2 ms·
The crisis is simple, MPEG rarely cared to make royalty free standards, except may be in the case of DASH. So this is now haunting MPEG tech in a big way, since
by shmerl 9y ago
The crisis is simple, MPEG rarely cared to make royalty free standards, except may be in the case of DASH. So this is now haunting MPEG tech in a big way, since free codecs are replacing patent encumbered ones for various technical and financial reasons. DASH counter example itself demonstrates it, since it's adopted by big users just fine.
> The situation can be described as tragic.
I'd call the situation liberating. Tragic for parasitic patent aggressors, but great for actual technology progress. Choose what you prefer.
> AOM will certainly give much needed stability to the video codec market but this will come at the cost of reduced if not entirely halted technical progress. There will simply be no incentive for a company to develop new video compression technologies knowing that it assets will be thankfully – and nothing more – accepted by AOM for use in its video codec.
That's false, because instead of patent trolling, proper company would be adding resources to the common pool, benefiting in result from it. I guess the author finds the concept of collaboration to be foreign, but it actually pushes progress much faster than patent driven pocket lining.
> Can something be done?
MPEG can fix it going forward, and push for royalty free / patent unencumbered technology only.
- clouddrover 9y ago> MPEG rarely cared to make royalty free standards, except may be in the case of DASH DASH is not royalty-free: http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/DASH/Pages/Intro.aspx http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/DASH/Pages/Intro.aspx
- shmerl 9y ago> DASH is not royalty-free It is, the above is just a list that trolls are assembling to intimidate others. They have it on many thigns, including established royalty free codecs. If they sue someone with it and prove in court they actually own patents on DASH - then it will be another story. Until then - intimidation doesn't equal ownership. In this industry, such intimidating tactics (very protection racket and mafia like) are commonplace. Check the story how Qualcomm and some others tried to intimidate Opus project.
- clouddrover 9y agoYou can't just dismiss it and hope that it is. The MPEG LA has been successful with their other patent pools. They've got a good chance of being successful with this one as well. That's what happened to VC-1. Microsoft tried to release VC-1 on royalty-free terms but the MPEG LA formed a patent pool and then it was no longer royalty-free.
- shmerl 9y ago> You can't just dismiss it and hope that it is. Probably not. The better way is to do a review and have ready rebuttals of fake patent claims. I didn't exactly look into how it was done for DASH, but its big users like YouTube and Netflix should have done it. > The MPEG LA has been successful with their other patent pools. And completely unsuccessful with many others. There was the same type of list put out by MPEG-LA trolls for VPx, and I remember there was research published that debunked it all. So there is zero trust in anything that MPEG-LA say, but surely having concrete defense is a good thing.
- clouddrover 9y ago> There was the same type of list put out by MPEG-LA trolls for VPx No. They didn't succeed in forming a patent pool for VP8 or VP9. It was one of their "pools in formation" but was never established. The DASH patent pool is beyond that stage.
- shmerl 9y agoWhich doesn't make it any more valid. But I agree that big players like Google and others should spend resources on preventive defense and debunk all that in advance. And if they'll fail, there should be some concerted effort to make a patent unencumbered alternative.
- tinus_hn 9y agoMPEG LA has been succesful similarly to why Netflix and the iTunes Store were succesful: make it easy and affordable to comply. On the other hand suing costumers who torrent movies was not succesful at all.