6 ms·
> distributism Thank you for giving a name to something I have been pondering a lot. I have come to this conclusion by thinking about automation and technologi
by visarga 9y ago
> distributism
Thank you for giving a name to something I have been pondering a lot. I have come to this conclusion by thinking about automation and technological unemployment. If people own land, or productive tools, they can be self reliant and exist without jobs from corporations, or help from the state. Naturally people would organise as a cooperative or a market of services, exchanging services for services, because they have little money and no corporate jobs. Yet they can work, so they can create a kindergarten for children of the neighbourhood, or a medical clinic, or a mechanic repair-shop, or a construction company, and so on.
By combining these skills a neighbourhood, or a city could be self reliant. In the future, with the advent of solar energy, agro-bots, 3d-printing and other empowering technologies it will be even easier to be self reliant. I see this as a better solution to UBI which depends on the state, which is corruptible and the corporations, which are greedy. People would retain their agency, unlike in the UBI scenario, where they would be wards of the state.
There is no purpose to automation that does not exist in the service of humanity at large, but only for a few. Automation must be owned by the people directly. We need to have the means of production in our hands in order to survive. There is one single job the advancement of automation can't take from us - the job of taking care of ourselves! And that's hard work.
- sagichmal 9y agoWhy is this form of self-reliance a virtue? To me, it looks pathological; certainly not something we should collectively be working towards.
- bgibson 9y agoReducing interdependence in human society mitigates systemic risk. It absolutely is a virtue to be collectively working towards.
- sagichmal 9y agoSystemic risk reduction is one effect of reducing interdependence. What are the others? On balance, are they net-negative or net-positive?
- ergothus 9y agoI can't say if it's better or not, but we do know that human organizations function poorly at scale. The larger the group, the more difficult it is to communicate, the easier it is to feel powerless, the more the problems of a large chunk of the group are remote and abstract (and thus ignored/missed/downplayed/deprioritized) I suspect that you also have more corruption and/or abuse of power because (a) the previous entries all empower sociopathic individuals, (b) you have a larger pool from which to find such sociopaths, and (c) you have more positions of power for said sociopaths to fill. You have all of these problems in small groups, but many of our policing/accountability systems don't function well in very large groups.
- kbenson 9y agoI'm not sure any of your claims are backed up by data. Is our larger society more corrupt? Is it more difficult to communicate? I could just as easily argue that smaller, more insular groups promote distrust of outsiders and lack of empathy, which might lead to more wars. I have no idea if that's true, but it sounds plausible to me. In the end, actually examining data is what's needed. Until there are facts to assess, we're just spouting wild conjecture.
- ergothus 9y ago> I'm not sure any of your claims are backed up by data. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number has a decent collection of the research I know of. There is a little hand-waving involved when it comes to "why", but it's notable that multiple researchers over decades disagree about the number, not the base concept. Likewise, studies related to the base concept of the non-technical Brooks Law support the non-linear impact on communication as a group grows (off hand I can't find a study on that, but I know I've read of multiple). Edit: Also https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/how-risky-is-it-really/201108/statistical-numbing-why-millions-can-die-and-we-don-t-care https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/how-risky-is-it-really/... points out some research about the distance/abstractness I mentioned. Anecdotally, plenty of governing and/or economic systems (e.g. communism) have historical success in small groups and no examples of success in large groups, but that's a completely different kind of evidence. The corruption/abuse item is not part of the research, which is why I separated that as "I suspect" Given the above, and what we know about leaders (executives, politicians) and how sociopathic tendencies are an asset to personal success I find it very plausible but I have no actual evidence, thus "I suspect". > I could just as easily argue that smaller, more insular groups promote distrust of outsiders and lack of empathy You could, and I'd actually be interested to see any research on the topic because I've not thought about that one but it does match our general experiences about exposure and tolerance to social differences. That's orthogonal to my point though, as I was only addressing internal workings, not interactions between groups.
- hathawsh 9y agoI'm upvoting you just for engaging in this conversation, even though I thoroughly disagree with you. :-) The "distributism" described above is the dream of virtually every rural community. People choose to live in rural communities because it's a little piece of heaven for them: they are surrounded by people they know, they have clean air, the earth is right beneath their feet, the stars are bright, the pace is slow, and so on. They want to serve their neighbors and receive services from their neighbors. How is that mindset pathological? I am always encouraged by innovations that help rural folks be more self-reliant so they can work toward their dream of self-sustaining, independent communities.
- scribu 9y agoThe problem is that a small community can’t develop or even maintain advanced technology, including that required for sanitation and healthcare. So, you either choose total independence and low technology or interdependence with other groups and advanced tech.
