5 ms·
> AOM will certainly give much needed stability to the video codec market but this will come at the cost of reduced if not entirely halted technical progress. T
by clouddrover 9y ago
> AOM will certainly give much needed stability to the video codec market but this will come at the cost of reduced if not entirely halted technical progress. There will simply be no incentive for a company to develop new video compression technologies
I don't think is correct. The driver for innovation in video compression technologies will continue to be the practical problems of encoding and distributing video. The quest for smaller video file sizes while maintaining quality is what has driven the development of VP8 to VP9 and now to AV1. Smaller video file sizes directly help reduce the costs of companies like Google, Amazon, Netflix, Hulu, Apple, etc. and I don't see that changing any time soon. There will be an AV2 eventually.
- gok 9y agoSure a company might want to fund development of a proprietary way to reduce their costs but why would they want to make that available to their competitors in a global standard for free?
- Jonnax 9y agoSo they can get adoption in the market? For example you need hardware acceleration for it to be a feasible alternative on mobile.
- clouddrover 9y agoBecause they need their video to play on other company's devices. Netflix and Google want to use AV1. To make the best use of it they want it supported on as many phones, TVs, computers, tablets, etc. as possible. This "coopetition" is good for everyone.
- sigstoat 9y agothey need good decoders, and acceptable encoders to be free, to spur adoption. they can try to keep an advantage by not releasing their most cutting edge encoder.
- trothamel 9y agoAren't the browser vendors the gatekeepers here? As long as there are browsers that are given away for free, the decoders would be have to be made also. And if the browsers refuse to add a decoder unless encoding is also patent-free, then we have free codecs.
- gsnedders 9y ago> As long as there are browsers that are given away for free, the decoders would be have to be made also. Or have major platforms (realistically, Windows, macOS, iOS, and Android) ship decoders at the platform level, and have them ubiquitous enough. This is, ultimately, how we got H.264 decoders commonplace in browsers. That said, Firefox held out for a long time with H.264, and only once it was clear it was costing them users did they give in and add H.264 to the whitelisted platform codecs exposed.
- lawl 9y ago> That said, Firefox held out for a long time with H.264, and only once it was clear it was costing them users did they give in and add H.264 to the whitelisted platform codecs exposed. But even then MPEG (LA) didn't really make any money out of that because IIRC they pulled a hack where Cisco is providing a decoder binary, which they distribute. But the license fee has a cap which cisco was already almost at anyways, so that didn't cost cisco much. Then they have (had planned?) reproducible compilation. So the decoder is open source, but you're not allowed to ship a binary that hasn't been compiled by cisco, but you can always verify the binary cisco provides matches the source code, as the resulting binary will be exactly the same if your compile it yourself. Cisco essentially sponsored an open-source royalty-free decoder here. So yeah, they gave in, but MPEG got nothing from them. Good. Fuck MPEG LA.
- clouddrover 9y ago> IIRC they pulled a hack where Cisco is providing a decoder binary OpenH264 is only used for WebRTC and, importantly, there's no AAC support (which doesn't matter for WebRTC because you can just use Opus). Firefox uses the OS platform's H.264 decoder for video element playback. > which cisco was already almost at anyways, so that didn't cost cisco much It apparently cost Cisco quite a lot more in licensing fees but they considered it worth it for the sake of integration with their video conferencing hardware. See the comments to this blog post from Monty Montgomery for some discussion on it: https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html?thread=439550#cmt439550 https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html?thread=439550#cmt...
- nitwit005 9y agoBecause a lot of companies pay costs on products they don't control. A company like Netflix generally has to store their movie files in multiple different formats to support all the various different devices that are out there. If they want to improve the format, they need everyone else on board.
- guelo 9y agoYes. This is the lie of software patents. That somehow without thousands of lawyers and corrupt business contracts engineers will stop innovating. We don't need them.
- ryandrake 9y agoIt's the lie of intellectual property in general: Without a way to own ideas and inventions, and control how others use them, nobody will invent or create new ideas.
- Ace17 9y agoThe actual lie of "intellectual property" is that such a thing exists at all.
