jericho. I can totally see why someone would want to blow in a shofar because of its Biblical associations.
Some Evangelical Christians support Israel because of Christian Zionism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Zionism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Zionism . Quoting from there:
> Christian believers are instructed by Scripture to acknowledge the Hebraic roots of their faith and to actively assist and participate in the plan of God for the Ingathering of the Jewish People and the Restoration of the nation of Israel in our day.
The end goal is that this is a prerequisite for the Second Coming of Christ and the end of the world.
Where does a fetishized victimhood of Jews and Israel fit in?
- wahern 9y agoI'm well aware of the context, contemporary cultural trends in Evangelicalism, and aware that their behavior was innocent on a personal level. But it speaks to how the incidents of Judaism and Jewishness are conflated with the individuals, causing the objectification of a group people. (Also, neither of us was there. My manager was and we'll have to take his word regarding how out of sorts it was. There's more to the story, such as what the booth was promoting and his interactions with attendees, of which I don't remember the specifics. As a Catholic kid who grew up in the Deep South being teased by Baptist and Pentecostal kids--and sometimes teachers--for supposedly worshipping Mary and who used the incidents of my religion--praying the Rosary, sign of the cross--to demean me, I think I have some sense of how non-practitioners handling such things, depending on the context and their manner, could be indicative of some deeper social pathology. Another example as a Catholic--the way Hollywood mines Roman Catholic symbolism to impart mystical, paranormal, or conspiratorial qualities to a story, always conspicuously devoid of core Christian symbols like Jesus, because in the traditional Protestant-American narrative Catholicism was everything _except_ the worship of Jesus.) Where the victimhood comes in is how Evangelical Christian politicians in particular justify extreme, pro-Israeli foreign policies by reference to the history of anti-Semitism and in particular the Holocaust. These people claim to know what anti-Semitism means and how it should inform politics, even though they're neither Jewish nor ever had to personally experience anti-Semitism. They objective Israelis and Jews the way Muslim leaders in Arab countries objectify Jewish and Christian minorities, by reference to their special status as Abrahamic religions and a God given mandate to protect them. And within the larger narrative of victimization in American culture, they've positioned themselves as defenders of a victimized group--much like they've positioned themselves as victims in the recent Freedom of Religion debates--and used that position to justify policies with are ultimately self-serving. (So far the policies are largely welcomed in Israel, but I'm sure most Israelis know they're playing with fire by courting Evangelical groups.) More to the point, the staff who worked at that think tank were well aware of the objectification and deeper prejudices that underlay the financial and political support given to them by certain groups. It's a complex and subtle dimension to racism that most people don't understand, especially if they've not experienced it first hand. That Evangelical Christians are oblivious to this dimension speaks to how pernicious it can be, as it shows how people believing themselves innocent, sympathetic, and righteous can unknowingly harbor, perpetuate, and exacerbate social prejudice.
- eesmith 9y agoI agree that Christians (cue #NotAllChristians) have something that could be called a "victimization fetish". I agree that many couple the Holocaust of the Jews with anything they see as a diminishing of their faith, including equating the removal of special privileges that Christianity has had over other faiths with the Holocaust. I'm willing to call this a victimization-by-proxy. What I disagree with is that your example, as originally described, shows evidence of a victimization fetish-by-proxy towards Jews. Most of what you wrote just now also fits into a Christian Zionism interpretation. The 'special status' of Jews in the US is of course partially to do with the Holocaust and Zionism, as well as a response to the disgraceful way the US dealt with Jews who tried to escape by immigrating to the US. But I think we should also interpret it as an attempt to unify disparate branches of Christian faith under the banner of so-called "shared Judeo-Christian values". It's a way to brush doctrinaire differences under the table. When people claim that "Merry Christmas" is part of our Judeo-Christian values then I can't help but think they are including "Judeo" as a fig leaf. Given that you know the context, and since what you described is a friend-of-a-friend account, where you don't recall the specifics, I think you can understand why I don't agree with the conclusion you drew from the recollection you gave, even if I can agree with your overall thesis.
- M_Bakhtiari 9y agoI get the impression that in the US and Canada Christian Zionism isn't even exclusively an Evangelical affair, I seem to be hearing the same talking points from neo-conservative Catholics as well, like the various Rebel Media Catholics. Christian Zionists seem perfectly happy to support Israel even to the detriment of the native Christians it displaces, but at least they can brush them off as "Mary worshippers", it's a lot harder to make that case with a straight face if you're Catholic.