4 ms·
When people first started discussing which codecs to use on the web a decade ago, the argument made for the MPEG-LA stuff was that a) we're better, b) we're rea
by jcranmer 9y ago
When people first started discussing which codecs to use on the web a decade ago, the argument made for the MPEG-LA stuff was that a) we're better, b) we're reasonably priced, c) we're already everywhere in hardware, and d) you don't have to worry about the patents because we've got you covered. Ultimately, they won on that basis. However, when HEVC rolled around, that argument was destroyed by the multiple patent pools, and the consumer groups for the patents were pissed off enough to make competitive alternatives.
I suspect that he believes that the perpetual funding stream of ever-better patents is needed to fund the research for ever-better codecs (which, as you say, is disputable but not unreasonable). I also suspect that he would argue that some of the problems of the protection racket amounts to a necessary evil (a protection racket does give you a viable means to combat submarine patents). However, the AV1/HEVC situation undermines these arguments, and this is someone who realizes the gravy train is running out of rails and is desperate to keep it from derailing instead of bailing while he still can.
- djsumdog 9y agoSo how does this work out fee/patentwise in the OSS world? I know ffmpeg/libav can play HEVC/x265 streams (or at least mpv can). Can it not encode to HEVC? Or do the fees start to apply when you start distributing content? Or is it like mp3 where fees are only attached to hardware encoders/decoders (which gets all iffy because where do you draw the line between hardware sold for encoding/decoding that has software codecs on it vs general purpose OSes with the same codecs?) And doesn't Firefox have some special deal with Cisco to use their x264 decoder on the web?
- TD-Linux 9y agoffmpeg just ignores patent licensing - you're responsible for paying the appropriate licensing fees if you use it. The same applies to x264 and x265. Generally the pools won't go after ffmpeg itself but rather companies shipping it once they get big enough / have money. For example: https://github.com/mbebenita/Broadway/issues/124 https://github.com/mbebenita/Broadway/issues/124 HEVC is currently literally impossible to license. One of the pools hasn't decided on pricing yet. You basically have to set aside some cash and hope it's enough to back-pay once they announce the pricing. But even with the existing ones, you have to pay for encoders, decoders, and videos encoded in it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Efficiency_Video_Coding#Patent_license_terms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Efficiency_Video_Coding#P...
- icebraining 9y agoThere's no special deal per se, Cisco released OpenH264 for everyone, and it can be used royalty-free as long as you only use the binaries (instead of the source): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenH264 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenH264
- Retric 9y agoI don't think we need better codecs, video resolution increases slower than hardware and networking speeds. So, complete stagnation is viable.
- phkahler 9y ago>> So, complete stagnation is viable. If you consider compression from an information theory point of view, for any given measure of "quality" there is theoretically a limit to compression. It's not clear where the limit is, or how close we are to it, but because it does exist stagnation is inevitable eventually. As it gets harder to make gains it will become less of a business proposition and more of a research/academic thing.
- Kushan 9y agoResolution isn't the only part to consider, the amount of detail you can store in that resolution can differ widely. With the push towards enhanced colour spaces, higher framerates, etc. there's plenty of need for better compression technology. Besides, for a company like Netflix or Youtube, shaving 5% off the file size without a drop in quality can literally mean millions of dollars saved per year.