3 ms·
> The culprit is the numbers themselves, not the lies that augment them, nor the profits made in doing so. The only reason there can be a market, let alone a bl
by danso 9y ago
> The culprit is the numbers themselves, not the lies that augment them, nor the profits made in doing so. The only reason there can be a market, let alone a black market, for social-media engagement is because these services are marketplaces of attention, not of ideas, products, or services. That’s why Twitter counts followers, likes, retweets, and all the rest so prominently. If the numbers were less visible, or entirely hidden, everyone might live more meaningful, more productive lives online, using posts as means to ends rather than as circulations within the system.
Sorry, I haven't had my coffee this morning, but this reads as eloquent but blathering nonsense. What kind of marketplaces for ideas are there that don't intrinsically involve a competition for attention? Twitter is far from perfect but that doesn't mean that all the numbers that users accumulate are as fake as the author's own following.
There is something rich about someone turning up his nose toward the vanity of social media, while publishing his screed in a mass-market publication in which his byline comes attached with a resumé worthy blurb ("He is the Ivan Allen College Distinguished Chair in media studies...His latest book is Play Anything) that links to his Twitter account.
- danso 9y agoAnd also, the opening paragraph is the height of privilege: > In the summer of 2015, the game designer Bennett Foddy and I were sloshing down cocktails while waiting for prime dry-aged rib-eye steaks in Midtown Manhattan. We weren’t living large, exactly, but we did pause to assess our rising professional fortunes. Among them, both of us seemed to be blowing up on Twitter. “Where did all these followers come from?” I asked. We’d both added tens of thousands of apparent fans over the previous year or so... > ...Even so, their effect was real: Foddy and I looked far more popular and important than our cronies. A colleague of Foddy’s at New York University, passed over by Twitter for such largesse, had become so agitated that he’d cornered Foddy to ask if he was buying followers. The whole matter was a Pandora’s box that I kept carefully hidden and firmly closed. I don't mean the bit about chowing down on steaks in midtown Manhattan, but that the OP just seems to accept his placement on Twitter's recommended-follow list to be status quo or destiny or based on merit. He continues to muse about how he gets to keep his "phantom following" even after Twitter fixed its recommendation algorithm. If social media followings are as fake and meaningless as he tells everyone else it is, he doesn't provide a compelling reason why he hasn't shed his early largesse, which would be easy enough to do by deleting and then recreating his account.
- IncRnd 9y ago> And also, the opening paragraph is the height of privilege: > I don't mean the bit about chowing down on steaks in midtown Manhattan, but that the OP just seems to accept his placement on Twitter's recommended-follow list to be status quo or destiny or based on merit. Actually, it's the opposite of privilege. The entire article is about fake followers being common amongst accounts.
- thefifthsetpin 9y agoThere would still be competition for attention. If I want my ideas propagated, then I want lots of real people actively reading my tweets (or re-tweets of my tweets). Fake followers do not read my tweets, and by and large nobody reads what they re-tweet. Their only use is to put a big # on my profile. Removing that prominent # only breaks twitter for bots.
- mattgreenrocks 9y agoIt'd be neat if Twitter started not displaying the vanity metrics for awhile just to mess with people.
- platinumrad 9y agoIan Bogost is probably the worst regular contributor to The Atlantic and I say this as someone who probably agrees with his broader point at least half the time. Aside from having an insufferably pretentious writing style, he frequently cherry-picks examples or falls back to meaningless vagary when trying to support his sweeping proclamations or edgy contrarian assertions. I recommend reading just about anyone else.
- gaius 9y agoHis book “Racing The Beam” is very good, tho’
- snowwrestler 9y agoMost marketplaces for ideas do not intrinsically involve a competition for raw quantitative attention--i.e. a single metric like raw numbers of viewers or minutes of attention (or in the case of Twitter, followers or retweets). Most marketplaces for ideas, historically, have measured success with a more complex function that also included qualitative assessments of who heard the idea, when they heard it, and what they did with it. For example classical music and jazz are never going to get as many listeners as popular music. That's not what success looks like. Going back a few hundred years, it didn't even really matter if the audience liked a piece of classical music, as long as the artist's patron did. What is fake is the flattening of the metric of success for every single person or idea into the same 2 or 3 numbers. The Atlantic is a pretty well-known magazine, sure, but it does not command nearly the aggregate attention that The Voice, a TV singing competition on NBC, does. But Twitter (and other social media platforms) invite us to directly compare the two without further context.
- walterstucco 9y agoThe most important metric for me already exists It's called Google analytics on my website, instead of an opaque counter on a private - somewhat shady - business web site