3 ms·
I don't want to get lost on terminology (what is more fundamental, what do we call a physical change...). I try to understand the consequences of the approach y
by kgwgk 9y ago
I don't want to get lost on terminology (what is more fundamental, what do we call a physical change...). I try to understand the consequences of the approach you propose.
In 4.1 you look at a couple of similar examples that are quite simple, a particle/detector system in the first half ("measurement") and a particle/particle system in the second half ("entanglement").
The "measurement" part starts like von Neumann's measurement scheme, which is a two step process. In the first step, one assumes that the "target" and the "probe" are composed into a single quantum system (there is entanglement like in the particle/particle system considered later, I agree with that). This system is in principle in a superposition of states, the density matrix does contain interaction terms.
In the second step, one applies a non-unitary operator to actually take the measurement at the classical/macroscopic level and the interference terms dissapear. Instead of a pure quantum state we end with a diagonal density matrix representing a mixed state (the system is either in one state or the other, we don't know which one but we know the corresponding probabilities).
I still don't understand how the second step works in your approach and why do the interference terms vanish.
I understand even less how do you conclude that "the entanglement destroys the interference in exactly the same way (according to the mathematics) that measurement does." The entangled pair looks identical to the pre-measurement target/probe pair, but interference is still present at that point (and vanishes because of the measurement, whether or not we call this the collapse of the wave function).
By the way, in the video there is a slide saying that the resulting wave funtion is |ΨU |^2 + |ΨL|^2 but that's not a wave function.
- lisper 9y agoYou are talking about the math, and I'm talking about what happens physically. As an analogy, this is like talking about whether F=G * m1 * m2 / r^2 is an accurate mathematical model of gravity in the weak limit (it is) vs talking about whether earth is actually pulling you down towards its surface (it isn't). But since you are obviously well versed in the math, I suggest you read the Cerf and Adami paper that my presentation is based on: https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605002 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605002 Also, Zurek's work on decoherence. Those will probably answer your questions better than I can. I'm just a popularizer, not a physicist.
- kgwgk 9y agoI was trying to find what does happen physically according to you. For the time being, you've only explained what does not happen ("measurement does not cause the collapse of the wave function", "When you measure a particle, nothing happens to that particle as a result of the measurement."). Reading your paper I thought something happened, somewhere in the transition from page 6 to page 7, because I understood that you were getting a well-defined value out of the measurement. The paper you linked now makes clear that in this model nothing happens at all, ever. Anything less than the wave function for the whole universe is just an illusion, there is no classical world. It's not an accident that your description looked like the standard measurement scheme from von Neumann, as they are just reproducing it. They seem to think that when von Neumann described the measurement process as an interaction of two quantum systems he didn't notice that this interaction was beyond the classical concept of correlations, and this is why he needed a second stage to perform the measurement and collapse the state vector. In the pre-measurement step, the 'target' (system to be measured, with states |u> and |d>) and the 'probe' (quantum detector, with states |+> and |->) are combined. This system will be a superposition of the states |u,+> and |d,->. The density matrix includes the diagonal terms |u,+><u,+| and |d,-><d,-| and also the diagonal terms |u,+><d,-| and |d,-><u,+|. Von Neumann introduces a projection step which keeps only the diagonal terms. The resulting density matrix is no longer a pure state but a mixed state (for a closed system, pure states correspond to eigenvalues of the density matrix and then a diagonal matrix has to represent a classical mixture of the corresponding pure states and cannot be a superposition). After the measurement following von Neumann we have a statistical ensemble of the possible outcomes and choosing one of them doesn't pose any conceptual problem. Cerf and Adami avoid the second step by taking the entangled system, ignoring the state of the target and looking only at the probe. Mathematically, one obtains a reduced density matrix by tracing out one subsystem and the result is a diagonal density matrix which contains only |+><+| and |-><-| without any interference terms. However, this is an improper mixed state and cannot be interpreted as before (because it's not the description of a full system but the result of looking at a subsystem). Their reduced density matrix does not represent a defined (but unknown) state because the subsystem remains entangled with the rest of the system (target+probe). They say that the full system continues to evolve in a unitary way without any kind of collapse, but then how is any measurement done at all? Their description of the detector is an (improper) mixture of |+> and |->, at what point do we get one or the other as a result? Note that Cerf and Adami consider their model completely unrelated to Zurek's. Decoherence and einselection are interesting, provide a physical mechanism to explain how the interference terms become (close to) zero in the "correct" basis in a (practically) irreversible way, and have some experimental support. But it doesn't completely solve the problem of measurement: how does the system settle on one particular outcome?