- kbenson 9y agoWell, at least until we reach the science fiction utopian dream of nanoassemblers that can make nanoassemblers. Then rural communities could truly be independent. Although that independence would be like a group of proto humans that knew about fire and how to use it, but not how to make it, and thus carefully guarded it and kept it fed, lest it go out.
- hathawsh 9y agoCertainly. There will always be interdependence and rural communities understand that; that's why they drive modern pickup trucks rather than horse-drawn carriages. Still, they are always looking for ways to reduce their dependence on cities.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ehead 9y ago
- zjaffee 9y agoThis already exists, and is in many ways a form of communism. Take a look at kibutz's in israel.
- marnett 9y agoI think GP is referencing a type of Commune, where potentially services, possessions, and responsibilities are shared amongst those who live there. America has had communes as well Communism is where all property is publicly owned and each is given what they need. A commune is a self-reliant community, likely to be small - individuals need each other. A communist state is still a state, it is not decentralized like a commune, but very centralized. Instead of relying on each other everyone relies entirely on the state.
- zzz157 9y agoFrom a certain perspective I agree, and though I am a free market capitalist to my core, the free market doesn't preclude an organization behaving in a communist fashion; the free market simply doesn't require it. I very much encourage things like this.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoYou see it in my locality, none of the local farmers own their harvesting machines, as a group they own the machinery collectively. This is still a long way from communism though.
- darpa_escapee 9y ago> There is no purpose to automation that does not exist in the service of humanity at large, but only for a few. There certainly is, to the few that are served. Increased productivity that doesn't require manpower/hours has been captured for centuries. A capitalist economy provides many incentives to privately hold productivity gains from automation, while providing virtually none to relinquish them to the public.
- ben_w 9y ago> [people] can be self reliant and exist without jobs from corporations, or help from the state. Naturally people would organise as a cooperative or a market of services, exchanging services for services, because they have little money and no corporate jobs. Yet they can work, so they can create a kindergarten for children of the neighbourhood, or a medical clinic, or a mechanic repair-shop, or a construction company, and so on. How is that self-reliant? It’s different from most of the current developed economies, but it’s still division of labour and relying on others for some things.
- vanderZwan 9y ago> Distributism (also known as distributionism or distributivism) is an economic ideology that developed in Europe in the late 19th and early 20th century based upon the principles of Catholic social teaching, especially the teachings of Pope Leo XIII in his encyclical Rerum novarum and Pope Pius XI in Quadragesimo anno. > According to distributists, property ownership is a fundamental right, and the means of production should be spread as widely as possible, rather than being centralized under the control of the state (state capitalism), a few individuals (plutocracy), or corporations (corporatocracy). Distributism, therefore, advocates a society marked by widespread property ownership. > Distributism has often been described in opposition to both socialism and capitalism, which distributists see as equally flawed and exploitative. Thomas Storck argues: "both socialism and capitalism are products of the European Enlightenment and are thus modernizing and anti-traditional forces. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism So not to be snarky, but how is this anything more than simple "Marxism, minus the parts that don't work with Catholic religion, plus Catholic religion"?
- AlphaSite 9y agoShared ownership vs individual ownership, I think?
- svieira 9y agoProperly understood, Distributism is capitalism limited by an understanding of the purpose of capital. Just as there is no mathematical system that can prove all of its first principles, so there is no system of capital that can within itself articulate a just distribution of that capital. The assertions of Distributism are that: * Everyone has a right to private property (ad contra of Marxism) * That right to private property is not absolute (ad contra of laissez faire capitalism) * Laws should aim for the maximum distribution of the means of production, rather than the optimal throughput of productivity possible with those means (ad contra of if-it-is-not-100%-it-is-not-a-monopoly capitalism) This is inspired by Catholic principles and promoted by Catholic thinkers, but it is certainly something one can come to without being Catholic.
- pfisch 9y ago
- rmk 9y agoThis is a type of utopia that many of us yearn for, but never appears to have worked at the level of large nation-states. I mean, here are some things that are not taken into account: - People who can not work because they simply can't hold down a job, period. - Externalities such as neighboring (or even distant) communes dumping wastewater into rivers etc., or polluting the ground, or air... you get the idea. What about natural calamities, such as earthquakes, tsunamis, volcanic eruptions, and such? - Conflicts over scarce resources. Water, for example. Communes that rely on a common source of water will likely have conflicts. How are they resolved? - Any commune is exceedingly unlikely to be good at producing all the things it needs. Trade will need to develop. Does 'self-reliance' exclude the possibility of trade? - How large should a commune be, to enable innovation? Without innovation, there will be stagnation that will harm the commune in the long run. - How would a commune handle people that are 'different'? How about criminals within and without?
