10 ms·
A man accused of cheating at video games may lose his Guinness World Record
- stefs 9y agoi've never played the game, but if it's on mame, wouldn't a simple evolutionary search yield good results?
- warp 9y agoI really enjoyed watching Ben Heck trying to get a faster score with the help of Todd Rogers using simulated inputs? on the real hardware: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfXwSYzEjcE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfXwSYzEjcE
- awesomepantsm 9y agoWith only 5.1 seconds of input, you could brute force it if you really wanted.
- EtDybNuvCu 9y agoCould you? The game runs at NTSC rates, which we'll round up to 60Hz. We'll also say that 6s of inputs need to be considered, and scores which are above 6s will be discarded. We'll finally say that the possible input states consist of the joystick in either left ("shifting") or neutral ("popping") position, and the gas button either up or down. This generates four possible input states. The number of possible input states in total will be 60 * 6 = 360, and so the total input space is 4 * * 360 = 2 * * 720, which is a little big for brute-force exploration. Many of these states suck; after all, the total number of shifts is not ~300, but ~5. So a guided search is likelier to pay off. Edit: Thanks HN for eating asterisks and having no math mode.
- taneq 9y agoThere's brute force and then there's brute force. You know that the joystick inputs have to be applied in a certain order, and you basically want the throttle on unless you're above a certain RPM, so the search space is more like 60^4 with a couple of parameters, which is plenty tractable.
- FroshKiller 9y agoI think the maximum polling frequency on the 2600's joystick ports is only 30 Hz.
- sp332 9y agoThat depends if the best result is similar to a bunch of slightly less-good results, or if the best is a wild leap that doesn't look anything like other good results.
- NietTim 9y agoGood!
- woliveirajr 9y ago> Beyond the software analysis evidence, which speaks directly to Todd Rogers’s Dragster 5.51 score time I didn't understand this sentence: it means that, looking at the code and calculating all possibilities of gear changing moments, it would be impossible to achieve 5.51 ? If so, why would any other evidence be necessary ? Or, if it wasn't such analysis (and I think that this one would be definitive), why wasn't this one done ?
- jperry 9y agoNo, it's exactly that and it was done years ago. He's just been untouchable until recently.
- watwut 9y agoWhy was he untouchable?
- bspn 9y agoHere's some background from a TG insider: "I seem to recall Walter Day had sold the rights to TG a couple years back. I used to work for TG some years ago, but hated it. My brother I and were constantly having to fight with what I call "the old guard" comprised of record holders from the early 80's. First, they resisted every one of our innovative new ideas like speed-gaming records for consoles, and then later we discovered a lot of the records from the '80s were bogus because video proof was not required back then. The worst was "Mr. Activision" (aka Todd Rogers), where I and several others were able to prepare a case and conclusively prove Todd had been completely fabricating world records for various Atari games. To name a few: Barnstorming (2600): Todd's record, which stood for many years, was proven to be impossible once we broke down the game code and stripped the stage of any obstacles. With the stage completely blank, flying a straight line to the finish was slower than Todd's record. When we presented this evidence, we were attacked by fans and supporters of Todd, and eventually an excuse was cooked up that I lovingly refer to as "the coffee stain excuse". Yes, after being attacked and told we were clueless about how good Todd was, one of the referees covered for him and claimed the 'document' detailing his record had a coffee stain on the part where the record time was listed. Instead of throwing the record out and forcing Todd to do a legit one on video tape, they just simply adjusted the record to be MAYBE possible by adding a half-second to the time." Source: http://nintendoage.com/forum/messageview.cfm?catid=31&threadid=89222 http://nintendoage.com/forum/messageview.cfm?catid=31&thread...
- zimpenfish 9y agoAlternate link for people who can't be bothered defeating WAPO paywalls: https://kotaku.com/infamous-atari-player-gets-world-record-removed-after-3-1822511777 https://kotaku.com/infamous-atari-player-gets-world-record-r...
- danso 9y agoAlso worth pointing out the extensive writeup on Twin Galaxies (the score/records tracking site mentioned in the OP and Kotaku): http://www.twingalaxies.com/feed_details.php/87/dragster-designer-without-a-shadow-of-a-doubt-about-todd-rogers-record/1 http://www.twingalaxies.com/feed_details.php/87/dragster-des... Contains some interesting insights about the Activision's spotty history of archiving game records. The most surprising thing to me about all of this is how Dragster's creator, David Crane, feels so sure that the record is sound: "I have no doubts, then or now".
- millzlane 9y agoI find that if you right-click on the link, then open it in a private tab or incognito. It will allow you you to read the article.
- doodpants 9y agoI find that viewing the article with JavaScript turned off works too.
- Vadoff 9y agoHere's a good video summary about Todd Rogers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8e-H4sEHB54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8e-H4sEHB54
- graphitezepp 9y agoThis video stands by itself for all you need to know about the situation. It is pretty clear cut that this Rogers guy 'scum bagged' his way to his prominence when gaming was in a quite less developed state.
