4 ms·
TL;DR unions, shady contractors and expensive project requirements in no particular order. Edit: Was this not an accurate summary of the key issues mentioned?
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
TL;DR unions, shady contractors and expensive project requirements in no particular order.
Edit: Was this not an accurate summary of the key issues mentioned?
- homulilly 9y agoSpecifically bad union rules. European countries also rely on union labor and don't have this problem. Another factor mentioned in the article is poor management which seems to be a common theme in America.
- ng12 9y agoWhat do Europeans do differently? In the US the non-corrupt unions fade to obscurity.
- rebuilder 9y agoI wonder if it's that European unions have long had legitimate political clout, while it sounds like in the USA, unions have been under more suppression, and have developed tactics to match? This is entirely based on my thoroughly unresearched preconception of the matter, BTW.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWhen I look at Germany it looks to me that both sides are more reasonable and try to find compromise. In the US either employers want to squeeze all they can out of the work force and get rid of unions or the unions get greedy (see police unions who happily bankrupt municipalities for their pensions). Maybe it's a reflection of the "winner takes it all" political system.
- rebuilder 9y agoI'm reading these articles and wondering: why do these unions have rules for e.g. the number of workers that must be posted to a specific task? Safety? It seems like a tremendously inflexible way to go about it. I'm genuinely curious btw. I wouldn't be surprised to hear it's a counterreaction to historically irresponsible employers, for example, but I do wonder about the rationale behind U.S. union rules as reported.
- bhhaskin 9y agoIt is because they are so corrupt. It has nothing to do with safety 99% of the time, but ensuring they need more workers on the job site. The mob got heavily involved with unions in the USA fairly early on, and influenced their tactics to what we have today. Europe didn't have that same issue.
- wahern 9y agoI can't find it ATM, but recently there was a good article that linked this phenomenon to the disappearance of unions. As unions disappear in the private sector they become increasingly dependent on the public sector to employ their laborers. Because union members vote and because unions so visiblly represent the working-class, in many cities the best way to be pro labor is to support union labor. In areas were unions are strong but increasingly relegated to public sector work, that translates to pressure to bloat public sector projects with union labor. One way to think of it is as a form of work program. On a related note, some conservative commentators have pointed out recently that if you combine U.S. healthcare spending with U.S. welfare spending, it roughly equates to what European countries spend on healthcare + welfare. IOW, we don't overspend on healthcare so much as we trade-off social welfare spending for healthcare spending. Similarly, I wouldn't be surprised if you combine the overspending on public works projects with similar jobs programs, it would likewise roughly equate to what European countries spend on public works + jobs. IOW, public works projects are expensive because we refuse to adequately fund training, long-term unemployment benefits, etc. I think this is all comes down to Americans' inability to embrace the necessity and role of social welfare programs. But because we can't admit of the need doesn't mean our society doesn't ultimately respond to the need; our response is just obscure and indirect in a way that preserves the fantasy of the free-market. For example, we can blame these excessive public works projects on "corruption" and "bloat" rather than admitting that they're pressure-relief valves for legitimate political, economic, and social demands. Something similar could be said regarding the Trump phenomenon.
- rebuilder 9y agoThank you. This was exactly the kind of I-never-would-have-looked-at-it-that-way answer I was looking for.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thebradbain 9y agoI don’t know enough about the topic to discuss the last two, but unions don’t intrinsically slow down metro development: France, for example, has one of the largest transport/trade unions (CFTD and CFT) and much stronger union laws than the US. And yet Paris has the second busiest and comprehensive metro in Europe, second only to Moscow. Not to mention how clean it is compared to anything in the US, a beautiful feat of design, architecture and engineering on its own, even! [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Democratic_Confederation_of_Labour https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Democratic_Confederat... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Métro https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Métro
- bsder 9y agoUm, the article in no way supports the first two as the primary problem. And, I would also like to point out that the cost per mile drops dramatically as the NUMBER OF MILES goes up. Note that most of the foreign projects mentioned are 3+ miles. And note that even the US projects which are longer magically cost less. So, perhaps the issues are: 1) a mayfly has an attention span longer than the average US voter and so getting projects approved and committed to for long durations borders on impossible 2) most contractors understand that their funding could be pulled at any time due to the vicissitudes of said mayflys, so they book as much revenue as possible and do as little work as they can until the pressure becomes overwhelming and the voting public is actually COMMITTED to funding and completing the project