3 ms·
> I would argue also that no one has proven that it's efficient at preventing terrorist attacks. What if arrests in terrorist investigations are kept under wra
by Cthulhu_ 9y ago
> I would argue also that no one has proven that it's efficient at preventing terrorist attacks.
What if arrests in terrorist investigations are kept under wraps though? If the public would hear of thwarted terrorist attacks on a regular basis, either they'd feel more and more unsafe - that is, the terrorists win - or the terrorists find out about other cells and find ways to circumvent detection.
- ChrisSD 9y agoSo arrests but no trials? Or are the trials secret too?
- mseebach 9y agoNeither. Successful anti-terrorism is about nipping this stuff in the bud before the potential perpetrators get close to having specific plans. You can easily think of tactics that would disrupt recruiting, financing and supply chains quietly, all the way down to simply having a "friendly" chat with someone (and/or their mother). The extend to which this happens and to what degree surveillance helps with this is difficult to ascertain, of course.
- naasking 9y agoHumint is always more effective than sigint at these efforts. Far too much noise in the former case.
- naasking 9y agoTerrorists would quickly know about other cell failures if no attacks ever succeed, so they would already be changing their game. Constantly thwarting attacks would also increase confidence in the effectiveness of these measures, not decrease them. If there was evidence to speak of, we would have seen it by now. The arguments in favour of surveillance are smoke and mirrors.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIf we were catching terrorists on the regular with programs enabled by these sorts of laws you can bet your ass they'd be trotting out each and every one of them in front of the press while singing praise to the dragnet programs that made it possible.
- nkkollaw 9y agoSince that seems to be a popular excuse to start wars and otherwise-unacceptable laws, I doubt they're doing that. Fear is pretty good for politicians.