3 ms·
What vital safety protections do you believe are missing? >The fact that a significant amount of California politicians have been bought and paid for by Google
by joshuamorton 9y ago
What vital safety protections do you believe are missing?
>The fact that a significant amount of California politicians have been bought and paid for by Google and are still resistant to adopting Google's preferred legislation on self-driving cars shows some level of how reckless Google has been here.
Erm, there are about 30 conjectures in this statement. I don't know how I can have a good faith conversation with you when you say stuff like this that I can best describe as made up nonsense. Its tautological and impossible to even imagine a counterargument. Just to be clear, here's what you're assuming:
- Google's vehicles are unsafe (if they weren't what they are doing wouldn't be reckless, by definition)
- Google has significant control of the CA legislature
- Google is resistant to this regulation for safety reasons, and not some other reason (for example: competative advantage)
- California's regulations don't harm Google's advances in areas unrelated to safety
Just as a simple counterexample: Waymo wants to beta test the infrastructure for scaling out its fleet without safety drivers. There have been 0 disengagements in the last N,000 miles (where, say, N is suitably large), and the cars appear able to drive themselves in all circumstances they encounter in Phoenix. In such a case, continuing to require safety drivers (as in CA) would be harmful to their goals, and wouldn't actually have an impact on safety.
To summarize: your entire argument that Google is being reckless is predicated on their vehicles being unsafe. If they arne't unsafe, nothing else follows. You don't trust Google. But I don't understand where "don't trust" becomes "actively assume malice at every point". That seems, strange.