- rayiner 9y agoIn many areas, engineers need to get paid to innovate. Dating back to at least the standardization of CD-ROM, that was mediated through the use of patents. Note that until recently, there was almost no open source development of media codecs. Today, there is an advertising and entertainment industry generating huge surpluses that can also bankroll engineers to develop codecs. I’m not convinced that this is a better model.
- vetinari 9y ago> Note that until recently, there was almost no open source development of media codecs. Vorbis was released in 2002. That's 16 years ago. That's hardly 'until recently'.
- icebraining 9y agoAlso FLAC and Musepack, which I think are even older. Plus for video, Theora's initial release was in 2004.
- 9y ago
- genericpseudo 9y agoThis means that codec development makes no sense for anyone who doesn't own either a large distribution platform or a large playback platform. (Much of the research has been done by middleware companies attempting to tax the two; their business goes from royalties to work-for-hire, at best, which is way less attractive for them). This is fine – in a macroeconomic sense – but of course it sucks if you're one of the companies being disrupted.
- didibus 9y agoWouldn't academic research still persist? Or has that also moved to a can't patent or profit from it, no interest in furthering research mindset?
- wahern 9y agoBy that logic Free Software wouldn't exist, not to mention codecs like Vorbis. The logic of software patents systematically underestimates the existing incentive structures. That's because of the simplifications economists usually make. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assume_a_can_opener https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assume_a_can_opener) The assumptions underlying patents become less justifiable as 1) the pace of innovation in an industry increases, compounding first-mover advantage; 2) complexity increases, because integration of an invention into a viable product becomes much more difficult--often such that copyright and other IP protections alone are more than sufficient to provide a moat; 3) as financing becomes cheaper and potential markets larger the time horizon for and amount of ROI demanded by investors diminishes; Those are especially applicable to many modern high-technology industries, software (Silicon Valley) and industrial (SpaceX). Other industries have proven to be able to thrive without strong patent protections or even copyright protections for myriad other reasons. The fashion industry has thrived without strong patent or copyright protections, largely based on trademark and marketing. Likewise for the beverage industry and consumer foodstuffs more generally. Major automakers had poor copyright protections, and while they had stronger patent protections, as safety regulations increased they shifted to a market segmentation model such that the big auto manufacturers often freely license patents among each other long before the patent expires. Economists, especially conservative economists, often argue against anti-trust, reasoning that as markets become larger (finance markets, consumer markets, etc), the typical lifetime of a monopoly become shorter--often shorter than the typical lifetime of anti-trust litigation. I would argue that as markets grow larger and more fluid they're far more capable of discovering and leveraging sufficient incentives to support innovation in the absence of government-imposed monopolies. Especially in the realm of software, the circumstances where there's a legitimate market failure requiring patents are so uncommon that there's no reason to even entertain the notion of a software patent system. In the absence of _manifest_, _systemic_ market failures, patent advocates make the same mistake Communists make--an inability to imagine how a market can support an endeavor is not evidence that a market is incapable of supporting that endeavor; it's merely evidence of one's own lack of information and imagination. And the surest way to introduce market failure is by dangling the prospect of government-imposed monopoly rents, artificially increasing the opportunity costs of discovering and leveraging all the non-obvious incentives that naturally exist or could evolve.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI agree it isn't correct, the implication is that the only "value" that generate new codecs is 'money for royalties.' There are many reasons for developing better codecs, whether they perform better on hardware, they allow for more channels in a pipe with fixed bandwidth, or optimize the viewing experience for particular types of signals. When I read the reference post I heard the echos of rationalizations that have been used for years and years to justify applying rents against someone else's labor. I can only hope that the author is correct in that this rent seeking behavior has become unsustainable. That would be a good thing indeed.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nightcracker 9y ago> AOM will certainly give much needed stability to the video codec market but this will come at the cost of reduced if not entirely halted technical progress. There will simply be no incentive for a company to develop new video compression technologies. And nothing of value was lost.
- chrisseaton 9y agoRight - it's patently false. If there was no incentive to develop new video compression, then why would anyone pay someone else to develop new video compression (buying licenses) either?