- xutopia 9y agoFor those who can't watch. Some games were scored in increments of 5 and he somehow got a score finishing with an 8. Many scores were ridiculous like 650000 for a game that goes in increments of 100 and the second highest video verified score was in the 90k range. Then the fact that all his records were referee verified instead of video verified. The referee is serving a sentence for child rape. Then there is the lie about the videos being taken by the police department and never returned which was proven false by a call to the police department. Then the fact that the record holder had direct access to the Twin Galaxies database and ent3ered his own records though he says he only did it once.
- danso 9y agoIronically, in the case of the Dragster record, his exact time does match the nature of Dragster's clock being only precise to 3/100ths of a second: > Despite Omnigamer’s claim, as previously mentioned, Activision supposedly had created a machine-assisted run that determined 5.54 a perfect score, which is .03 better than Koziel’s model, thus making it impossible in his determinations. Crane explained to me that the “Dragster timer is .03 seconds per tick, so the difference that is being discussed is one tick of the game clock in a record set 35 years ago.” http://www.twingalaxies.com/feed_details.php/87/dragster-designer-without-a-shadow-of-a-doubt-about-todd-rogers-record/1 http://www.twingalaxies.com/feed_details.php/87/dragster-des...
- unreal37 9y ago
- bbarn 9y agoSo, is the opinion that he just fabricated the photo, or that he had a knack for figuring these glitches out? Because as far as I know, glitching things is considered all well and good with speed runners, and lots of his other high scores imply some kind of glitching or another.
- jerf 9y agoGlitching is not universally considered "well and good" by speedrunners. There are multiple categories. Claiming you have a glitchless run that uses glitches is cheating. You may also run in a category that permits certain glitches, in the no-holds-barred category that must be run on real hardware, or the tool-assisted category, or any other game-specific category. Same deal. This is the current state of the world. 10 years or so ago and before, there was a much stronger presumption of glitchlessness. Though you'd still encounter the problem that rigorously defining "glitch" can be quite challenging.
- tomku 9y agoTwin Galaxies is notorious for banning glitches completely and it's one of the many reasons the speedrunning community abandoned TG. If he glitched, his runs would be invalid by TG's own rules. As far as glitching in speedruns nowadays, it depends. You play by the rules of the category you choose to run, which may allow no glitches, some specific glitches or all glitches. To give an example, let's take a look at a popular speedgame, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time[1]. The "Any%" record, meaning beating the game with all glitches allowed, is 17m09s. The "Glitchless" completion record is 3hr48m38s. Categories like "No IM/WW" and "MST" are glitch limit categories where specific glitches are banned and the times are intermediate between any% and glitchless. Less-popular games will have fewer categories, but if there's interesting glitches, there'll usually be at least "no/few glitches" and "more/all glitches" categories. [1]: https://www.speedrun.com/oot https://www.speedrun.com/oot
- xamuel 9y ago>banning glitches How can you even define glitches? In the original Super Mario Brothers, you could dash and then crouch and then slide through narrow tunnels while crouching. It wasn't documented in any official manual or anything, but everyone did it. Is that a glitch?
- fortythirteen 9y ago"It's unethical!" cried the group so obsessed with protecting those in their inner circle that they regularly find loopholes to keep from recognizing legit records. There are some good mods at TG, but I find that many, if not most of them, treat it like an elite social club instead of the supposed impartial record authority that they promote themselves as.
- Jeema101 9y agoOne thing that has maybe not been considered is that the Atari 2600 is susceptible to what's known in the online Atari community as 'frying', whereby cycling the power off and then back on very quickly while the console is running can lead to weird changes in the program state. Not saying this is what occurred, but it could be a possibility, depending on the code...
- xamuel 9y agoReminds me of a controversial technique discovered in the TAS community. Start saving your savefile, then cut the power mid-write. Usually creates a savefile with a bad checksum, but with certain timing on certain games, can result in playable corrupt savefiles which can be used for a faster win. One of the reasons this idea is so controversial is the TAS community always assumes games should be played frame by frame, but this technique would open sub-frame "gameplay" (timing when you cut the power with much higher precision)
- nightcracker 9y agoI used to do something similar as a kid, cloning Pokemon in Pokemon Gold by turning off the Game Boy mid-save.
- lovehashbrowns 9y agoThere are some games where you can modify the program state to glitch to the end, like Super Mario World: https://youtu.be/vAHXK2wut_I https://youtu.be/vAHXK2wut_I The explanation for the glitch is really interesting. But something like this has to be given its own category. There's a Super Mario World category that allows for that "Credits Warp" glitch. The other categories have different rules for what you can and can't do. So it's possible that Todd did something funky, but that would still make his scores illegitimate.
- dkonofalski 9y agoWhile that could be a possibility, that would still invalidate his score. It needs to be a full run and the game resets its memory at the start of each attempt so there'd be no way to start a new attempt with a "fryed" console.
- xelxebar 9y agoThis reminds me of the slimy feel I get about Billy Mitchell every time I see a video of him.
