4 ms·
One's (monetary) value isn't defined by one's amount or intensity of labor, but rather by the value lost should one be removed from the equation. Factory worker
by airstrike 9y ago
One's (monetary) value isn't defined by one's amount or intensity of labor, but rather by the value lost should one be removed from the equation. Factory workers can be replaced by virtually anyone else (and often by machines) while Hedge Fund traders / managers often cannot.
While algorithms are increasingly prevalent in Wall Street, at the end of the day there's a human who either writes them or reads their output before making a decision, and that person is not easily replaceable.
Beyond that, for every successful Hedge Fund there are countless that failed catastrophically, so any analysis of "how much a Hedge Fund manager makes" is subject to severe survivorship bias. [0]
The disparity between the CEO of a public company and its hordes of workers is even clearer. Very few people possess the combination of skills that make a high-caliber CEO successful, which is why very few people are rewarded like them. LeBron James also doesn't work 1,000 times harder than a factory worker.
Finally, it's worth remembering that 70% of wealthy families lose their wealth by the second generation, and a stunning 90% by the third. [1] I wouldn't lose any sleep over rich kids who feel troubled about their "entitlement".
[0] https://xkcd.com/1827/ https://xkcd.com/1827/
[1] http://time.com/money/3925308/rich-families-lose-wealth/ http://time.com/money/3925308/rich-families-lose-wealth/
- lovich 9y agoI'd have to disagree with your point about CEO's having rare skills. CEOs appear to not be rated against anything. you have giant failures like Yahoo under Mayer or the executives at Toys R Us giving themselves bonuses as they are going through bankruptcy. Instead of not getting compensated for their failure they are getting amounts of money that most Americans could retire in. When the business does well people say it's due to the CEO, but when they fail people argue about how bad it might have been. There's no way to know. It seems more like a scam vs investors or employees than some measurements skill that actually merits compensation
- Banthum 9y agoWe don't know how Yahoo would've done under someone else. It could've been much worse. It's perfectly possible Mayer did unique work that paid her compensation and much more in savings. Without the counterfactual, we cannot judge her.
- zimpenfish 9y agoHaving worked there, I think any CEO would have struggled. It was a mess of middle management and "clever people" fiefdoms run rampant.
- lovich 9y agoThis is exactly the argument I am talking about. It's fine that we can't judge CEOs, but then why are they taking home millions of dollars? If we can't judge them for failures then we shouldn't be able to judge them for successes as well and they shouldn't be able to pull out the "rare skills" argument
- airstrike 9y agoThey are taking home millions of dollars because the owners of those companies want to pay them as much, and they have the final say over how much to pay.
- airstrike 9y ago> When the business does well people say it's due to the CEO, but when they fail people argue about how bad it might have been. Do you have any data to back that up? In the meantime I'd rather believe the null hypothesis that CEOs are blamed for bad performance just as often as they are commended for successful results.
- Retra 9y agoCEO pay has been skyrocketing not because they have gotten more important, but because they're all sitting on each others' boards giving each other pay raises and because CEO pay is public knowledge, they just go back to their board and say "look what I'm now worth." It is a regulatory problem and a power problem. It is laughable to think people have that much extra value. Those are teachable skills, and the cost of that education is not nearly as much as is being spent.
- cimmanom 9y agoAnd someone who's been working in fast food since high school to support their family is unlikely to have the chance to get the education necessary to become a hedge fund manager, nor the connections to help them get their first interview if they do manage to get that education. Even if they have an equal or greater aptitude for the work than the kid who's about to matriculate to Yale with tuition and expenses paid in full by his well-connected family. This cartoon illustrates it well: http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/the-pencilsword-on-a-plate http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/the-pencilsword-on-a-plate
- airstrike 9y agoRight, and that's not something we can fix entirely. We can, however, empower kids and foster an environment that is at a minimum good enough to let them achieve more than their parents did. Regardless of the causes of such inequality, the fact is the CEO is more prepared than the janitor and is paid more accordingly.