3 ms·
How is a nanoscale arrangement of molecules a new state of matter? Seems like this is all University press release puffery at its best.
by kevin_thibedeau 9y ago
How is a nanoscale arrangement of molecules a new state of matter? Seems like this is all University press release puffery at its best.
- twic 9y agoThat does seem like a bit of an exaggeration. But then, "state of matter" isn't particularly well-defined, as far as i know, so who's to say it isn't one? Perhaps relevant to this is the point about band gaps: > The Princeton scientists discovered a few years ago that hyperuniform materials can have “band gaps,” which block certain frequencies from propagating That's a property that crystals can have, but disordered materials can't, right? So it's interesting that a non-crystalline material can have that property.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoQuasicrystals and metamaterials exhibit the same phenomena. They were well known and studied in 2014. Regardless, having unique interactions with the outside world is not a new intrinsic state.