5 ms·
Performance and features. In single threaded performance, Apple's A chips are way ahead. That's because Apple highly customizes and optimizes their core designs
by simonh 9y ago
Performance and features. In single threaded performance, Apple's A chips are way ahead. That's because Apple highly customizes and optimizes their core designs, while Qualcom and Samsung use largely vanila ARM reference designs with maybe a few tweaks. Apple chips also have considerably more cache. That's difficult for the competition to counter because they are very price sensitive and cache size eats up expensive die space.
The counter argument is that the other systems make up for this by having more cores, which is really a cop out. Single threaded execution has a far more direct effect on user experience, gaming performance, etc. They can't compete in core engineering so make it up by slapping on more fairly generic cores. It does appear that Samsung is responding to this and investing in more advanced core designs.
The final area is custom features like the neural engine behind real-time face recognition, real time 3D face lighting effects and such. The competition don't really have these at all, so we don't know how far behind they are.
There's a pretty good article on this linked below.
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4138071-apple-cpu-advantage-revisited https://seekingalpha.com/article/4138071-apple-cpu-advantage...
- servitor 9y agoThe Samsung M1, M2 and soon the M3 are all fully custom.
- simonh 9y agoYep, it does look like Samsung may be in a position to catch up soon. That could make a real problem for Qualcom the other Android manufacturers. Samsung are the biggest manufacturer of high end Android phones. If Qualcom can't sell high end CPUs to them any more, it might make manufacturing any truly high end CPUs uneconomical, or at least drive up costs even further.
- servitor 9y agoWatch out for what comes out of ARM Austin. Their last core was the A72 from a couple of years ago. Rumour has it they've been working on a big core to better compete with Apple and Samsung. Looking back, it makes sense that Qualcomm discarded their underperforming custom design efforts (at least for the mobile market). If ARM can deliver a competitive design, why not fully commit to their roadmap and save significant amounts on R&D costs?
- sydd 9y agoBecause if ARM cannot deliver they are fucked.
- hinkley 9y agoA lesson Apple learned at the hands of Motorola. I sometimes wonder how much of It Just Works was influenced by having slower machines. When doing everything takes longer, if you do it right the first time then it’s still faster than doing it twice.
- akvadrako 9y agoARM is not just one company - it's a semi-standard.
- Shikadi 9y agoWould you mind backing up your claim? To my knowledge, ARM is one company that licenses their designs to other companies, who are free to parameterize and modify as they please.
- kingosticks 9y agoI don't know what the above comment was referring to but they are more than what you describe. I'd submit AMBA as an example of this; I've seen this tech utilised by IP for ASICs that don't actually contain any ARM processor cores themselves. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Microcontroller_Bus_Architecture https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Microcontroller_Bus...
- protomyth 9y agoI think the idea is that it probably matters very little to Apple or Samsung or any other company that has an architectural license how well the ARM originated core performs because they are building their own core and ARM is basically a standard committee to them. Obviously companies that are using the actual ARM cores care about ARM's ability to perform.
- strictnein 9y agoApple made the decision to pursue performance at the cost of device life.
- boznz 9y ago>Performance and features. I think both these metrics are now adequate, battery life is the single metric I am interested in now.
- abritinthebay 9y agoBattery life is, realistically, part of performance- it’s just “per watt”. Apple is also a leader in that area as well.
- bitmapbrother 9y ago>That's because Apple highly customizes and optimizes their core designs, while Qualcom and Samsung use largely vanila ARM reference designs with maybe a few tweaks Here's the Anandtech article on the "few" tweaks Samsung has made to its 6 wide decode custom M3 cores in the upcoming Exynos 9810. https://www.anandtech.com/show/12361/samsung-exynos-m3-architecture https://www.anandtech.com/show/12361/samsung-exynos-m3-archi...