3 ms·
Have we had the conversation yet about the politeness of not trying to hunt down someone who quite apparently does not want to be found? I feel that there's no
by Waterluvian 9y ago
Have we had the conversation yet about the politeness of not trying to hunt down someone who quite apparently does not want to be found?
I feel that there's no value to trying to figure out his/her identity other than personal gain at his/her expense. It doesn't help us collectively.
- ImSkeptical 9y agoI thought the same thing. It's not just impolite, there are safety implications as well to being revealed as a potentially really rich person. Plus, the person "identified" may or may not have the resources to defend themselves.
- devereaux 9y agoI had made a post about that when the story was flagged and no comments allowed. I reposted it a minute ago. TLDR: It is at best disrespectful, at worst could cause great harm to this person. We have a few heroes - the kind of persons who can disable by themselves a botnet that was hurting the NHS. We repay them by exposing their identity. https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/6bcerj/doxing_the_hero_who_stopped_wannacry_was/ https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/6bcerj/doxing_t... Satoshi is one such hero - he gave us technology that will help people secure property rights, with lack of trust of hostile goverments. Think what you want about crypto. It is a technological solution to a social problem. Once again, some people think hunting our heroes is acceptable. Personally, I find that disgusting. Some people say we have to few nice persons, to few heroes. If this is the kind of negative feedback they receive, I think I know why.
- krapp 9y ago> Have we had the conversation yet about the politeness of not trying to hunt down someone who quite apparently does not want to be found? This is the internet... no one is afforded the luxury of anonymity when the hivemind takes an interest in them.
- bb88 9y ago> Have we had the conversation yet about the politeness of not trying to hunt down someone who quite apparently does not want to be found? I'm going to take the con or anti position here. 1. People who commit crimes should be exposed. (Not saying Satoshi has, but answering your question generally) 2. People who engage in public discourse, should not be expected to have their identities remain private. 3. People who potentially have billions of dollars (whether realized or not) should also not expect privacy. > I feel that there's no value to trying to figure out his/her identity other than personal gain at his/her expense. Factually incorrect. If I can find out who Satoshi is, I can create a web page and sell ad space on the web page. That's value -- in the best kind -- economic value. And economic value can be more than just personal gain, it can create jobs for others. > It doesn't help us collectively. We can ask if he thought about the side effects of Bitcoin while developing his algorithm. E.g. money laundering, increased energy demand for little economic gain, etc. And interestingly, Bram Cohen has also recently came out with another version of Bitcoin with an algorithm better than PoW. [Edited to clarify economic value]
- Waterluvian 9y agoThanks for taking the con position. Here are some of my thoughts. Re: #3. I don't understand why being wealthy means you cannot expect privacy. Re: creating a webpage: that's what I meant by: "other than personal gain". Ie. if you can figure it out, you can profiteer. Re: asking about side-effects. Yes, fair enough. There are certainly some academic benefits of knowing who it is. You might be able to pressure them into answering questions. Though I think it's implicit that if the individual does not want to be found, they're unlikely to suddenly be welcoming and happy to answer questions.
- bb88 9y ago> I don't understand why being wealthy means you cannot expect privacy. The more wealth, the deeper and more heinous one's crimes can be. It's not that Satoshi would fund a terrorist organization, because I find it unlikely he would do so. But he is just a few clicks away from sending his bitcoins to ISIS, say. And if he did that, wouldn't you want to know who he is? Law, like programming, is defined by the corner cases. Laws aren't written from the perspective that 99% of people are good. They're written from the perspective that there's 1% who aren't.