- vanadium 9y agoReportedly, that's just a persona and he amped it up for the King of Kong film. But I definitely get where you're coming from.
- acomjean 9y agoThe King of Kong film makes him look bad. He clearly fills a kind villain role. In the movie extras he's seen delivering a Q-Bert machine to a excited senior citizen so she can practice for a tournament. Seemed oddly out of character from the way he was portrayed in the movie. I don't know him personally, but he keeps showing up at video game events and clearly is enthusiastic about them.
- throwaway675309 9y agoThe movie definitely makes him look a bit mustache-twirling Bond cartoonish but I've seen him at things like the Southern-Fried Gaming Expo and he does come across as pretty conceited.
- CrystalLangUser 9y agoTwinGalaxies had quite the extensive writeup on Todd's various cheating [1]. There was a staggering amount of evidence, including TAS (Tool Assisted Speedruns) proving that Todd's time is physically impossible. That blew up in a 274-page thread, but ultimately I believe it took Robert T Mruczek's writeup to finally ban Todd.[1] Not surprising as Mcruzek is part of the "old guard". I think this reflected very poorly on TG and I have no intention of using them in the future. [1]: http://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/175364-Dispute-Dick-Moreland-Atari-2600-VCS-Dragster-NTSC-Game-1-Difficulty-B-Fastest-Time-Player-Todd-Rogers-Score-05-51?p=945909&viewfull=1#post945909 http://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/175364-Dispute-Di...
- dmix 9y agoWhy does it reflect poorly on TG? > Todd's "Dragster" performance is one that I have qualified as being one of the top five video game performances of all time within multiple forum posts and in several interviews. I'd be curious to know what the other 4 performances were.
- s4vi0r 9y agoBecause they accepted beyond ridiculous scores without any real proof, or even skepticism? In like every game this dude has a record in his score is impossibly higher than 2nd place. And these aren't even games or records which have been around for a couple weeks so that you can argue there's room for improvement.
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoWait what? I was with you until the last line and now I'm confused. Why does this reflect poorly on TG if they removed it when there was good evidence it was false?
- nightcracker 9y agoThey have fabricated records and turned a blind eye for decades to Todd's outrageous 'records'.
- madshiva 9y agoOk guy, Todd say : "that he wasn't starting at first gear but second". I'll try to do that and hope restore some easy juding. Do you dumbly follow rules if you need beat the time? No you start to dig solution. Pretending that it's not possible is easy, doing it is a lot harder. Finding a solution that nobody has taking in count, and that you win 0.1 secondes why he even need to justify this? to give you his trick? I can totally agree with other cheats that he propably did on other game, but this is not relevent if he cheated on these, because the subject is this score not every score. It's like you will be a cheater your whole life because you cheated at a family party. Once upon a time, I have finished mario bros 3 with one life, I can't do this again, and I was at level 2-2 or 2-3 with no warp zone near me. No way to prove that, but I know that I have make it.
- wnevets 9y ago>Rogers’s record on the classic Atari arcade game Centipede, for example, had been listed on the Twin Galaxies site as being 65,000,000. The second-highest score, 58,078, barely comes close Wow and nobody thought that was a bit suspicious?
- BoiledCabbage 9y agoI don't follow this stuff, but Twin Galaxies deserves zero respect after this. To be considered a reputable organization and not even question scores like this is laughable. And there were multiple this absurd.
- fortythirteen 9y agoYet try to submit legitimate high scores as an _unknown_ and you'll find them repeatedly dismissed on "technicalities". Many of their arcade "high scores" for lesser known titles are easily broken by someone practicing for less than a week, but happen to be long held by TG regulars, with hundreds of "high scores".
- hanasu 9y agoTo be fair, many of those games are rather uncommon and may just not accessible for public play by anyone. TG arcade scores must be done on original hardware. So some scores are a testament to rarity more than anything. Particularly on the MAME (emulator) side of arcade scoring - on a previous incarnation of the TG website, the rules for submission to a game were not public until a score had been submitted for that game. Some folks with many high scores were simply submitting any score at all so that others could even play along.
- hanasu 9y agoMost, if not all, of Todd's scores were entered by a single referee. At the time, each 'platform' (console, computer, arcade etc.) had its own referee that would verify scores. That referee clearly was not trustworthy. However, Todd's scores were as equally valid as any other score on the site - all verified in secret by a single other human. There has been years of doubt about Todd's scores, among those by other gamers. TG was recently purchased by a new owner. That new owner launched a 'dispute' system whereby any score could be challenged and examined by the community. There was never a formal process until now that would have allowed for this, regardless of how many doubters there were.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 9y agoInteresting article. For as long as I've been playing games there have been people claiming they did things which seemed unlikely if not impossible. However, given today's cycle accurate simulators and computation power it seems like you could certainly answer the question of whether or not the software would ever get to a certain point.
- 534b44a 9y agoThe referee that decided most of the scores in prison for 30 years, he was a very close friend to the cheater [1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8e-H4sEHB54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8e-H4sEHB54