3 ms·
The claim isn't that slaves weren't involved? The very first thing you see when loading the page is "Who Built the Pyramids? Not slaves.". Later on, the artic
by perl4ever 9y ago
The claim isn't that slaves weren't involved?
The very first thing you see when loading the page is "Who Built the Pyramids? Not slaves.".
Later on, the article says (of Lehner): "He has found the city of the pyramid builders. They were not slaves."
Near the end, it says "Slaves or not, as the last season of his dig began, Lehner still did not know where all the workers slept."
So I think my original comment was salient and reacting to how the article actually presented things. It makes clear statements that slaves weren't involved. Then it leaves the possibility open at the end. It's common in many articles to overstate a claim in the beginning to grab readers, and I don't care for it.
- pluma 9y agoSurely "slaves built the pyramids" implies that at least the majority of people involved were slaves. The article inverses that simplified statement, implying the same caveat: at least the majority of people involved weren't slaves (though some might have been). If slaves were present in the society, it's absurd to interpret a blanket statement like "not slaves (built the pyramids)" to imply no slaves were involved, especially when it's a direct response to the blanket statements "the pyramids were built by slaves" (which noone would take to mean that no non-slaves were present anywhere near the construction site -- it's a given that someone would need to oversee the slaves somehow). But we're literally arguing over semantics. Unless you assume that all generalisations are always intended to be understood 100% literally and that archeologists would want to express 100% confidence in knowing exactly what group in society each person involved in a construction project thousands of years ago belonged to, there really isn't anything worth arguing over. General ignorance has it that the pyramids were built almost entirely by slaves. This article claims that is not the case. Everything else is just fluff to make for a better read.
- alasdair_ 9y ago>Surely "slaves built the pyramids" implies that at least the majority of people involved were slaves. If I heard "structural engineers built the suspension bridge" I'd simply assume they were involved, not that they were physically responsible for over 50 percent of all tasks.
- bufferoverflow 9y ago"structural engineers built the suspension bridge" is a false statement though. Engineers don't build generally, they engineer.