- svieira 9y agoThis is not at the expense of the large nation state, it just limits the power of the nation, preferring to push down the responsibilities to the lowest level possible, rather than aggregating up the moment that any benefits can be found from that aggregation. We live in a world where (to quote GKC [1]): > Lancashire merchants whenever they like > Can water the beer of a man in Klondike > Or poison the meat of a man in Bombay; > And that is the meaning of Empire Day. The advantage of centralization is that we can stop the poisoning all at once (because there is only one place doing the poisoning). However, when the meat is poisoned many more people suffer food poisoning than would if the food packaging were distributed. [1]: http://www.gkc.org.uk/gkc/books/Songs_of_Education125.html
- pjc50 9y agoProbably best to distinguish between "self-reliant economically, but connected to the world economy" vs "closed system". Trying to be self-reliant in terms of physical inputs doesn't work in the oil age. Whereas the various small and micro-states manage to be economically self-reliant while importing staples. I don't think distributism requires a closed system.
- jawns 9y ago
- shams93 9y agoThe problem is around 98% of farmers have to lease their land. Most farmland in the US is owned by a handful of people.
- tengbretson 9y agoReally want to see a source on this one.
- dredmorbius 9y agoNot sure this fully backs the statistic above, but a detailed USDA report: https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/74672/60298_eib161.pdf?v=42607 https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/74672/60298_ei... It doesn't clearly state how many farmers lease land, but 39% of acreage is rented. The 98% statistic appears in the follwing item, but concerns white vs black land ownership, not rental vs. ownership: https://inequality.org/research/owns-land/ https://inequality.org/research/owns-land/
- funkulation 9y agoThis system already exists in Israel. There are Kibbutzim, full blown cooperative communities spread across the country (which were the initial backbone of the country but have decline over time). They share income depending on the Kibbutz, but some of these communities are very productive and very well off. There are also Moshavs that aren’t quite as collective but still cooperative. Everyone in the Moshav shares a fixed piece of land in the community but production and income is controlled by the individual laborer. However, the community will still share costs together, like machinery, supplies, marketing of output. Both are 70 year+ running models and proven to be successful no reason they can’t everywhere else.
- analog31 9y agoThe earth can't physically support the existing human population without great cooperative ventures such as the production of electricity and nitrogen fertilizer. It can't support life at anywhere close to the present day level of prosperity without additional great ventures such as transportation, medicine, telecommunications, money systems, and electronics manufacturing. All known means of operating those ventures depend on the state, including the entitlements granted to corporations. Giving up these ventures would require such a massive reduction to the quantity and quality of human life, that it would be unacceptable to the vast majority of people. The Haber process ended humanity's hopes of creating a society based on self reliance.
- stale2002 9y agoBy every possible quality of life metric, things have been getting better and better for humans. People have predicted the population bomb many times for hundreds of years, and every time they have been wrong. Scientists predict human population to peak in 2040 anyway. I think that we can make it till then. The world supports the current population quite well, right now.
- analog31 9y agoI hope I wasn't predicting a population bomb. What I was suggesting was that the existing population level is sustained by organized human activity at a scale that can't be managed by independent individuals or small groups. Thus a proposed restructuring of society requires a credible plan for maintaining or replacing some specific activities such as the Haber process.
- NotUsingLinux 9y agoIt's interesting to see your thoughts on UBI, how you connect it necessarily to the state. I think this doesn't have to be the case: https://joincircles.net https://joincircles.net I am also very much in favor of distributed, self reliant communities. Yet I want to preserve the advantages of a global linked economy. I hope that Blockchain technology will help us to achieve this. I tried to capture some of the thought vectors here: https://gist.github.com/AndreasS2501/2dc6c5813f5fd8abc79aad44479843be https://gist.github.com/AndreasS2501/2dc6c5813f5fd8abc79aad4...
- larsahlstrom 9y ago"If people own land" I limit my comment to that. Truth is that.. 1. Your military secure the borders of what all knows as USA. 2. You have defined land area. 3. And you have a certain number of people living there within. Now divide your lanarea with number of people, and see how much land everybody has the right to. You cannot OWN land. You can secure it. To OWN lan you have to have a proof of origin of the land. Nobody has. As the land is much older than your relatives way way back. People try to avoid this and manipulate "laws" to be able to own land, which is just criminal. Your land should be owned by all of you. It is a fedaral issue. A State defines often as something evil. Thats the rich 1%'ers propaganda and thei dreams. A State in you case is Federal USA. And it should keep records of the land, and everybode should arrend, hire, their birth right. It is simply only that way you can "own" land. You may find this rediculous... but it is the truth. In my country there is 9 million people on a secured land of 445000km2. Gives me about 10 footbolls field side by side of land. I also have kid and a wife that has the same as I. If the world would be managed by the truth.